62 ms·
Yes The linux idiots have one glaring example: PulseAudio Throw away user experience, system stability, judicious use of CPU for what? It certainly improves
by raverbashing 14y ago
Yes
The linux idiots have one glaring example: PulseAudio
Throw away user experience, system stability, judicious use of CPU for what?
It certainly improves certain details of the user experience, when it works correctly, also usually consuming more CPU than flash player
- jlgreco 14y agoAm I the only person in the world who has never had anything but a pleasant experience with PulseAudio? The first time I noticed that I was using it, I had already been using it for a year...
- raverbashing 14y agoLet me ask you some questions then: - How often do you reboot your computer - What audio softwares you use the most For me, PA crashes around once a week (and this is with the latest version I tried), or just plain stops working (like muting the sound, garbled sound, etc) Not to mention the delay that happens while switching songs in mplayer for example. Use ALSA and song switch is instantaneous.
- jlgreco 14y ago> - How often do you reboot your computer Once every two or three months, when I remember to apply updates. > - What audio softwares you use the most Only flash (youtube, primarily. Also youtube's html5 player probably, I haven't paid much attention to that) and mplayer. A few years ago, XMMS2. I used to use an XMMS2 client I wrote for music, now I just use some bash scripts and mplayer; I can't say I've noticed any delay while switching songs with mplayer or XMMS2. When I play music from my laptop through my raspberry pi connected to my TV with pusleaudio, then I notice an audio delay. That is the only sore spot pulseaudio has ever presented me.
- raverbashing 14y agoVery interesting. I thought some instability may be due to PA staying up for a long time, but apparently not. About the delay, try this: mplayer *mp3 (in a directory with mp3 files, of course), then press >. There should be a significant delay in switching songs (like, 0.5s). Make sure mplayer shows it's using the [Pulse] driver With ALSA this is very fast
- dscrd 14y ago"Not to mention the delay that happens while switching songs in mplayer for example. Use ALSA and song switch is instantaneous. " There's a good possibility that this is mplayer's fault more than PA's.
- mercurial 14y agoNo issue on a couple of machines. Running with a call to start-pulseaudio-x11 from my .xsession, works fine. I believe running it as a system daemon is not recommended, though.
- chao- 14y agoMy most recent attempt to use PulseAudio (as it came via Ubuntu) had the quirk of not activating the headphone jack when something was inserted. It dutifully turned off my speakers, but no sound was available elsewhere. I previously had stock Debian on the machine, and everything was working fine. A half day's effort was put into toying with ALSA configs that Pulse was deferring to for whatever driver choices it made. Dozens of help articles or threads where everyone else in the world could proclaim "Thanks, that fixed it for me!" left me with less functionality than I started with. The only thing Pulse has ever done right for me was was help to record some loopback audio on an otherwise-crippled sound card.
- lmm 14y agoNo, there are a decent chunk of users for whom it works fine. Maybe as many as 95%. But there's also a substantial number of users for whom it introduces major problems - which would be more forgiveable (at least to yours truly) if it provided any visible advantages over existing systems. (After a few months of trying to make pulse work I left for FreeBSD, which works beautifully and avoids a lot of linux's change (seemingly) for the sake of change)
- elwin 14y agoI haven't had any recent trouble with it. Back in the early days, it didn't always work well with SDL, but that was fixed years ago. I've been able to crash the daemon with stress tests, but it seems to restart automatically. I can't understand all the dislike of PulseAudio either. It certainly has a nicer API than /dev/dsp.
- threedaymonk 14y agoNo, you're not the only one. I'd been forewarned of the awfulness of pulse, but didn't even notice its installation until later, when I discovered all the useful things I could do with it: play music over the office Apple airplay thingy; use two sets of headphones simultaneously; send audio to another computer in the house. Without any typing, searching, or rebooting, I remember OSS and Alsa, and I don't miss either. As far as I can see, it makes Linux audio work like any other computer in this millennium.
- armored_mammal 14y agoI agree with. The only problems I've ever had with it have turned out to either be problems with the actual hardware or problems with the clients, not problems with Pulse Itself. I will admit having a lot of a hate for figuring out which audio 'profile' is which... If you've got the plugs for 7.1 and a normal line in as well as possibly a digital one, they you've probably got 23 choices of profile for your built in audio device. Add in a GPU with HDMI and the NVIDIA driver and you probably get at least another 7+ choices all labeled Nvidia... I find I frequently have to guess multiple times whenever I hook up a TV via HDMI. But it works quite well if you define works as works without adding on any usability riders.
