13 ms·
Ad industry threatens Firefox users with more ads if Mozilla moves on tracking
- arocks 14y ago> This is damaging to consumer interest and will undermine the Internet. If that is the case, then people will eventually stop using Firefox and sites will continue to put annoying popups that confusingly say 'We use cookies, do you agree?" However I doubt that is what users would prefer. I think they would prefer less privacy invading advertisements and more contextually relevant ones.
- tokenizer 14y agoThis seems like a typical response. I'm curious if Mozilla will cave or continue. While I like the idea of restricting third party cookies, I can understand the advertising businesses argument. They need to know what you want, so you can click on the ad, thereby providing a small amount of revenue to both website and advertiser.
- claudius 14y agoAnd what actual value is created by that?
- richardwhiuk 14y agoAs the article notes, Apple's Safari browser has done this since launch, and is the most popular browser on mobile. There isn't a convincing argument that's going to cause Mozilla to cave here. This isn't a bold new move - it's Mozilla following Apple's lead, given that Microsoft has caused DNT to go into a death spiral. I'm not sure why Mozilla would care about any business arrangement between some websites and advertisers.
- h2s 14y ago> They'll see untargeted ads, which will look like spam That's your loss, not mine, asshole.
- skore 14y agoA thousand times this. "Oh no! Somebody else will stop doing our job for us, the horror!". Go die in a thousand fucking fires, people working in advertising/marketing[0]. [0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDW_Hj2K0wo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDW_Hj2K0wo (edit: Jeez, hyperbole detectors seem to have a calibration problem today.)
- pud 14y agoThe irony in your comment is that YouTube exists because of advertising.
- skore 14y agoYes, it is ironic, but I could just as well have put in a quote.
- adam-a 14y agoYouTube is supported by advertising, but it doesn't exist _because_ of it. It's possible to imagine a world where users did not tolerate advertising and YouTube found their funding from user subscriptions, product referrals, government funding, or some other means.
- arrrg 14y agoSo, uhm, people working at Google should die?
- skore 14y agoYou mean just like the farmers who produce food that people working in advertising eat?
- arrrg 14y agoGoogle sells advertising space. They are a giant marketing company. And no, you cannot divorce responsibilities like that. That’s just dumb. How can you even?! How is that argumentation even possible?!
- lucb1e 14y agoSafari is already doing the same for years. This kind of privacy improvements actually make me want to donate to Mozilla to continue their efforts.
- lucaspiller 14y ago++ Chrome will just do whatever is good for Google (and hence other advertisers) unless they get pressured to do anything different. I'm glad to see Mozilla taking the user's side on this.
- efdee 14y agoI could be wrong, but hasn't this been an option in Chrome Preferences for ages?
- keithpeter 14y agoThere is also a preference in Firefox. I think the original article is talking about default settings.
- joosters 14y agoChrome eventually added the option to block 3rd party cookies, but it certainly wasn't there to begin with. I don't think the option is there on their mobile browsers either - it didn't exist on Android when I last looked, and definitely wasn't there on iOS either.
- Zirro 14y agoSafari on iOS (and the desktop) blocks third-party cookies by default.
- arrrg 14y agoIt’s a preference in every goddamn browser in existence since the beginning of time. That’s not the issue here. This is about defaults. No one cares about some obscure preference. It’s irrelevant.
- shawabawa3 14y ago> we will lose the opportunity to monitor and protect our privacy How exactly will blocking 3rd party cookies stop us protecting our privacy? I could understand if they said something like "it will stop targeted ads", but that is just clearly bullshit
- thexa4 14y agoBecause they;ll switch to different methods of tracking. For example, you can be tracked almost uniquely by the plugins you currently have installed. It's harder to mask that than to remove a tracking cookie.
- Nursie 14y agoSo we stop giving away information like that too? I'm still really not sure why my requesting information from a web server should leak any information about me beyond an IP address.
