10 ms·
Free speech is protected - so long as it is speech by corporations. I'm sure that corporations everywhere rejoiced at Citizens United. But compare with Morse
by btilly 14y ago
Free speech is protected - so long as it is speech by corporations. I'm sure that corporations everywhere rejoiced at Citizens United.
But compare with Morse v. Frederick.
- rayiner 14y agoThe gist of Citizens United was that the government couldn't ban political speech near an election. The speaker in question just happened to be a company. Morse just said that kids have limited free speech rights. Both seem like good decisions to me and consistent with our historical practice.
- btilly 14y agoThe gist of Citizens United is that rights never intended by the Founders to apply to corporations now do. And spending money qualifies as speech. You probably also think that Clapper v. Amnesty International was a good decision. And think that they should not have heard Hepting v. AT&T. Those two cases seem highly relevant to their likely attitude on this one.
- rayiner 14y agoThe founding fathers likely never contemplated that groups of people would have different free speech rights than individual people. And Citizens United was about a political movie critical of Hilary Clinton during an election season when she was running for office. It's not "is money speech." I can't think of anything more deserving of free speech protections than political speech, especially critical political speech. Clapper was a very sensible decision. The plaintiffs in the case couldn't even prove that they had been harmed!
- btilly 14y agoActually the founding fathers were very aware of corporations and their intertwining with political power. For example the Boston Tea Party destroyed property of the East India Company to protest laws passed by the English Parliament on behalf of that corporation, undoubtably motivated by the large monetary contributions that said corporation made to the elections for Parliament. The result is that there is no shortage of commentary from the founding fathers on the evils of corporations. And that is why in the early days of the Republic a majority of US states had laws BANNING corporations from engaging in any kind of political activities. It is historically absurd to maintain that the founding fathers merely overlooked the possibility that corporations would want to engage in political speech. The did not overlook it - they had seen it up close and emphatically wanted no part of it!
- snowwrestler 14y agoIf you were right, then they should have explicitly and specifically carved corporations out of the Bill of Rights, which they obviously did not do. That was not an oversight.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- triplesec 14y agoBy definition it was an oversight, whether intentional or inadvertent...
- meddlepal 14y agoCan you have an intentional oversight? Seems inconsistent...
- triplesec 14y agoYes I can, though it's a good question! Probably better couched as "deliberate oversight". Think in a political situation where you don't want to deal with an issue because it'll open a can of worms. 'Don't Ask Don't Tell' in the US ilitary was one such thing. Here's an example f he use of the term in a blog about Apple products: http://www.mikesouthby.co.uk/2011/12/os-x-understanding-enabling-ssd-trim-support/ http://www.mikesouthby.co.uk/2011/12/os-x-understanding-enab...
- Evbn 14y agoAvoiding something is not the same as oversight. Oversight is failing to notice something. DADT did not stop observation of homosexual activity.
- btilly 14y agoThe idea that corporations could be considered people with natural rights did not surface until a century later, and would have seemed absurd to the founders. If they had thought that such an absurd interpretation was a serious risk, I'm sure that they would have made their position clear, but the question never arose at the time.
- strlen 14y ago> Clapper was a very sensible decision. The plaintiffs in the case couldn't even prove that they had been harmed! Seems very sensible, compared to how difficult the search for a plaintiff with standing had been for the case that became Heller. If a civil rights activist (Parker) that received death threats had no standing to challenge DC's handgun ban, as he never tried to register a handgun (unlike Heller, who was arguably a less sympathetic defendant -- an anti-government "gun-nut", etc...), I don't see how Amnesty had standing in this case. Second amendment is actually a great example of how poor plaintiff choice often hurts civil rights causes. See Miller vs. US -- a felony charge of transporting a sawed shotgun with defendant himself being killed before decision was rendered; the outcome resulted in 70 year reign of "collective rights" interpretation of second amendment.
- Evbn 14y ago"Standing" is horribly abused. It is used to reject plaintiffs challenging government secrecy, because they can't prove they have standing unless they win the case -- a Catch-22. Similarly, if you are banned from doing something, you don't get standing unless you do it anyway, at great personal risk. Wanting to do it is not granted standing (though it should) Standing is the legal equivalent of launching the Challenger with known frozen o-rings just because it hadn't crashed yet
- afarrell 14y agoI fail to see how prohibiting groups of people from spending money on video equipment is any more justifiable than prohibiting them from spending money on a printing press. Were not presses back in 1790 very expensive?
