6 ms·
No, the alternative is to have the government build subsidized housing and then enact strict price controls so that even poor families can afford to live reason
by bjourne 14y ago
No, the alternative is to have the government build subsidized housing and then enact strict price controls so that even poor families can afford to live reasonably. That's how it was done in Singapore for example and is why they can live in "spacious" 30-70 m^2 apartments despite having a higher population density than Hong Kong. See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore.
- Adaptive 14y agoYes this. The HK govt is appalling in its disregard of the poverty line. (>6yrs in HK, and I'm no SG fanboy, but it is SO far beyond HK in this, there is just no comparison)
- yskchu 14y agoCan you quantify this? HK has one of the best welfare systems in the world.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoI think the problem in HK is the number of undocumented immigrants. No papers, no open borders, surrounded mostly by water, these people are easy to exploit. I was told that many of the construction workers' (building skyscrapers) wages barely amount to the cost of the day's food.
- Evbn 14y agoIt's sort of amazing the people in these conditions care enough about quality of work to build buildings that don't fall down.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoCough, ahem, well, it was also explained to me that there may be some systematic labor-related problems with construction quality in those buildings. Not exactly related to worker pay-rate, but the gist is that they tend to pour the concrete too wet (because it is easier/faster to work). This is probably because of productivity-based bonus pay for foremen. The difference in strength isn't enough to cause a building to fail under nominal conditions, but catastrophic failure is more probable in some destructive event (weather, earthquake, explosion, etc).
- Adaptive 14y agoAn agency colleague and I did volunteer design and marketing work for a Hong Kong food bank (St. James). At the time it was one of the few food banks in HK (I don't know if this has changed or not, but I'd be surprised if it has). Part of our initial work was research and I was pretty shocked that the HK govt didn't even set a national poverty line. Given a rough line of half median income, over a million HK residents were easily below at the time. If you're talking strictly social security, even the government acknowledges it has a problem. Here's a recent SCMP article where the welfare dept itself states that at least 40% of HK residents in poverty aren't covered by welfare. http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1062025/700000-slip-through-hong-kongs-welfare-net http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1062025/700000-sl... (mirror: http://goo.gl/GxyTw http://goo.gl/GxyTw ) The good news is that the HK govt did, finally, just implement a standard poverty line (half median income). This is the first step and a long time in coming.
- wilfra 14y agoI disagree it is the governments job to give people a place to live. From the sounds of it, Hong Kong already does a lot of this. At some point, people need to take care of themselves.
- EricDeb 14y agoIt is absolutely the governments job to give people places to live if they are unable (not unwilling) to do so on their own. The difficulty lies in determining who is truly unable and who is simply unwilling.
- cglace 14y agoIt is absolutely your opinion that it is their job.
- eigenvector 14y agoIt is the job of the people to determine what the job of the government is.
- cglace 14y agoThat was my point.
- bjourne 14y agoYou are free to hold your opinion. But at least be upfront with that you consider it an ideological issue as there obviously are reasonable alternatives to having poor people live in prison cells.
- wilfra 14y agothey are not being forced to live there, they are choosing to do so and paying rent. they are free to move anywhere else they want, including across the border to mainland china where it is much cheaper.
- greggman 14y agoIs that really how it works in SG? I've been told housing prices are outrageous there and if you're too poor to afford public housing you get shipped off to the poor house and are not allowed to leave unless you can find someone to take responsibility for you. Note: I've only visited SG so this is 2nd hand info through my friends in SG.
- redact207 14y agoThat's sort of how it works here. The Singaporean housing market is divided into HDB (public housing) and Condo (private housing). Condo's nowadays start at around SGD 1m for something small and basic, but aren't such a bad deal with banks charging interest of just 1.8% on a 40 year loan. Most Singaporeans can't afford this with an average monthly wage of just SGD 2,000 per month. Public housing on the other hand is heavily subsidised and somewhat controlled for PRs and citizens. FYI Singapore was a giant slum up until the government formed the HDB board in the 1960s. The CPF (Singapore's retirement fund) can be used as a deposit against your apartment which nowadays start at SGD 300,000 if you go far from the city. As you can guess, this results in many people having a lot of cash tied up in non-liquid assets when they retire that leads to a host of other issues. I moved to Singapore 3 years ago from Australia and love the place and prefer life here to Hong Kong any day.
- hollerith 14y ago>Condo's nowadays start at around SGD 1m for something small and basic 1,000,000 SGD is about 800,000 USD.
- Evbn 14y agoBut effectively half that with the (subsidized?) interest rates.
- adrinavarro 14y agoWell, that makes around 1200 EUR. So, that's even better than the "common" (not avg) monthly wage in many places in Europe. Indeed, cost of living in Singapore must be over the roof…
- yskchu 14y ago48% of the HK population already live in government provided/subsidized housing, that's already very high. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_in_Hong_Kong#Housing_statistics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_in_Hong_Kong#Housing_st...
- Quiark 14y agoI was in Singapore and now I'm living in HK. Reading that SG has higher density than HK made was surprising, because here in HK there are so many needle-like apartment buildings, but I didn't see that so much in SG. I think the reason is that HK does have bigger area than SG but actually far less land is being used in HK (many hills), so practically speaking, the density is higher in HK :)
- saosebastiao 14y agoPublic housing or housing vouchers are one thing. Price controls are another. Price controls are absolutely, without a single empirical doubt, the worst policy you could enact. You might as well start torching your housing supply...the effects are the same.
- dllthomas 14y agoHyperbolic, but accurate when you've accounted for that.
- Evbn 14y agoVouchers without controls drive up prices, becoming a transfer from govt to landlords. Public owned housing is the answer.
- saosebastiao 14y agoVouchers with artificial limitations on new development drive up prices, becoming a transfer from govt to landlords Eliminating artificial limitations on new development is the answer.
- anovikov 14y agoPeople are driven to these places by economic opportunities. They are not living in cages because they have nothing else to do, but because they want to live in Hong Kong, even much better conditions in mainland China is of no interest to them. This is like how people abandon their well built, fully paid out 3-bedroom apartments in mainland Russia and flock to Moscow where they share rooms with strangers, with 5-10 people living together in an apartment in their 30s. This isn't poverty, this is how people try to escape poverty. They cannot be helped to do it (otherwise more people will flock in - you can't move all China/all Russia to Hong Kong/Moscow), and should not be banned from trying (that kills economic progress, with Russians staying in Russian province means they will simply slowly die of vodka, in Moscow they might do something useful, i think same goes to Chinese).
- cynicalkane 14y ago> the government build subsidized housing and then enact strict price controls You're aware that the US has been doing this since the 1950s, right? And it hasn't worked as well for us?