4 ms·
The blog post doesn't have many details, no; but it includes a link to a court filing on scribd (http://www.scribd.com/doc/13481284/Kip-Macys-995-Absurd-Indictm
by cperciva 18y ago
The blog post doesn't have many details, no; but it includes a link to a court filing on scribd (http://www.scribd.com/doc/13481284/Kip-Macys-995-Absurd-Indictment http://www.scribd.com/doc/13481284/Kip-Macys-995-Absurd-Indi...)
which casts light on some of the allegations.
- jibiki 18y agoI'm reading through that filing, and it's not clear to me why the guy stopped paying rent, or why Macy didn't personally contact him after that. The whole story is bizarre. If Macy wanted to do things by the book, then he should have drafted a written lease, and if he wanted a handshake agreement then he should have talked with Morrow about the eviction, repairs, etc. On the other hand, Morrow is pretty obviously paranoid, and it's hard to see how the DA could have missed that.
- cperciva 18y agoMy understanding from reading the filing is that the Macys wanted to get rid of Morrow, were told that Morrow had a year to move out because he was "disabled", and paid Morrow $7500 to move. Then Morrow just, err, didn't move. I'm sure that the Macys didn't want any sort of handshake agreement with Morrow at all.
- tptacek 18y agoYou don't need to believe Morrow is a good guy to believe that the state has good cause to put Macy on trial.
- jonmatherson 18y agoActually you do. If you establish a pattern of perjury as well as the prosecutor coaching witness to hide exculpatory evidence then you have some fundamental problems with your case. The Durham NC case was not as clear cut as it was made out to be in the press either.
- tptacek 18y agoWhat you're saying is a non sequitor. I'm saying Morrow can be an abusive tenant, and the Macy's can still have committed a crime in their efforts to get rid of him as fast as they can. It is, after all, absurdly hard to shake an abusive renter in San Francisco. You're talking about prosecutorial misconduct, and in effect saying "the whole damn system's out of order". Maybe you're right, but that has nothing to do with what I just said.
- jonmatherson 18y agoThe question is the veracity of those involved. Given that Morrow's complaints are financially motivated, he has admitted that he had no right to be in the room, he never left (i.e. he did not fear for his safety), and he has perjured himself in a number of cases - it is entirely unclear if a crime actually took place.
- tptacek 18y agoIf it was entirely clear a crime had taken place, we'd be discussing Macy's conviction, not his indictment. More importantly, there are more people who's veracity you're questioning than just Morrow: the city attorney, two city inspectors, and a police officer.
- jonmatherson 18y agoYour questioning is quite justified. Unfortunately, San Francisco is on par with Chicago in terms of corruption and the way to win votes and keep your job is by siding with tenants.
- tptacek 18y agoThe evident difference between you and and me is that I won't take a generality like "San Francisco is corrupt" and use it to attempt to win any argument about crime in the state of California.
- tptacek 18y agoSo I went through the motion to dismiss --- this is a motion from Macy's own attorney, for whatever that's worth --- and what I learned in addition to what the Chron wrote is: * There's an SFPD officer who testified against the Macy's. * That city inspectors had to instruct the Macy's not to board up Morrow's windows. * That the Macy's do in fact seem to stipulate that they (or their contractors) cut triangular notches into load-bearing beams below Morrow's apartment --- "by accident". The substance of the filing seems to be that the grand jury proceedings were unfair; for instance, a grand juror made an inquiry about Morrow's mental health, exerting her own claimed expertise as a psychiatrist, and therefore that the indictment should be dismissed on a technicality. But grand jury proceedings are always unfair. The point of a grand jury is to clear a procedural hurdle before bringing people to actual trial. You have almost no rights in a grand jury. It seems premature to suggest on this basis that the Macys are victims of a miscarriage of justice.
- cperciva 18y agoMotions to dismiss are usually filed by the defendants' lawyers. :-) Other things indicated by the document include that: * There are a lot of charges which seem to have no evidence behind them aside from Morrow saying "well, I saw someone who looks sort of like one of the Macys shortly before/after something happened". * There are a lot of charges where, when they first investigated, the SFPD said "we see no evidence of any crime here". * There are some charges which appear to be based on very odd legal theories, e.g., that entering a room which a tenant isn't renting counts as burglary, or that moving an ex-tenant's property into a storage room constitutes theft. As for the focus on the grand jury proceedings: Well, that's just the way the system works. These charges were originally filed by the DA, which would have resulted in a preliminary hearing being held to examine the evidence and decide if there was any reasonable basis for the charges; but bringing the charges through a grand jury bypasses that process (since grand juries, at least in theory, won't indict someone without reasonable evidence).
- tptacek 18y agoWhen you say "room that the tenant isn't renting", you're referring to another room in the apartment the tenant was renting, not some random room in the whole building. It's worth knowing that there's a dispute about whether Morrow had any kind of tenancy in the "shared" rooms in the apartment. If I'm renting from you, and I have a bedroom, and I have a roommate, and she has a bedroom, and we share a living room, and you enter my apartment without notice and start messing around with the living room, I call the police and you get cited. In San Francisco, I get to deduct an amount from my rent if you get cited. I like that rule; so should you. Having said that: there clearly are people who abuse tenant law in San Francisco. A strong case has been made that Morrow's one of them. But even if you just look at the stuff that appears to be stipulated: that the Macy's cut the beams underneath Morrow's apartment, boarded up his windows, and cut his power --- there seems to be a real case here.