- kislayverma 14y agoBigoted idiots. This rant is surprisingly similar to press release before every western invasion of a country - freedom, threat to 'small' consumers etc. "we will lose the opportunity to monitor and protect our privacy" Really now!!! So my privacy is best served by sharing all my data? This is so Orwellian. Noam Chomsky should have something to say on this :)
- judofyr 14y agoI almost find this a bit cute: > Without third-party cookies, they will not be able to participate in the existing industry system for privacy protection. Their privacy is still protected, but they can't participate in the privacy protection system! Oh noes! > They will see an increase in the irrelevant spam advertising served to them So you're telling me that when you serve ads for "RightWingNews.com, LiberalOasis.com, MotherhoodWTF.com, and SuburbanDaddy.com [and] thousands of small businesses" there's no possible way to find relevant ads without tracking the user?
- mkmkmmmmm 14y agoUsing Firefox and AdBlock Plus I actually expect I will continue to see exactly zero irrelevant spam advertising. Still, it's funny to see the mental gymnastics going on when someone obviously wants to exploit people but does not want to admit it.
- ne0phyte 14y agoWell, there will be new ways to embed ads. Like ads between related articles or when you scroll through results and one of them has 6pt "Ad" in the corner but looks exactly like the real search results. They will find a way to make it really hard to block that stuff based on generic rules or by blocking the servers that serve the ads.
- relix 14y agoBy running AdBlock, you're the one doing the exploiting. It's no different than pirating stuff, you don't have the moral high ground here.
- af3 14y agoJust to make sure, in Chrome this option could be enabled in Preferences?
- sirn 14y agoIt's a different feature. The gist of this new behavior is a change from Allow All Cookies to Allow Cookies Only From Visited Domains. This is unlike Block All Third-Party Cookies option that existed in both Firefox and Chrome in the way that third party cookie is still accepted but only if user ever visited that "third-party" website before. The behavior may be less strict than Block All Third-Party Cookies option and probably won't make much difference for Facebook or Google's tracking cookies (if you use them). But being the new default option means smaller players going to take a direct hit. Which is good.
- jcr 14y ago> "The Internet was created on the foundations of advertising," said Jaffe. This Jaffe character is factually wrong in most of his statements, but claiming the above is wrong to the degree of at least blatantly ignorant, or more likely to the degree of willfully and maliciously misleading.
- Jgrubb 14y agoWell sure, if you're going to take it literally, the foundation of the internet has more to do with software and Linux and TCP than advertising. The fact is though, and I'm surprised to find that I must be the only HN regular who finds himself working in the world of marketing and advertising, that a hell of a lot of the internet and people working on making it better, not just worse, is paid for by advertising money. The vitriol that's on display from everybody on this thread is, in a big way, as myopic and ignorant and full of self-righteousness as the guy they're calling names (who I agree is all of the above, yes).
- johnsoft 14y ago"Some sites nowadays depend on advertising as a revenue stream," is a far cry from "The Internet was created on the foundations of advertising." Reading through http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Internet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Internet, if I had to guess what motivated the people who worked on those early networks, I would say it had more to do with the potential to advance humanity with accessible, near-instant communication than it did the ability to serve ads to people. Ads were not on anyone's mind when they first saw text appear in real-time from thousands of miles away. Ads were just a single application for the new technology, and they came about much later.
- hhw 14y agoDon't you mean BSD rather than Linux, as BSD was the reference TCP/IP implementation for DARPA?
- Samuel_Michon 14y ago“the foundation of the internet has more to do with software and Linux” Linux is barely 20 years old, the Internet has been around for decades before that. In recent years, it seems like more and more people are using ‘Linux’ in a context where they actually mean ‘Unix’. Just like the Internet and the web are not the same, these distinctions matter. “ I must be the only HN regular who finds himself working in the world of marketing and advertising” Nope, there are plenty of us here.
- sneak 14y agoThe intense pushback from the ad industry is testament to the fact that they're on the right track for user privacy. Carry on, Mozilla!
- caf 14y agoCorrect. "Henhouse security improved - foxes appalled."
- gargoiler 14y agoThat's extremely naive. You can track people perfectly well without using cookies.
- jeltz 14y agoHe said that they are on the right track. Not that this will be the only change needed to protect the privacy of the users.
