5 ms·
It's a shame the phrase "police state" has been so abused. But this is quite an adequate moment for its usage.
by dmix 14y ago
It's a shame the phrase "police state" has been so abused. But this is quite an adequate moment for its usage.
- ihsw 14y agoCitizens still have rights to protect themselves so we're not a police state yet, however we are driving down that road at 90MPH though.
- rayiner 14y agoWhat exactly is "police state" about this situation? Police reacted on a tip and it turned out the tipster made a mistake. I didn't get the memo that we're now calling "police state" every time the police actually do their jobs.
- joe_the_user 14y agoThe job of the police would seem to me to be "exercising appropriate discretion" rather than sending an army to any place where there's vague implication something bad might happen.
- rayiner 14y agoIt wasn't "any place" it was a school, and it wasn't a "vague implication" but a rather specific report (guy, black mask, gun) (the fact that a report is wrong does not mean it is vague). That seems to warrant a pretty serious reaction. Indeed, there was a report of a gunman in my law school a few years ago. The place was locked down, SWAT came, there was a helicopter, the works: http://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/Gunman-Seen-at-Northwesterns-Chicago-Campus-82798722.html http://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/Gunman-Seen-at-Northwes.... It's standard operating procedure when dealing with sensitive areas with lots of people.
- anigbrowl 14y agothere's vague implication something bad might happen Vague implementation: 'people get mugged down that street, I wouldn't got here after dark.' That's a far cry from 'there's a man walking around with a ski mask and an assault rifle.' Sure, it was a false positive, but that's a pretty specific claim, don't you think?
- FireBeyond 14y agoRight, as someone in Emergency Services (not Law Enforcement, and not particularly fond thereof) in Olympia, Washington, the article is a little biased: the tipster was a teenager who 'insistently and repeatedly' stated that he could specifically identify an AK-47 assault rifle when a police chopper was overhead, the man, 'in his theatrical nature', started 'aiming and pointing his umbrella at the helicopter' (as confirmed by video from the chopper) the schools -chose- to go on lockdown at the suggestion, not requirement of officers one of the schools (that my partner's daughter attends, so if anything, I'm biased towards caution) chose to go on lockdown despite being a nearly three mile walk through medium density neighborhood, and the area already being cordoned off (so of debatable necessity). "city-wide" - a very small city (population 46,000), and an area of perhaps 1 sq mi was actually cordoned off... "multi-disciplinary" - 12 units were involved, including Olympia PD and Thurston County Sheriff. Helicopter, not helicopters... There are valid fears of a police state, but when you are asking the person calling 911, "are you sure he's carrying a weapon, not a cane or similar?" and the caller says "I know guns, and he has an AK-47 with him", and the person in question pretends to take potshots at police helicopter (in the singular), there's probably bound to be something of a response.
- tikhonj 14y agoNo. Had the kid been "disappeared" and all news suppressed, "police state" would be adequate. For this? Perhaps it's plain incompetence. Maybe just an overreaction over flawed intel. Certainly nothing sinister.
- cookingrobot 14y agoIt's not even overreaction - it seems like proper reaction to flawed intel. It's like if someone falsely pulls a fire alarm, and the firetrucks speed over to check it out.