4 ms·
I don't know which country are you in, but in the US the unions is nowhere near apolitical and apathetic. The unions such as NEA and SEIU are among the most pro
by smsm42 14y ago
I don't know which country are you in, but in the US the unions is nowhere near apolitical and apathetic. The unions such as NEA and SEIU are among the most prolific political donors and most powerful lobbies, and routinely engage in both local and national politics, and any politician who wants to take on them takes huge risk.
See e.g.: http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list_stfed.php?order=A http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list_stfed.php?order=A
>>>> blacks and women worked effectively under different laws,
You know that many labor measures - like minimal wages, etc. - were taken - with wide support of unions - to exclude blacks from labor markets, and at the time were openly acknowledged as such?
See e.g.: http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2013/03/06/mandated-wages-and-discrimination-n1525477 http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2013/03/06/ma...
- seanmcdirmid 14y ago> You know that many labor measures - like minimal wages, etc. - were taken - with wide support of unions - to exclude blacks from labor markets, and at the time were openly acknowledged as such? This is one of those infamous libertarian myths formulated from taking a few past statements to represent a consensus of the time; that somehow black labor should have been cheaper than white labor if the free market was considered alone. This racist crap doesn't belong on Hackernews.
- whatshisface 14y agoI think you are missing his logic: It doesn't matter what the nonstandard group can produce, it matters what the bosses think they can produce. If I think someone is worth $4/h, I won't pay them more, even if I am wrong.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoThere are two problems here. First, the myth is widely pushed by groups with certain ideologies without much grounding in real history. They take a couple of quotes from way back when and make a sweeping generalization. But when we go back through unbiased sources, the argument falls apart; the minimum wage was mostly well intentioned. Second, that poorly educated blacks were somehow inferior to poorly educated whites is extremely racist in itself. The argument then should NEVER be "the minimum wage hurts blacks", it should rather be "racism hurts blacks". No would here would argue with that.
- smsm42 14y agoRacism hurts blacks. Minimum wage hurts blacks too, among other low-skilled workers. If you think blacks are absent among low-skilled workers - well, it must be nice living on your planet, welcome to Earth. >>>> the minimum wage was mostly well intentioned. How you then explain the quotes about "colored labor"? Ah, yes, I know - they never said that, despite the sources, evil libertarians invented that. Maybe on your planet they didn't indeed.
- seanmcdirmid 14y ago> If you think blacks are absent among low-skilled workers I said given two poorly educated workers, one white, one black. Any big delta in their treatment is due to racism, not the minimum wage. > How you then explain the quotes about "colored labor"? Ah, yes, I know - they never said that, despite the sources, evil libertarians invented that. You cherry picked your sources and then made a broad generalization. Libertarians aren't racist, they are just dishonest for using racism to further their own ends: to make the minimum wage sound like a racist plot when there is no real evidence for that.
- smsm42 14y ago>>>> I said given two poorly educated workers, one white, one black. Any big delta in their treatment is due to racism, not the minimum wage. Big delta in treating two specific workers can be due to anything, not excluding racism of course. But we weren't discussing specific people, we were discussing the fact that the unions contributed a lot to the fact that blacks effectively worked under "different laws" then whites, back at 19th and early 20th century. It is a fact, and your claim that it is a "libertarian myth" is false, and if you ask any historians knowledgeable in the subject, they will tell you that the same as I am. >>>> to make the minimum wage sound like a racist plot when there is no real evidence for that. I don't know what you call "real evidence". There are quotes from prominent labor officials. There are history books. There are articles by historians who research the question. I gave you a number of links, you can find more by simple google reseqrch on labor relations and African Americans. If you willing to deny the facts because your ideology says something you now support can not have bad roots - well, I can not help you with your willful ignorance, I can only feel sorry for you. You still know what the truth is, even if you can't admit it.
- smsm42 14y agoWhat racist crap? Black labor was cheaper, this was a fact of life, universally recognized by contemporaries. Why it was cheaper is a complex question, but I did not intend to open it, because the fact that it was cheaper was known and mentioned repeatedly. You may say it was wrong, but it still doesn't change the fact it was what it was. And because it was a fact of life, unions were up in arms against blacks "taking their jobs" and "lowering the prices" (as they are up in arms now against other non-union people lowering the prices). Of course, another solution would be to accept everybody to the union and have them receive the same wages, but for some reason (I live as an exercise to you what it was) they preferred not to go with that, and African Americans had to organize their own unions - with, of course, much less power and access to legislation and regulation - because they were frequently excluded from the white unions up to the Civil Rights era. You can talk all day long about evil libertarians but if you look it up the history of labor and racial relationships is widely available and there's no way to deny the basic fact that racism played a huge role here and unions were as racist as state officials were. See e.g.: http://www.oxfordaasc.com/oa/article/opr/t0005/e0934?p=oamonthAe0T9U5iRqSCU&d=/opr/t0005/e0934 http://www.oxfordaasc.com/oa/article/opr/t0005/e0934?p=oamon... among many other sources (really, it's just a google away). If Oxford's African American studies center is full of racist libertarians, then apparently they are much more powerful than universally thought.
- coldtea 14y ago>I don't know which country are you in, but in the US the unions is nowhere near apolitical and apathetic. The unions such as NEA and SEIU are among the most prolific political donors and most powerful lobbies, and routinely engage in both local and national politics, and any politician who wants to take on them takes huge risk. Yes. We call those kind of unions apolitical and apathetic where I am from. They don't represent the workers interests, and they don't involve mass active participation from their members (like unions of old). They just make some union leaders "political players" and "influencers". I was referring to actual militant and mass-participation (not just mass registration) unions of old. >You know that many labor measures - like minimal wages, etc. - were taken - with wide support of unions - to exclude blacks from labor markets, and at the time were openly acknowledged as such? No, I know this to be a liberal myth. For one, minimal wages were established all over the world, not only in the US. Including tons of places without blacks (or whites) or racial tensions. People all over the world have argued for, demanded, and still demand, minimal wage laws for reasons having absolutely nothing to do with some US racism issues back in the 19th century. Second, if racism was prevalent in society at large, I wouldn't expect the unions of the time to be immune to that. Unions are made of people. So they could have said the things you quote but that doesn't mean the unions are inherently racist. It just means that unions in a racist society were racist. There are also lots of wonderful examples of collaboration between black and whites, and immigrants of all races and origins, in the US labor movement. If anything, the businessmen and employers of the time were even more racist, because their interests (cheep labor, etc) depended on it. It's for business reasons that the slaves were brought to the US in the first place, after all, and it was done not by poor workers, but by wealthy businessmen and land owners.
- smsm42 14y ago>>>> They don't represent the workers interests, and they don't involve mass active participation from their members I don't know if they represent workers interests (I suppose since they insist of compulsory membership, they feel voluntary one would not work well for them) but you can certainly observe mass active participation - e.g. recall recent events in Wisconsin where the governor tried to reduce the power and the privileges of the unions. >>>> No, I know this to be a liberal myth. You don't "know" it, you think and hope it is, but if you look at the real history, then you would know it's true. >>>> People all over the world have argued for, demanded, and still demand, minimal wage laws for reasons having absolutely nothing to do with some US racism issues back in the 19th century. That may be true, but US is not "all over the world", and in this particular part of the world both unions and minimum wage laws have particular history. >>>> Second, if racism was prevalent in society at large, I wouldn't expect the unions of the time to be immune to that. I do not. You seem to, saying that the fact that unions were racist is a "myth". If you admin they were, then you can proceed to justifying it by saying "everybody did it" (which is not true too, but differently). You can not both deny it and justify it at the same time. Choose one.