- Silhouette 14y agoIn their blogs, the two groups lambasted Mozilla, predicting dire consequences, including the shuttering of small businesses and small websites, fewer choices for online users, and more ads in Firefox. Or small businesses will have to bring their revenue in by other means, such as charging real money for valuable content and services, or simply running ads themselves, targeted at their own viewers' likely interests, without relying on third party middlemen. Either of those outcomes sucks for the middlemen, but not so much for anyone else. Fortunately for the advertisers and the user-as-product platform services, micropayments are mostly still wishful thinking, so they're not likely to see this happen on a wide scale in the immediate future. But if they think small -- or even large -- businesses on the web can only survive by using their ad networks, sooner or later they're going to get a rude awakening about the sustainability of their business model. I imagine there will be some last gasp effort to legislate that people can't view sites without viewing the ads, shortly before the ad networks finally retreat into obscurity, but that's so user-hostile that I don't see it gaining much traction. In the meantime, the first team who manage to gain traction with a social network that is totally user-focused and charges a small annual fee for basic features and a few more small fees for top-ups is probably going to be very rich. And for the smaller sites, anyone with enough traffic visiting say a blog to make real money via the ad networks is probably also in a position to negotiate a direct ad deal and cut out the middleman for better returns.
- mfjordvald 14y ago> Either of those outcomes sucks for the middlemen, but not so much for anyone else. It actually also sucks for the businesses themselves, at least in my case. I'd much rather spend my time creating valuable content for everyone than creating valuable content for a few who pay me. Of course there are alternatives I can try, I can keep content free and solicit donations, I can create various merchandise or I can directly sell advertising space hosted on my own site. All these options essentially take time away from creating content in the first place. My fear is that I'll be too busy trying to make money to make good content. Ad networks at least have the benefit of a "fire and forget" and having someone manage that whole aspect of my business, leaving me to work on content. I totally get the whole point of no tracking, I'm not even really against it. I'm just trying to point out that it's not just the big business ad networks that will be affected here.
- arethuza 14y agoI've only recently installed AdBlock as, although I know advertising revenue is important to some of the small sites I use, I've been a bit perturbed as to how creepy a lot of online advertising has become. I spend a few minutes thinking about buying something (e.g. an electric raclette coooker) and for weeks I am pestered on loads of different websites about them - which I find really annoying.
- brador 14y agoAm I the only person who actually likes relevant ads? I like finding new things I didn't know existed to buy...
- awjr 14y agoThat's fine until you go to a site looking to buy something for your daughter. Suddenly the rest of my day's browsing is polluted by pink ponies.
- _delirium 14y agoI like ads relevant to the site I'm visiting. I don't like ads that try to connect to something I was doing previously. Those break my concentration, and seem somewhat trollish. E.g. I'm trying to book tickets for a trip, then I need to switch to researching something else and am blocking out the trip from my mind for a bit. It's not helpful to have your own little troll Clippy following you around the internet asking around every corner, "I notice you're trying to get work done, but what about that trip you haven't booked yet?", even when you're visiting sites completely unrelated to travel. Yeah, I know about that trip, I'm just not working on it right now, because I have other things to do, and I don't need to be reminded about it on every goddamn page I visit. It seems like the explicit purpose of those retargeting ads is to distract me from what I'm currently trying to concentrate on, by reminding me of something I was doing previously. That's not something I want, and in fact I find it quite intrusive.
- oneandoneis2 14y agoThe one thing that irritates me most about them is they aren't smart enough to STOP. Say I google "laser pen". Suddenly, I get ads about lasers! Cool! Then I buy one of these laser pens. The ads have done their job. Lucky them. But now that I've bought a laser pen, I no longer need to be shown ads for them - I won't buy another one, so for God's sake, stop showing me ads for them! Learn to know when an ad has served its purpose and move on. I did a search for "injury lawyer" a while ago, I swear it was six months before I stopped seeing ambulance-chaser adverts on every damn website I visited...
- tinco 14y ago"The facts are that [Firefox users] will get more ads, not less, and those ads will not be tailored to their interests," he said. "They'll see untargeted ads, which will look like spam."" If this is truly the case then Firefox users will notice and either turn the third party cookies back on or complain/switch to chrome. If the effect is that big, and people want to see the targeted ads, what do the ad networks stand to lose? Firefox is making a right move, there is now a distinctive conscious choice you can make: Firefox, privacy by default. Chrome and IE can never counter that (because of their affiliations with ad networks). Maybe its not the biggest reason to use a browser, but it's a big one and it enforces Firefox's position in the market.
