4 ms·
"By contrast alt-med is open. Anyone can learn about it. Anyone can become a practitioner. Anyone can experiment. It's also unmitigated bullshit. It's tolerant
by Nursie 14y ago
"By contrast alt-med is open. Anyone can learn about it. Anyone can become a practitioner. Anyone can experiment.
It's also unmitigated bullshit. It's tolerant of different views and opinions because none of them are based on evidence.
Alt-med is actually more free-enterprise. There is more patient choice. It's less expensive.
The 'choice' is an illusion. None of it works so sure, choose what you like. It's less expensive because it's nonsense.
The bedside manner you get...
Because it's a con game and that's all they have to offer.
- analog 14y agoIf it works it's not unmitigated bullshit.
- Nursie 14y agoIt doesn't. Do you know what we call alternative medicine that works? Medicine.
- analog 14y agoWell I know several people for whom the Paleo diet has worked, and also alt medicine. I don't know why it works but it's unscientific to ignore the evidence simply because you don't understand it.
- Nursie 14y agoAnecdotes != evidence. It's unscientific to elevate your anecdotes above actual studies because you subjectively feel there's something there. This is why we have studies. I don't know why it works but it's unscientific to ignore the evidence simply because you don't understand it. Classic. Homeopathy enthusiasts always wheel this out and it's hilarious. "Just because you don't understand how it works you shouldn't ignore it!". I don't understand how it works because it doesn't! And this has been shown over and over again! I have no idea about the paleo diet, but if it seems to do good things for people we should first establish whether that is true and then find out how it's true. Alt med always misses step 1.
- analog 14y agoI'm sorry but anecdotes are evidence, just with a very small sample size. You can keep saying "it doesn't work" as many times as you like but you'll still be wrong.
- Nursie 14y agoI'm sorry but anecdotes are evidence, just with a very small sample size. OK, anecdotes are not good evidence, and cannot be used as evidence because they suffer from nearly all the problems that a good study accounts for and real evidence gathering processes account for and mitigate. Anecdotal data suffers from confirmation bias, from selection bias, it has a small enough sample size to be meaningless, and is as a result worthless. Better? You can keep saying "it doesn't work" as many times as you like but you'll still be wrong. [Citation Needed]
- analog 14y agoRight, but if you've tried doctors and they haven't been able to help, and if you have heard of a treatment which anecdotally works, and has no reported side effects, then why wouldn't you try it. If it works for you then you still have a sample size of one but this would be good enough.
- Nursie 14y agoThat depends on what the condition is, how trustworthy the anecdotes are and how much someone was trying to charge me for it. For instance in the case of terminal cancer, some people get ripped off by charlatans to the tune of hundreds of thousands of dollars. The anecdotal data around these assholes is all overwhelmingly positive and claims no side effects, because people who are ripped off and then die tend not to talk about it but the very few who survive for reasons unknown shout a lot. The reason you might not try it is because you'd be bankrupting the family you're going to leave behind, or funneling good-will donations to a conman. There are numerous examples of alt-med 'cures' that are dreadfully harmful (black salve, sodium hypochlorite enemas). This idea that CAM is fine to try if you're out of options because it has no side effects is itself very dodgy. Hell, even acupuncture carries some elevated risk of infection because you're pushing needles through the skin. But if it was something minor, cheap and there really were no side effects, sure - why not? --edit-- But telling if there really are no side effects does require some basis in provable fact, or you're just necking unknown quantities of unknown stuff, which may not be a great plan.
