3 ms·
But the verity of the argument WRT woodsmoke speaks to the strength of the analogy. Many here appear to agree that burning of woodsmoke is not always bad [appe
by pbhjpbhj 14y ago
But the verity of the argument WRT woodsmoke speaks to the strength of the analogy.
Many here appear to agree that burning of woodsmoke is not always bad [appeal to majority!] and that the article appears# to go far beyond what there is evidence for in claiming wood burning is wrong, period. [of course that doesn't mean it isn't wrong]
Following the analogy to a conclusion on this basis says that those who appeal to scientific arguments for atheism are using poor data and over-reaching often attacking practices which don't match well with real life.
If the woodsmoke argument is poor but the analogy is sound then the conclusion is that those who light wood-fires like those who are religious are justified in rejecting this sort of "scientific position".
He's done for the anti-woodsmoke position what proving the pope is fallible does for atheism.
- - -
# I only read the snippets of the conclusions of the papers in the comments and not the actual papers.