8 ms·
Some of this actually fits perfectly into the framework of Kurzweil's The Singularity in the sense that you could argue that most neuroscientists are too focuse
by joe_the_user 14y ago
Some of this actually fits perfectly into the framework of Kurzweil's The Singularity in the sense that you could argue that most neuroscientists are too focused to the complexity of the brain and aren't anticipating the progress that may be possible through rapid evolution of tools for looking at the brain.
The said, I think Kurzweil's plan for constructing an intelligence actually oversteps his basic approach. Tools are advancing on multiple fronts. Not only does that give us multiple ways a singularity could happen (from brain-simulation to simplistic-but-massive-ai to clever-ai to bio-computers) but the multiple advancing fronts could go around apart walls (a sufficiently sophisticate computer could make brain processes look less opaque etc).
Personally, I'd say Paul Allen's counter-argument, which I recall as boiling down to the inherent limits of human-produced software, is the most plausible counter-argument.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> Personally, I'd say Paul Allen's counter-argument, which I recall as boiling down to the inherent limits of human-produced software, is the most plausible counter-argument I often wonder if the ultimate end counter argument may be that the same things that make us "intelligent" are also those that give us our human flaws - exactly the same things that we were trying to avoid in the first place by using computers. Perhaps we can't have human-like intelligence without also being forgetful, inaccurate, selfish, lazy, irrational, greedy, angry, sad etc. If someone did invent a computer with all those attributes, would it be useful?
- Filligree 14y agoMost of those attributes turn out to have perfectly good explanations in evolutionary psychology. That being the case, there's no reason to expect a mind that isn't produced by the same process to possess them.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> there's no reason to expect a mind that isn't produced by the same process to possess them True ... but then will those minds be able to perform the feats of intelligence that we hope for from the "singularity"? Will a mind unable put aside the fact that valves can make a t.v. set run, unable to dream, imagine, love, and lacking the motivation of greed and competition with its peers etc. - will that mind be able to discover the transistor as an alternative? Perhaps our evolutionary psychology is part of the reason we exhibit what intelligence we have, not just an unnecessary relic of our past?
- Filligree 14y ago> Perhaps our evolutionary psychology is part of the reason we exhibit what intelligence we have, not just an unnecessary relic of our past? Dare we take the risk that it isn't?