- dalke 14y agoLet's say that 10% of the people who switched to a paleo diet found that it "worked". (Without knowing what "worked" means, I'll assume it's "lose weight.") If you talk to those people for whom it worked, then great! there may be evidence there. However, let's say that of the people who decided lose weight through other means (a low calorie diet, more exercise, gastric bypass, whatever), 10% were successful. With this additional information, it's hard to conclude that choosing a paleo diet makes a strong difference. In other words, looking at the success cases doesn't give a conclusion, only a possible path for followup investigation. It's unscientific to say that something "works" by only looking at the successful cases. You also need to track the failure cases (those who tried paleo but where it didn't work), and the success and failure cases for other methods. The same for medicine. If someone tries X (aspirin, herbs, whiskey, zinc, penicillin, etc.) for the flu then gets better within a couple of days, then it doesn't mean that X actually "worked". There could be other reasons for why the person got better, like the person's own immune system. (For the record, none of those 'medicines' will work against the flu, though a few of them will help relieve some of the symptoms.) That's why these anecdotal accounts, while true and even heart-felt, don't suffice to make a scientific conclusion.
- MDS100 14y agoSome things do work and are not yet accepted in medicine. Herbal medicine etc.pp. Often it's just hard to patent and/or isn't financially lucrative to get FDA approval. Also lifestyle in general is terribly handled in medicine. MDs know nearly nothing about what matters and what they should recommend. They are decades behind the available evidence.
- Nursie 14y agoSome herbal medicine may work. Without proper studies we don't know. I agree that lifestyle stuff is important, can be handled by none MD folks, and can have a huge impact on life and health in general. What gets my goat is the CAM proponents who claim they can cure anything and everything with their woo.
- MDS100 14y agoBut there are a bunch of studies on useful stuff. Inositol, Theanine etc. And we still don't do studies because interests don't align well for it to happen quickly. My point being that some Alt Med Practitioners actually help. I don't like it, because I heavily dislike the widespread incompetence about science/medicine in Alt Med circles. But it's still true. Well the MDs do give you lifestyle advice. And the "professionals" that should care about this stuff (esp. dieticians) also suck badly. They often just regurgitate the food pyramid. I completely agree otherwise.
- illuminate 14y ago"Some things do work and are not yet accepted in medicine. Herbal medicine etc." Herbal medicine is medicine. "Alt-med" is reserved for treatments that are not and will not ever be evidence-based.
- MDS100 14y agoI am on my way to my MD, I know. But in the real world people do use "Alt Med" for treatments that have shown efficacy already. It takes far longer than expected until this stuff becomes part of practiced medicine though. In the end I don't care about the label, but the evidence/science and the results.
- api 14y agoI don't disagree much on fact, but the attitude on display here is not helpful. It turns people off. There was a time when people were willing to trust authority figures and accept the advice of credentialed experts without question. That time is over. If you talk this way to people, they tune you out. Part of the reason for this is the Internet itself, and the general displacing of one-to-many communications with many-to-many communications. The medium is the message, and the message of this medium is "information is liquid, and there are no privileged points of view." But more significantly, I think people have grown fatigued with the errors and lies of experts. Experts with all the right credentials once told women to smoke. It's a great way to lose weight. Margarine was once good for you. In 2006, the worst time to buy a house in 100 years, the President of the United States stood up on stage and encouraged more people to buy homes. People are sick of it, and they're not listening anymore. It doesn't matter if you're right or wrong. The only way to get peoples' attention now is to speak to them like equals and explain yourself. Opaque statements that appeal to authority tend to be tossed in the waste basket by most educated, thinking people. The only people who are willing to "just believe" anymore are fanatics, and they tend to be followers of the most idiotic bullshit imaginable.
- Nursie 14y agoI'm not really sure I make appeals to authority, and the fact that I rip into stuff is me treating people as equals, not as fragile china dolls that need to be cosseted and persuaded with allusions to reality to persuade them down from their weird views. I'm also pretty sure you're right that it puts a lot of people off, and I'm not the right person to talk to them :) Oh and I absolutely agree that the days of listening to experts and authority figures are over. I'm not one. You'll find me the last person to say that the medical establishment has everything right, or that we should always listen to doctors because they're just so clever. I just think that most of the thought behind alt-med in its various forms is nonsense too.