8 ms·
> When you observe chickens up close, they're surprisingly attractive animals. Wow! I kept 20-25 laying hens in yearly batches when I was between the ages of
by bediger4000 14y ago
> When you observe chickens up close, they're surprisingly attractive animals.
Wow! I kept 20-25 laying hens in yearly batches when I was between the ages of 13 and 18. I found them to be singularly repulsive, all having the same rude, avaricious, gluttonous personality, and all behaving in the most horrible manner possible. I'm not against eating chicken mainly because of this experience.
I also had several pairs of ducks during those years, providing an avian contrast. Ducks have different personalities, aren't nearly as vicious to each other or to their prey, and are generally good sports.
Everything else you say about laying hens is true in my experience. The eggs are indeed much, much better than supermarket eggs.
- 205guy 14y agoActually, you're both right, you just had different experiences. With 2-6 hens, the flock is more centered around the human, allow themselves to be touched and hand fed, and exhibit recognizable personalities. With 10-20 hens, the flock is more "wild" and establish their own pecking order by being aggressive to each other (and grabbing all the food they can grab before the others). I had a flock of 12 and saw both kinds of behavior, though because we kept the roosters for a while, it tended towards the wild side. Of course, chicken breeds, coop environment, and owner personality are huge factors in chicken behavior as well. BTW, this is a great article in that it reveals a little about our industrial food chain. I suppose it's popular here on HN because it has a bit of the "How things work" vibe. There should be articles like this for every type of food sold in stores.
- yareally 14y agoIt seems very common with animals and humans alike that we tend to exhibit "mob mentality" when in larger groups. I picture the hens in a large group attacking each other over food to be similar to going out on "Black Friday" after the US Thanksgiving or a company with a broken employee culture. Not exactly the most attractive or positive examples of human nature.
- gadders 14y agoI always picture battery cages as being like a Super Max Federal prison.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoMaking generalizations from a single style of husbandry is a little like making generalizations about human children based on a single school. A year at many US schools might lead you to believe children are rude, avaricious, and gluttonous, but I don't think that's a fair universal characterization of kids. A sibling comment mentions flock size as a factor, but there are many factors in chicken personality. Most farmers create scarcity across almost all resources, from food to grooming space, to running and flying room, to pasture time, and so on. Almost any creature, in constant competition for scarce resources amongst her peers, will develop a deplorable personality, sadistic or vindictive.
- eurleif 14y ago>I'm not against eating chicken mainly because of this experience. I don't understand your reasoning there. To me, whether it's ok to eat an animal should depend on whether it can experience suffering, not on whether it has a good personality. I mean, is it ok to eat people who are jerks?
- StavrosK 14y agoOooh, not with my current ethics, but interesting thought experiment.
- pyre 14y agoAnother interesting though experiment: A lot of people respond to the "why is it ok to eat these animals" question with, "because chickens/cows/turkeys are dumb." Following that logic, it's ok to eat people with a low enough IQ, or mental handicaps, no?
- stephencanon 14y agoHaving kept both ducks and chickens myself, the ducks were a noisy undifferentiated mass of (delicious) hassle. The chickens were fascinating and all had distinct personalities; they were vicious to bugs and occasionally each other, but always friendly with people. Go figure.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Falling3 14y agoThis is some really terrible generalizing. I've spent a lot of time with a lot of different chickens (hens and roosters). If you spend a fair amount of time with them, you really do see individual personalities strongly emerge. I've known many chickens to learn their names and excitedly come running up when called. I've also known a few who enjoyed being held. Now, I've also spent some time with ducks and I'm not going to do any sort of contrast like you have. Ducks can be just as pleasant to be around. They can also be horrible to each other. I knew one duck who was prone to getting picked on by his flock mates, who occasionally attempted to drown him. I've gotta laugh a bit at your use of the word avaricious to describe a chicken. I'm not sure where that could even be coming from. I'm not trying to discount your experience, but it really doesn't seem to me that you spent the time getting to know the animals in any way. And using that as a justification to eat them. Well I've got some coworkers you might be interested in too...
- zbyszek 14y agoDifferent personalities all right. Recall the Ig Nobel Prize-winning observations of mallard necrophilia; https://moeliker.wordpress.com/the-duck/ https://moeliker.wordpress.com/the-duck/
- bediger4000 14y agoOne of my drakes would commit homosexual rape on the other drake, so I actual found that Ig Nobel article fascinating.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>Wow! I kept 20-25 laying hens in yearly batches when I was between the ages of 13 and 18. I found them to be singularly repulsive, all having the same rude, avaricious, gluttonous personality, and all behaving in the most horrible manner possible. Get yourself some Silkies. They lay smaller eggs but have a very pleasant disposition.
- triplesec 14y agoThat could just be projection! 8)