2 ms·
On Windows, Chrome also deliberately circumvents the normal system security model, installing in the unprotected user directory rather than as a real applicatio
by Silhouette 14y ago
On Windows, Chrome also deliberately circumvents the normal system security model, installing in the unprotected user directory rather than as a real application in order to allow its background updates.
It also installs (silently, without permission, and for reasons unspecified) a Firefox plug-in, and it reinstalls/reactivates that plug-in even if the user has explicitly chosen to disable it.
It amazes me that Google seem to get such a free ride with Chrome. A lot of the things it does are either indistinguishable from a lot of the things that malware does or leaving itself wide open to compromise if malware gets onto a system by some other mechanism.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jmillikin 14y ago> [Chrome] also installs (silently, without permission, > and for reasons unspecified) a Firefox plug-in, and it > reinstalls/reactivates that plug-in even if the user has > explicitly chosen to disable it. Could you elaborate more on this? Most of my machines have both Chrome and Firefox installed, but I don't see any unexpected or Chrome-related plugins in Firefox. A web search for [chrome installs firefox plugin] also turns up no relevant hits.
- Silhouette 14y agoInteresting. Right now I'm looking at a Firefox plug-in called Google Update 1.3.21.135 in Firefox, which I recently disabled (again) because it offers no uninstall option. I certainly didn't put it there myself, nor have I ever knowingly approved it. I just checked, and a similar plug-in has been installed on every other machine we've got handy. Is it possible that you've got something installed that somehow blocks this? It's been happening for years for us, causing much gnashing of teeth. [Edit] Here's a link describing the plug-in: http://superuser.com/questions/156913/what-is-the-google-update-firefox-add-on http://superuser.com/questions/156913/what-is-the-google-upd...
- nivla 14y agoYou are right, I just went through my Firefox plugins and I see "Google Update" along with a few "Google Talk" plugins. Given that I installed Firefox after Chrome, could those plugins have been installed and updated with Google Talk or does Chrome have an active app monitoring in the background?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 14y agoInstalling to a user folder doesn't make the system any more vulnerable to attack. Malware could easily put itself in the same place with or without chrome. Malware can also load programs from a secure location and immediately inject themselves.
- Silhouette 14y agoInstalling to a user folder doesn't make the system any more vulnerable to attack. Of course it does: it means any malware that manages to get onto the machine running as a non-administrator can arbitrarily compromise Chrome. If Chrome were installed properly as an application under Program Files, the Windows UAC mechanism would intercept attempts to modify it by unprivileged code. Installing a general executable platform like Chrome under the users directory effectively creates a privilege escalation vulnerability.
- gizmo686 14y ago>Of course it does: it means any malware that manages to get onto the machine running as a non-administrator can arbitrarily compromise Chrome. No. The malware would need to be run under an account with write access to Chrome. Because Chrome is in a user directory, the only accounts that should have write access to it are administrator, and that same user. If malware is running as the normal user account, then it can compromise the Chrome executable, and be able to run on that same user account when Chrome gets re-run. However, this at best allows malware to turn a 1 time compromise into a persistent compromise, and even then it is an ability that the malware has anyway. Assuming that Windows has no mechanism for a user to execute arbitrary code at login (which I doubt), the malware can always replace one of the shortcuts on the desktop with a shortcut to a malicious executable, that then loads the original executable, and maintains the same icon. Granted it is harder to detect a compromised executable, but if you do not know to look, how often to you check shortcuts/login programs? The malware cannot use this for privledge escalation because the only user who should ever run the Chrome executable is the user in whom's directory the executable is installed. And this is also the only non-administrator who could have compromised it in the first place. Installing to a user directory does however prevent another type of privledge escalation, because you do not ever need the give the executable (or installer) administrative access. EDIT: I completely re-wrote this while Silhouette wrote a responce.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]