- ishbits 14y agoPulseAudio is good now. It was a different story for me back in 2007/2008 though.
- derleth 14y ago> The linux idiots have one glaring example: PulseAudio PulseAudio works wonderfully for me. It allows software mixing, something that's never been possible for me prior to PulseAudio, and it never crashes. It also gives me a single place to control volume on a per-app basis (pavucontrol). That's not something I had prior to PulseAudio, either. I can also keep a single desktop session going for months.
- zanny 14y agoI agree with this, I have similar experiences with pulse. I also use the pulse equalizer, which is super easy to set up. I like it. I think it does things right, and they can optimize it more over time. It is better than having a fast audio subsystem that just can't do what I want. Pulse is a kitchen sink that at least covers its bases.
- iso-8859-1 14y agoNot this again... You could have complained about this years ago, but it makes no sense today. PulseAudio got fixed. > user experience you can set up PulseAudio for LAN audio streaming with padevchooser (GUI). Could you do this with ESD? Arts? Tell me about this audio streaming solution with super UX for Linux that you know...
- raverbashing 14y ago"you can set up PulseAudio for LAN audio streaming with padevchooser (GUI)." Yes, and? I understand this is a useful feature for some people, but I'm just interested in listening to music and PA does not me allow to do that without frequent crashes and bugs I don't care about the features of a car if it stops working at random. And yes, this has happened on every distro I tried since PA started being bundled. Every single distro, every single machine I've had only a stable system with PA OFF
- zanny 14y agoBugs can be fixed. Pulse is newer than Alsa and more complex, you should expect bugs. If you don't have a problem with the implementation details of PA (software mixing, optional software equalizing, networked audio, stateful audio adaption to devices) then just report the bugs and make it better. Don't whine and try to fragment the Linux space any worse than it already is, especially with Mir's announcement.
- raverbashing 14y agoYes, I should expect bugs soon after release But PA is 8 years now. I don't remember any software being so problematic as PA in the Linux world. Some have more problems, yes, but they usually have a limited deployment.
- iso-8859-1 14y agoFlash Player? You didn't have problems with that?
- mercurial 14y ago> It certainly improves certain details of the user experience, when it works correctly, also usually consuming more CPU than flash player You make a sweeping statement which is not true for every system. Looking at what happens playing a Youtube music video, according to htop: - pulseaudio is using between 0 and 1% CPU - plugin-container (wrapping Flash) is at 3% - firefox oscillates between 20 and 40% Now, my understanding is that, at the time pulseaudio came out, it was using untested functionalities in audio drivers which, for many chipsets, did not actually work and progressively got fixed. There was the same problem with graphics drivers when KDE 4.0 was introduced. Maybe you're out of luck and actually have a defective driver?
- raverbashing 14y agoThanks for this insightful answer I'm not sure I have a bad driver, the last two chipsets I used were Intel (and no weird audio devices), works fine with other sw. Latest distro tested: RHEL 6 and Fedora 16 For me, PA would stay around 5%, 10% sometimes, and even more depending on the task. Not to mention crashing every week (at a random moment)
- mercurial 14y agoThat's curious. You might be a victim of this bug: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=813407 https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=813407 I'm not sure if this could affect the CPU usage. I hear that you can play with the resample setting to lower it, but I haven't had to do that on a 5+ yo desktop.
- ashayh 14y agoYou should avoid RH based distros for Desktop related activities. Perhaps you should try Ubuntu, Mint or Suse.
- mindcrime 14y agoNonsense. Fedora is a fine desktop Linux... I run it on a woefully underpowered laptop which I use for development, and it is every bit as usable as, say, Ubuntu (which I use on my corporate laptop). In fact, I'd take my Fedora/KDE setup over this Ubuntu/Unity setup any day.
- notatoad 14y agoI'm going to guess you haven't used pulseaudio in the last 3-4 years?
- andrewaylett 14y agoI conducted an experiment on my last laptop, having noticed PulseAudio taking up more CPU than my media player. I found, quite consistently, that disabling PA led to my media player using more CPU on its own than the sum of the media player and PA when both were running.