4 ms·
I love the ruling. Unfortunately we have a 5-4 split in the Supreme Court. The liberal minority only needs a single judge to come to their side to win this.
by btilly 14y ago
I love the ruling.
Unfortunately we have a 5-4 split in the Supreme Court. The liberal minority only needs a single judge to come to their side to win this. However on civil liberties the trend has been negative. I'm therefore not particularly optimistic.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoFor the sake of this and Prop8 soon, I really, really hope you're wrong.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoDOMA is also up for a SCOTUS ruling, which is potentially far more substantive (because full-faith-and-credit will actually have force for marriages). It'll be interesting how that shakes out.
- jorgeortiz85 14y agoWindsor v US (the DOMA case up for a SCOTUS ruling) only challenges Section 3 of DOMA, not Section 2. Section 3 forbids the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages. Section 2 says states are not required to recognize the same-sex marriages of other states. The full-faith-and-credit clause of the Constitution gives Congress the power to "prescribe the Manner in which such Acts, Records and Proceedings shall be proved, and the Effect thereof", so it's very unlikely that Section 2 will be ruled unconstitutional.
- Evbn 14y agoIs "not doing" a legitimate "manner" of doing something. That seems rather tenuous.
- rayiner 14y agoIt depends which civil liberties you're talking about. The Roberts court has been good for free speech and gun rights, and it wasn't just the liberals. Brown v. EMA was 7-2 for example. The pro-habeas Hamdan, Hamdi, Boumediene cases also came out under Roberts. Several positive decisions on drugs (can't ban hullucigenic teas) and search an seizure too (GPS case).
- btilly 14y agoFree speech is protected - so long as it is speech by corporations. I'm sure that corporations everywhere rejoiced at Citizens United. But compare with Morse v. Frederick.
- rayiner 14y agoThe gist of Citizens United was that the government couldn't ban political speech near an election. The speaker in question just happened to be a company. Morse just said that kids have limited free speech rights. Both seem like good decisions to me and consistent with our historical practice.
- btilly 14y agoThe gist of Citizens United is that rights never intended by the Founders to apply to corporations now do. And spending money qualifies as speech. You probably also think that Clapper v. Amnesty International was a good decision. And think that they should not have heard Hepting v. AT&T. Those two cases seem highly relevant to their likely attitude on this one.
- rayiner 14y agoThe founding fathers likely never contemplated that groups of people would have different free speech rights than individual people. And Citizens United was about a political movie critical of Hilary Clinton during an election season when she was running for office. It's not "is money speech." I can't think of anything more deserving of free speech protections than political speech, especially critical political speech. Clapper was a very sensible decision. The plaintiffs in the case couldn't even prove that they had been harmed!
- btilly 14y agoActually the founding fathers were very aware of corporations and their intertwining with political power. For example the Boston Tea Party destroyed property of the East India Company to protest laws passed by the English Parliament on behalf of that corporation, undoubtably motivated by the large monetary contributions that said corporation made to the elections for Parliament. The result is that there is no shortage of commentary from the founding fathers on the evils of corporations. And that is why in the early days of the Republic a majority of US states had laws BANNING corporations from engaging in any kind of political activities. It is historically absurd to maintain that the founding fathers merely overlooked the possibility that corporations would want to engage in political speech. The did not overlook it - they had seen it up close and emphatically wanted no part of it!
- DannyBee 14y agoThe ruling is good but not great. It's better than what happened in 2006, but still only requires reasonable suspicion before they can take your laptop away from you for as long as they like to search it. Reasonable suspicion is a very low standard. It's basically more than a hunch, less than any real evidence. Even a combination of completely insignificant things can be reasonable suspicion.
- drags 14y agoThe split is not so clear-cut on search and seizure issues. Remember that it was Justice Scalia who wrote the majority opinion in Kyllo, which decided that using thermal imaging devices to search for grow houses ran afoul of the 4th Amendment.
- will_brown 14y ago>civil liberties the trend has been negative. Other disturbing degradation of civil liberties: - SCOTUS declining to hear the AT&T case of warrantless wiretapping emails, texts and other communication. -SCOTUS holding the Political Question Doctrine prohibits the Court from reviewing the Constitutionality of the President's extrajudicial targeted "Kill List" of US citizens nor can they review the Constitutionality on the criteria to get on the list. Recently a US District Court held Indefinite Detention of US citizens without due process to be Unconstitutional. However, I think SCOTUS will uphold this ruling 5-4 prompting Congress to re-write the law with the same effect, prompting the legal process all over again.
- rayiner 14y agoThe examples you mentioned aren't "degradation of civil liberties." They're the court punting on deciding issues they don't have to. The Court didn't hear the AT&T case because there wasn't any plaintiff that could prove they had been harmed. The Court didn't hear the "kill list" case because what the President does against enemy combatants off U.S. soil is indeed a political question, since the Constitution invests the President with primacy in international affairs. The Court has not shied away from hearing similar issues when there was a closer nexus to U.S. soil and there were individuals with standing. The Court overturned a lot of the government's practices in Guantanamo, for example, because it was: 1) U.S. controlled soil; and 2) the people suing were actually hurt by the practices, not just people who objected to the practices.
- cyrus_ 14y agoSo to clarify, you are stating that U.S. citizens should lose all right to due process the minute they step off U.S. soil? Or do you believe that any citizen deemed an enemy combatant can be killed by the executive on U.S. soil as well?
- rayiner 14y agoI'm not saying either of these things. I'm pointing out that separation of powers requires the Supreme Court to respect situations where the Constitution has given other branches primacy. It has never been true that the Supreme Court is the appropriate forum for redress of every possible Constitutional violation. That is to say, it can be simultaneously true that the Executive does something unconstitutional and that it is appropriate for the Supreme Court not to review the action. The conduct of war is an area in which the Constitution invests the President with primacy. But it's not a black/white issue--it's a spectrum. The more closely a matter touches U.S. soil, the more justification the Supreme Court has for intervening. At one end of the spectrum is the President's conduct with respect to foreigners on foreign soil. The Supreme Court has no business telling the President how to kill Taliban in Afghanistan. At the other end of the spectrum is the President's conduct with respect to Americans on American soil. The Supreme Court must insert itself in such situations, as it did in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld (2004), when it declared that the government must give due process to an American citizen captured in Afghanistan being held in Guantanamo. Between there is where it gets iffy. Hamdi, for reference, hadn't been in the U.S. since he was a child. Yet he was held to have due process rights because he was on U.S. controlled soil (Guantanamo Bay). The kill list cases have so far all been missing that crucial nexus to U.S. soil. Do you lose all your rights when you step off U.S. soil? No, and the Supreme Court has said so (Reid v. Covert). Do you lose all your rights when you leave the U.S., actively take up arms against it, and evade all attempts to bring you to justice? The Supreme Court is quite prudent not to take up that hairy situation, especially since civil libertarians may very well not like the answer.[1] [1] It wouldn't be unreasonable or unjustifiable for the Supreme Court to say that U.S. Citizens do retain the right to due process while off U.S. soil, even if they take up arms against the U.S., but that an administrative process is sufficient "process due" in situations where the Citizen refuses to submit himself to judicial process.