2 ms·
Must be dense today, but I don't really see what the arguing was about. That the environment conditions and affects consciousness? There's hardly a single neuro
by varjag 18y ago
Must be dense today, but I don't really see what the arguing was about. That the environment conditions and affects consciousness? There's hardly a single neuroscientist who would object to that.
The analogy with car was really horrible, not to mention the point of it is unclear.
It is understandable however that many people would find the idea of consciousness as product of neural interaction uncomfortable. It strips human of certain degree of divinity. I haven't read the book, but from the article this seems to be author's major concern.
- jimbokun 18y ago"That the environment conditions and affects consciousness?" That the environment is an integral part of consciousness.
- varjag 18y agoThis suggests two interpretations for me: one is that the environment directly affects the flow, shape and composition of one's conscious experience (i.e. what I said), the other that the conscious process happens to some degree extra-corporal so to say. Maybe there's some third interpretation that I miss?
- jimbokun 18y ago"one is that the environment directly affects the flow, shape and composition of one's conscious experience" I think he is saying not just that the environment "affects" consciousness, but is part of what we mean when we use the word "consciousness." In other words, the idea that you can "see" consciousness in an MRI scan is fundamentally in error. You need to also examine the environment and context in which that scan was taken, in order to make any progress in understanding what consciousness is.
- KirinDave 18y agoEnvironment is integral to conscious in the same sense that the road surface is integral to driving. It's the medium we interpret. Despite claims to the contrary, it really seems to me like the philosopher in this article is marking territory for a turf war.
- yters 18y agoPeople think they're smart because they've "realized" that consciousness doesn't exist and substance dualism is false. But, everyone stops there and just continue to be substance dualists, or greater arity, of some other stripe. I.e. there is no consciousness but there are apples, and kittens, and rainbows, and pots of gold. The real takeaway is that NO abstract concepts exist. It doesn't even make sense to say "every thing is only itself" since this again differentiates substances of "thing" and "self."
- radu_floricica 18y agoNo no no no no. Consciousness is a process (which you probably agree) but one which involves both the brain and the environment. The car analogy isn't that bad, though it's a bit incomplete. Imagine you want to study ways to optimize traffic in a city. You can use a car in a garage, since you have all the information necessary inside it (and you do, technically). Or you can use a model of the city with many toy cars inside it. Which will help you most? It's about the level of abstraction you choose to use. And it's important not only because some models are more efficient then others, but because some models have inherent biases. In this case, considering consciousness trapped inside the skull makes it a lot harder to see things which would be obvious when defining it as interaction between brains and environment.