6 ms·
Reposting and responding to a dead comment by lexarchy: -- >This is a clever hack, but I question the motives of both the father and Ars Technica. Must we era
by Karunamon 14y ago
Reposting and responding to a dead comment by lexarchy:
--
>This is a clever hack, but I question the motives of both the father and Ars Technica. Must we erase—or invert—all aspects of yin and yang, simply to appease the gods of equality?
You may have heard the French phrase vive la différence, which translates as "long live the difference", but do you know what it refers to? It means "let's celebrate the differences between the sexes." Nowadays it seems we are only allowed to celebrate their sameness, or their inversion. This makes me sad.
Vive la différence!
--
This kind of put into words an odd feeling I was having about the whole "war of the sexes" vibe that this seems to generate. I'm not sure the motives of the father or the site need questioned at all - it's a thoughtful gift to his daughter, and a very clever hack at that. Certainly worth covering in any case.
What I don't understand is how one of the most common storytelling tropes in history (we're talking Shakespeare and then some) has suddenly become uncool to use, or why we're making a harmless part of videogame history a political and social justice issue.
- mturmon 14y agoSometimes one gets tired of the same old stories, lazily retold by deep-pocketed corporations as an easy gimmick to make money. The deep-pocketed corporations always win in the end, but in the cracks, something different can flourish.
- GuiA 14y agoDonkey Kong was written by Shigeru Miyamoto, a junior developer who came from a product design background. How's that for deep-pocketed corporation? :-)
- joezydeco 14y agoMiyamoto certainly wrote the story behind the game, but he had help with the rest... http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/134790/the_secret_history_of_donkey_kong.php?print=1 http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/134790/the_secret_hist...
- healsdata 14y agoIf you'll take his word at face value, the father didn't really have any motives aside from making his daughter happy. "My three year old daughter and I play a lot of old games. Her favorite is Donkey Kong. Two days ago, she asked if she could play as the girl and save Mario. She's played as Peach in Super Mario Bros. 2 and naturally assumed she could do the same in Donkey Kong. I told her we couldn't in that particular Mario game, she seemed really bummed out by that. So what else can I do? I'm up at midnight hacking the ROM, replacing Mario with Pauline."
- derleth 14y ago> If you'll take his word at face value, the father didn't really have any motives aside from making his daughter happy. But the author is dead, so we're bound to analyze this in terms of Theory and come to actual conclusions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author (Whether I'm being sarcastic is entirely up to you.)
- qu4z-2 14y ago> (Whether I'm being sarcastic is entirely up to you.) This is the best part of the comment, even if there was a voice echoing in my head "What was the author's intention in writing that sentence?"
- shardling 14y agoBetween any two people there is such an enormous difference that I'm not very sympathetic to this argument. Let's just celebrate the real differences, and not lazily use gender/sex as a shorthand for particular social roles.
- drucken 14y agowe're making a harmless part of videogame history a political and social justice issue Who's "we"? Also, I know how the three year old feels, i.e. how sad I am when I have to play role playing games or multiplayer games as male!
- arrrg 14y agoI think it’s pretty normal if you are tired of the constant portrayal of women as weak, helpless and passive in certain media. What’s so wrong with calling out lazy storytelling based on dumb stereotypes? How can you even have a problem with that? I also like how you just declare something harmless. Why, exactly? It’s a part of video game history that lives on and is anything but harmless. Calling out crap is wrong – why exactly? Or is the portrayal of women as weak, helpless and passive – especially in a world where this is a popular stereotype – not crap? Nobody wants to burn cartridges or rewrite history or ban old games. People (for the most part) don’t even demonize anyone for this or blame anyone for acting maliciously. Is pointing something out (or privately doing something about it) really such a big deal? I really don’t get contrarians like you. Your arguments make no sense at all. (Except if you believe that women really are naturally weak, helpless and passive, i.e. hold sexist beliefs.)
- Karunamon 14y ago>What’s so wrong with calling out lazy storytelling based on dumb stereotypes? What exactly do you hope to accomplish by calling out arguably "lazy storytelling" (more like a homage to King Kong if some stories are to be believed) 32 years later? It's like complaining about racism in the early Bugs Bunny cartoons. What exactly are you hoping to accomplish other than a gripe? Damn Nintendo for using a common story trope three decades ago! What does this teach anyone? How horrible Nintendo is? What? >I really don’t get contrarians like you. Your arguments make no sense at all. (Except if you believe that women really are naturally weak, helpless and passive, i.e. hold sexist beliefs.) This was utterly unnecessary. If I'm a "contrarian", you are someone who searches for things to be offended by.
- arrrg 14y agoUhm, you do know that the trope lives on in Mario games? You are aware of that? Also, looking at history can be interesting and illustrative.
- Karunamon 14y agoYou are aware that the particular character hasn't appeared in a game since? You are aware that the trope you're referring to has been subverted, inverted, and toyed with just about every way possible by the very same company?
- columbo 14y ago> This kind of put into words an odd feeling I was having about the whole "war of the sexes" vibe What vibe? > we're making a harmless part of videogame history a political and social justice issue Who is doing that? > What I don't understand is how one of the most common storytelling tropes in history (we're talking Shakespeare and then some) has suddenly become uncool to use What are you trying to say? I thought I read a story about a dad who wanted to make a game fun for his daughter. I read the article, I read it again, yep, it's a story about a dad making changes to a game for his daughter. What story did you read?
- Karunamon 14y ago>What vibe? Have you read this comment thread? >Who is doing that? Have you read this comment thread? >What are you trying to say? That I don't understand some of the discussions (their purpose or mindset) the story is generating. I have no issue whatsoever with the story itself.
- damoncali 14y agoI don't know. I have two young daughters and they would want to be the girl character - just because. They're too small to know or care about social injustice. Sometimes, people are just having fun.
- pseut 14y agoI don't know the father's motives aside from the article, but I have a 4yo daughter and try to do whatever I can to encourage her to have, "I can change/fix that" as her first instinct when she runs into obstacles or problems. Whether there's a "war of the sexes" or not, boys are encouraged to hack way more than girls, so I'm more concerned about my daughters getting encouragement than my son (hypothetically... He's 1 so I don't really know yet). So I saw the article in that light: a father wanted to hack donkey kong so that he could show his daughter that hacking donkey kong to make the princess the hero is a totally normal thing that she should expect to learn to do as she gets older. Maybe I'm projecting too much onto the story.
- TheZenPsycho 14y ago"Father does nice thing for daughter. Internet embroiled in controversy over this bold act of political activism"
- rmc 14y agoWell one of the problems is that nearly all the stories follow that trope. What's wrong with expanding the number of stories we can tell? Why do we have to have the same story all the time? (Additionally, it's debateable if the dearth of females saving males in a genre is "harmless").