- rayiner 14y agoIndeed, the Solicitor General seemed to lose the momentum of the argument right around when one of the justices got him to admit that if the government could ban the airing of the movie (of a non-profit corporation, by the way) that there was no principled way that book banning wouldn't be okay under the same powers.
- makomk 14y agoWhich is curious - there were, as far as I know, no restrictions on them putting the exact same ads or films out over the Internet or through any means other than TV broadcasts (which are of course a Government-granted monopoly and therefore can reasonably be argued to need more regulation).
- rayiner 14y agoMight've have been a better angle, not necessarily a winning one though. The trend has been to be very skeptical of speech regulations on broadcast, even if it's a government granted monopoly. The 2nd Circuit smacked down the FCC for fining FOX that year for "fleeting expletives".
- snowwrestler 14y agoThis is not even close to the truth. Constitutional rights of expression have always applied to corporations. That is how the New York Times has freedom of the press, not just the reporters who work there. That is how the Catholic Church has freedom of religion, not just the people who follow that faith.
- wnight 14y agoWhat's the reasoning behind the corporation needing rights? It seems like if taken far enough my photocopier would need rights, whereas I think it would be more straight-forward to deal with the people behind the instrument rather than the instrument itself.
- dantheman 14y agoThe gist of it is, is that you don't lose your rights when your get together in a group.
- chc 14y agoBut you do lose many of your responsibilities behind the corporate veil. That's the thing that's so weird. Corporations don't merely give their constituent people a vehicle to exercise their rights. Corporations are totally separate people from any person inside the corporation.
- crusso 14y agoHow does the corporate veil affect free speech? Just looked at the largest union, the NEA. It's incorporated in many states for various reasons. Should that prevent it from participating in political discourse?
- snowwrestler 14y agoThe corporate veil protects shareholders from being personally liable for the debts and obligations incurred by the corporation. Speech does not create debts or obligations, so the veil is not an issue. Corporate speech is subject to some regulation, just like personal speech. Corporations can be sued for slander and libel, advertisements must meet certain standards of truthfulness, etc.
- jacoblyles 14y agoI stand with that reactionary right-wing organization, the ACLU, in declaring the Citizens United decision a victory for free speech and necessary for a strong democracy. IMO, when "progressives" talk about Citizens United they show their true colors...
- rayiner 14y agoNot only that, it was total self interest! They're a corporation after all.
- smsm42 14y agoHow using corporation to perform speech is different? New York Times is a corporation too, does it mean the government can intervene in what New York Times is publishing and infringe their free speech rights? Of course if individual people have free speech rights, these rights do not disappear if they organize to perform this speech - be it corporation, union, non-profit, or any other form of organization. That's what SCOTUS confirmed, and rightfully so.
- crusso 14y agoIf you're against groups of people (corporations) from having the same rights as individuals - does that logic also apply to unions?
- Evbn 14y agoSo a corporation (many individuals acting in concert) funding a movie should be unconstitutional, but a single billionaire natural person funding a movie should be constitutionally allowed? Because free speech? That seems horribly backward.
- jellicle 14y ago> The gist of Citizens United was that the government couldn't ban political speech near an election. The speaker in question just happened to be a company. Uh, no. The law in question applied only to corporations. The decision has nothing to do with individuals speaking.
- rayiner 14y agoOf course it has to do with individuals. It's hyper-legalistic to say that the fact that individuals are working through a corporation that they don't have individual rights. It's incredibly contrived, and it's a contrivance the Court didn't indulge. Also, the 'corporation' in this case was non-profit. I wasn't really looking forward to a post-Citizens United-gone the other way world where the Jeb Bush administration immediately used its newfound powers to ban speech from Sierra Club, etc.
- btilly 14y agoNewfound powers? Laws restricting the political activities of corporations are as old as the nation. The key issues involved in Citizens had already been decided the other way in both Austin v. Michigan Chamber of Commerce (1990) and McConnell v. Federal Election Commission (2003). There would have been nothing newfound in restricting the spending of corporate money on political issues. Yes, even in the case of non-profits.