- ne0phyte 14y agoChrome has an option to enable the Do-Not-Track request and to block all 3rd party cookies already. In the settings dialog that is, not in the chrome:// tweaks.
- Jgrubb 14y agowhat do the ad networks stand to lose? It's less about the actual ad networks. It's more that the sites who display ads that are better targeted and have a higher click through rate can charge more money for them and run fewer of those specific ads as a consequence. Businesses that are able to better target ads at people who might actually be in the market based on recent browsing behavior can spend their advertising money on reaching a higher quality audience. The alternative is that you get a spray of all kinds of ads that have no relevance.
- Kiro 14y agoI've said it before but in my opinion retargetting is a win-win-win situation for advertisers, publishers and visitors. Being retargetted has improved my online experience a lot since I only get ads I actually care about.
- wkearney99 14y agoThere's an old saying that goes "Don't piss on me and tell me it's raining." that seems applicable here. The ad industry is crying foul that a browser comes with it's own umbrella against their torrent of waste.
- EwanToo 14y agoYou can enable this in Firefox today, by going to about:config and setting the network.cookie.cookieBehavior value to 1 (0 is the default) You can also try setting network.cookie.thirdparty.sessionOnly to 1 to allow third party cookies during the session, but then delete them afterwards https://developer.mozilla.org/en/docs/Cookies_Preferences_in_Mozilla https://developer.mozilla.org/en/docs/Cookies_Preferences_in...
- huhtenberg 14y agoAlso, consider setting network.http.sendRefererHeader 1 as per discussion from yesterday on cross-domain referrer headers. See [0] for details. [0] http://kb.mozillazine.org/Network.http.sendRefererHeader http://kb.mozillazine.org/Network.http.sendRefererHeader
- qompiler 14y agoFirefox should enable AdBlock plus by default in the next update.
- scrrr 14y agoAnd that would probably increase their market share..
- Nursie 14y ago"The facts are that [Firefox users] will get more ads, not less, and those ads will not be tailored to their interests" he said. "They'll see untargeted ads..." OH THE HORROR!
- fear91 14y ago"; we will lose the opportunity to monitor and protect our privacy; " I laughed so hard at this one. Great move by the Firefox team. It made me donate for their cause.
- monsterix 14y agoGood riddance ANA/IAB. Better sense would have prevailed if you'd asked the choice been given to Firefox users to allow third party cookies if they wanted it.But no, you'd rather lash out on Mozilla. Good job - the two of you ad presidents! :)
- ginko 14y agoFirefox should include an ad blocker by default, then.
- DanBC 14y agoWhen I listen to advertisers talk I realise that I understand the individual words, but all strung together they mean something different, and reality starts to slide away until I'm through the looking glass in a weird world where "We want to show you our ads" is the same as "Why don't you want to see our brilliant content? People love those shouting smileys and buzzing mosquitoes!" Me saying "Really, I only leave ads on to give a smidgen of money to the content provider; I'd much rather make micro-payments direct" is interpreted as me being an obscure hard-line communist. I genuinely feel lost when listening to advertisers
- moron4hire 14y agoLies. It's just all lies.
- obsession 14y agoI wonder if the move to create Google Chrome was a due to a concern that Firefox would disturb Google's ad-serving business some day.
- tpetrina 14y agoThis is a battle they (advertisers) simply can't win. If they increase the number of ads for Firefox users, Firefox installation might suggest ad-blocking software to users. If we have a "browser choice screen" as a punishment for Microsofts abuse of monopoly, who can deny adding the same "choice" screen for ad-blocking software to a major browser? After all, public should be educated about ads.
- hackernewbie 14y agoThis should shove the internet into a more sophisticated mode of advertising (if more clandestine in many ways, shills ahoy). It's unprecendentedly pathetic to see companies worrying about their outmoded methods and hegemony on content choice. Imagine when content choice is purely based on relevance and recommendation (and shills).
- p6v53as 14y agoWe will soon have these ad networks to enforce us with laws that prohibit adblocks all together by calling the act of blocking ad as "piracy" and "theft" since we are not "paying" for the content provided. We can't let that happen, these networks must be put down as fast as possible till while they can't influence the government. Oh, wait, it's too late...