4 ms·
Going beyond "surface diversity" makes no economic sense for a profit-making institution. You need some kids from "tough backgrounds" and ethnic minorities to
by notahacker 14y ago
Going beyond "surface diversity" makes no economic sense for a profit-making institution.
You need some kids from "tough backgrounds" and ethnic minorities to convince your sponsors that their financial support is breaking down barriers, but you wouldn't want to spend money traipsing across the country mopping up all the "rough diamonds" to replace the regular upper-middle-class kids that don't need scholarships and are probably more likely to complete the course and leave a lavish endowment afterwards.
- spacemanaki 14y agoAren't all the ivy league schools (and most if not all prestigious universities) non-profits? I assume they have a bit more to their mission than just investing in alumns who will generate returns in the form of endowments.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoJust because it's a non-profit doesn't mean the institution isn't out for all the money it can get its hands on. It means that there aren't owners who are able to get the profits distributed to them in some form. But having more money rolling in means a lot to the careers of college leadership, even if they don't own the university - they can expect more prestige and power, distributing travel grants to faculty in the underwater basket-weaving department and whatnot... and generally buffing their resumé in case any other interesting college wants to hire them away.
- bsenftner 14y agoSorry, but "non-profit" does not mean altruistic. It's an exploited tax dodge a huge proportion of the time. Just look at the huge salaries in any successful non-profit, and you know they are not what they position themselves as.
- binxbolling 14y agoThis is not even slightly accurate and I hope most people can see your post as the trolling that it is.
- wallflower 14y agoIt has been argued that Harvard is basically an unregulated hedge fund attached to a university. http://www.cnbc.com/id/100291522 http://www.cnbc.com/id/100291522
- jseliger 14y ago>Aren't all the ivy league schools (and most if not all prestigious universities) non-profits? Yes, but nonprofits still act like businesses with the exception that they don't return money to shareholders. I'm part of a grant writing consulting firm and wrote a blog post inspired by a previous HN post like yours: "Why Nonprofits Are More Like Businesses Than You Realize" (http://blog.seliger.com/2012/09/02/why-nonprofits-are-more-like-businesses-than-you-realize/ http://blog.seliger.com/2012/09/02/why-nonprofits-are-more-l...) that explains what working with and around nonprofits is like.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoHere's a question, though. If you went to a public university gathering at one of these universities (students, profs, administration, whomever you prefer) and - without connecting it to the school's extant practices - proposed that the university undertake a course of action... Do you think that they would agree with you, or protest loudly that such a thing is ideologically invalid and that you're a horrible person who deserves to be shunned for the rest of your life and possibly longer?
- swampthing 14y agoOnly if you assume that the bright kids from "tough backgrounds and ethnic minorities" are less likely to succeed than dimmer non-minority rich kids. Which could be the case, but might not be. Because if it's not, and those bright kids end up being successes, it could very well be in the long-term interest of a profit-making institution to make sure those kids are alumni. Not just for any possible donations, but for maintaining your prestige.
- viscanti 14y agoThere's an interesting phenomenon that happens in the US. Upward social mobility almost never happens, but in the rare instance when it does, those examples are given as proof of the "American Dream". The book Ain't No Makin' It (http://www.amazon.com/Aint-Makin-Aspirations-Attainment-Neighborhood/dp/0813343585 http://www.amazon.com/Aint-Makin-Aspirations-Attainment-Neig...) does a good job of explaining the sociological issues. It's a fair assumption to say that bright kids from "tough backgrounds" are less likely to succeed. That's not on an individual level, but on a national level it's certainly true. For most, these are kids who saw their parents work hard and get nowhere. That's a special kind of demotivation that's difficult to shake by the time college rolls around. It's also why there's almost no upward social mobility in the US.
- mikecane 14y agoI haven't read that book. I recommend: Limbo: Blue-Collar Roots, White-Collar Dreams http://www.amazon.com/Limbo-Blue-Collar-Roots-White-Collar-Dreams/dp/0471714399 http://www.amazon.com/Limbo-Blue-Collar-Roots-White-Collar-D... EDIT to add: $25.52 for a Kindle book (Ain't No Makin' It)?! So the people who would be interested in perhaps reading it are screened out from affording it. Insanity.
- mindcrime 14y agoIt's also why there's almost no upward social mobility in the US. What's your basis for claiming that? It doesn't jibe with available data. See: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-viewpoint/011110-517702-how-media-misuse-income-data-to-match-their-preconceptions.htm http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-viewpoint/011110-51... or http://www.creators.com/opinion/thomas-sowell/dangerous-demagoguery-part-ii.html http://www.creators.com/opinion/thomas-sowell/dangerous-dema... or http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/Documents/incomemobilitystudy03-08revise.pdf http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/Documents... Quote: The key findings of this study include: There was considerable income mobility of individuals in the U.S. economy during the 1996 through 2005 period as over half of taxpayers moved to a different income quintile over this period. Roughly half of taxpayers who began in the bottom income quintile in 1996 moved up to a higher income group by 2005. Among those with the very highest incomes in 1996 – the top 1/100 of 1 percent – only 25 percent remained in this group in 2005. Moreover, the median real income of these taxpayers declined over this period. The degree of mobility among income groups is unchanged from the prior decade (1987 through 1996). Economic growth resulted in rising incomes for most taxpayers over the period from 1996 to 2005. Median incomes of all taxpayers increased by 24 percent after adjusting for inflation. The real incomes of two-thirds of all taxpayers increased over this period. In addition, the median incomes of those initially in the lower income groups increased more than the median incomes of those initially in the higher income groups.
- rurabe 14y agoIf you think of kids as investments, which is a very apt analogy from the perspective of these universities, the question is whether you should try to build a VC portfolio (aiming to get a few ultra-successes) or a mutual fund (aiming to get consistent growth from the majority of them). It would be interesting to see if there are any admissions departments on record with statements that map to those philosophies, and any data that shows how those schools endowments fare over time. This query completely ignores the human issue, which is significant and deserves consideration. But it would be interesting to know.