- dalke 14y agoYour reading of the Supreme Court decision is incorrect. Quoting from the decision: "The Court has recognized that the First Amendment applies to corporations, e.g., First Nat. Bank of Boston v. Bellotti , 435 U. S. 765 , and extended this protection to the context of political speech, see, e.g., NAACP v. Button , 371 U. S. 415 ." "The First Amendment prohibits Congress from fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for engaging in political speech, but Austin’s antidistortion rationale would permit the Government to ban political speech because the speaker is an association with a corporate form." These specifically say that while there may be a distinction between individual free speech rights and corporate free speech rights, the First Amendment applies to both. This "hyper-legalistic" argument from Supreme the Court is different than your statement, which is that corporate free speech is identical to individual free speech. Instead, it says that all "speakers" are covered under the 1st, and that individuals and companies are examples of speakers. (" All speakers, including individuals and the media, use money amassed from the economic marketplace to fund their speech, and the First Amendment protects the resulting speech." .. "That speakers may have influence over or access to elected officials does not mean that those officials are corrupt." .. " Political speech is so ingrained in this country’s culture that speakers find ways around campaign finance laws.", etc.) Your comparison to the Sierra Club is not a good one. The Sierra Club is a 501(c)(3), which means it has prohibitions on supporting political candidates and limits on lobbying. This is not changed by Citizen's United because of Regan v. Taxation With Representation of Washington, "a legislature’s decision not to subsidize the exercise of a fundamental right does not infringe the right." Citizen's United is a 501(c)(4) nonprofit, and income spent on political activities is, I believe, taxable and thus not subsidized. You should instead use the Supreme Court's example that the ability to restrict speech for a non-profit corporation (other than for tax reasons) implies that the government could also restrict speech for a for-profit media company. I have no immediate response to that argument. For what it's worth, I disagree with Citizen's United, and I believe that corporate rights must be subordinate to individual rights. The Court disagrees with me, and says that the only difference between a wealthy individual and a company is the limited liability, and that's insufficient to trigger a legal distinction under the First Amendment. I still disagree with that logic and believe it to be sufficient.
- dfc 14y agoMorse v. Frederick? Are you trolling? The Morse decision is so narrow that I don't know why you are expecting much traction by bringing it up. I'm curious are you in high school? Edit: There is nothing wrong if you are in high school. I was only asking because being a high school student would be a good explanation for why you think the Morse decision was so contentious.
- btilly 14y agoI brought it up as a free speech decision that demonstrates that this court is not universally on the side of free speech. And yes, I think that the government should not be censoring political speech that takes place off of government property, no matter how much it dislikes the message. As for your high school accusation, I'm in the top 50 posters on this site. You can easily check that I don't look like a high school student. In fact had I chosen to have children when I got married, they would have now been old enough to have graduated from college.)
- dfc 14y agoNo court is universally on the side of free speech. It was not an accusation of being a high school student. (I'm not even sure what the "accusation" would imply.) The question about high school was to assess why you thought the Morse decision was on the same level as Citizens United. And I'm not sure what you being in the top 50 has to do with anything.
- 1123581321 14y agoBy the top 50 remark he meant that you have a large body of material from which to ascertain that he is not a high school student.
- rdl 14y agoI wonder who the youngest on http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders (top 100) is. I see a few people I recognize as late-20s, at least, but most in 30s, and plenty in 40s-60s range
- strlen 14y agoSupreme Court doctrines aren't about left vs. right in the conventional sense. The justices are very solid about the principles they claim to stick to (standards of judicial review, what constitutes limitations on commerce clause, etc...) and civil liberties aren't a left vs. right matter. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_v._Entertainment_Merchants_Association http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_v._Entertainment_Merchant... for example: Scalia wrote a very strong pro-free speech majority opinion, extending speech to cover violent video games. Beyer (generally thought of as liberal) dissented using logic he would use in any other decisions, Thomas again used the "en-loco parentis" argument he often makes in decisions involving children (I disagree with him, but he sees it as consistent with support of free speech). See also Thomas' dissent in Raich vs. Gonzales. In 9th circuit, judge Alex Kozinski is probably the best example of a strongly civil liberties minded conservative/libertarian justice. I would like to see Kozinski in SCOTUS, but I'm pretty sure he'll receive The Mother of All Borkings if ever nominated.
- jaggederest 14y agoparenthetically, it was only recently that I realized the origin of the term 'borked' as relating to the nomination of Robert Bork to the Supreme Court.
- cynest 14y ago> Thomas again used the "en-loco parentis" argument he often makes in decisions involving children Just a note: it's in loco parentis, latin for in the place of the parent.
- 14y ago