5 ms·
Please explain how this situation would have worked if, instead of Adria, the original tweeter/picture-poster had been a white, heterosexual, Protestant man.
by aaronbrethorst 14y ago
Please explain how this situation would have worked if, instead of Adria, the original tweeter/picture-poster had been a white, heterosexual, Protestant man.
- pekk 14y agowhite men are never sent death threats, are you sure?
- czr80 14y agoWhat white men never get, and this is just an observation, I have no sides or deep interest in this mess, is a comment like: "this makes me re-think hiring white men, they're not worth the drama". I've seen a few of those around the place regarding Ms Richards.
- mladenkovacevic 14y agoAlso if a man did this, it wouldn't even register on the internet's "burn-the-hypocrite" scale and I would actually be able to read something else on HN.
- vor_ 14y agoI don't really think this is a worthwhile route to go down. Someone could very well argue that if a man took a woman's picture because he overheard her making a vagina joke, it wouldn't have gotten any serious attention at all. Adria's complaint was taken seriously, at least by the conference organizers and the employer of the man who was fired, because she was a woman, and women are most often the recipient of sexism, especially in tech. Therefore, it's vital to take a stand against those who exploit that attention through their own cynical motives.
- vor_ 14y agoI don't know if anyone has actually said they won't be hiring women because of Adria Richards. What people have definitely said is that Richards may have hurt gender relations by causing male techies to be nervous around female co-workers. This was actually the most common reaction from women to this story, among those that I read. In fact, I think it's a very underappreciated aspect of this tale that so many women sided against her. A lot of them make the same kinds of dick jokes--including, as we now know, Adria Richards.
- pekk 14y agoThat's a pretty crazy comment, but should I think it represents men in general?
- Guvante 14y agoThe original tweeter made it about gender, so it wouldn't have worked the same if it were a man. The posters point is that if a man had been the forefront of a lot of news then death threats would have been thrown at him too.
- pyre 14y agoYou've never seen Anonymous go nuclear on white supremacists? Or back when they were trolling Tom Green's live web show? etc. The fact that this is a "Women in Tech" issue is what generated so much publicity, and the publicity is what draws the trolls. If two posters on 4chan's /b/ board had some exchange where one named-and-shamed the other over a penis joke, and he ended up losing his job? I don't think it's hard to imagine Anonymous coming down hard in the perpetrator, whether male or female.
- mladenkovacevic 14y agoThe difference is in the scale. I bet if you compared their campaign of "going nuclear" on white supremacists it would register but a blip compared to what's going on here. And it IS because she is a woman... and also because she's black. Those two probably each increase the measure of the e-mob response exponentially.
- pyre 14y ago| I bet if you compared their campaign of | "going nuclear" on white supremacists it | would register but a blip compared to what's | going on here. What is it that makes what's going on here worse than anything else? The DDoS attacks? The threats? The volume of threats? Has she been SWAT'd[1]? (I'm not heavily invested in this mess, so maybe I'm missing something) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting
- jimzvz 14y ago>I bet... >...probably... >And it IS... Believe it or not, your opinion isn't fact.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- randallsquared 14y agoThen it would have been about Christianity, or about how technology culture is repressed and not sex positive.
- jlgreco 14y agoProtestant like baptist or something? I guess maybe they could have stirred up some outrage from the religious crowd, over some sort of perceived religious slight? But most issues these days likely to offend fundamentalist protestants are likely to offend fundamentalist catholics too... I don't really know; what are you trying to get at?
- citricsquid 14y agoI'm a very generic white male with absolutely no real notability and because I have some degree of worth in a very small part of the internet I've had people threaten to drive to my apartment and beat me up because I did something they don't agree with -- they never do, but the threats happen. Entirely possible that Adria's gender or race contributed to this, but it definitely happens to white straight males too. You're looking at the wrong end, don't look at the victim, look at the aggressors: anonymity and distance is the cause. There will never be any recourse for those that threaten, so they'll do it until they're blue in the face.
- 650REDHAIR 14y agoAfter spending some time online I'm guessing the response would be pretty much the same, but with more "fag" comments.