10 ms·
I don't understand. We've spent thousands of years, using 99.9% of able-bodied people for farming, hunting or some other food-gathering activities. Only selecte
by gambiting 14y ago
I don't understand.
We've spent thousands of years, using 99.9% of able-bodied people for farming, hunting or some other food-gathering activities. Only selected few could afford to NOT work in farming.
Even America, just 200 years ago had 90% of its population working as farmers.
Why such a desperate trend to make everyone grow their own food again? Sure, the food industry is not always honest,not always as good as your own home-grown food, but still - it allowed us to do something else with our lives, and pushed our societies an order of magnitude ahead.
As much as people should APPRECIATE farming, I don't think that everyone should do it. We produce enough food as it is.
We should teach kids how to code however, not because we need more programmers(which we do,but I digress) - but because it's the easiest way to introduce kids to logical, technical-like thinking. That way we can have more mathematicians, physicists, astronomers, engineers - people who we can afford to keep alive(almost literally) because they do not need to grown their own food anymore! They can sit at their desks for the whole day, thinking how to make the world better, instead of looking at how the crops grow.
I would say - why not give kids both? Is it too much to ask? Show them how vegetables are grown, how animals are cared for and how are they slaughtered, but at the same time, yes, please teach them how to code.
- barry-cotter 14y agoWhy such a desperate trend to make everyone grow their own food again? Look at me exercising a form of conspicuous consumption (the time of a highly educated profeasional) that my class and culture peers think are praiseworthy. Let me say everyone should indulge in my hobby. Let's look down on those who don't together.
- meaty 14y agoActually some of us do it as a context switch and a tie to our roots. Some of us, myself included consider it to be a valuable skill in an unstable world and some insurance against the fuckwits we have to trust in society. Also the stuff tastes better.
- fsniper 14y agoI don't believe computer programing is a good way to teach logical thinking. Sociology, Philosophy and Literature are better alternatives. Coding only makes you better micro managers, "thinking of efficient ways to make idiots do things you like". Also teaching agriculture or other physical goods producing craftsmanship to kids would make them better at real world challenges. Modern society seems to be run by digital arts but it's just an illusion of how we live.
- gambiting 14y ago"Sociology, Philosophy and Literature are better alternatives." Yes,but not for kids. You won't teach any of these subjects to kids, even if they are better for logical thinking. But if you show them an interesting way to start programming,they will see a very clear connection between what is being said and what happens = logic. Then it can be extended later in life, but this article specifically targets kids. And I have the exact opposite view to yours - I think there is not enough logic in our lives. Our society might be addicted to digital works, but it does not mean they understand how it all works.
- coldtea 14y ago>Yes,but not for kids. You won't teach any of these subjects to kids Really? Why? We have been doing it for millenia.
- gambiting 14y agoNo. We make kids at school read countless books, and trying to convey to them the meaning that's inside these books. Most kids don't care though, because I really don't think that you can read some of mature works at the age of 14 and understand the deep philosophical context inside them, even if your teacher serves it to you on a silver plate. It's not to say that kids are stupid - far from it. My point is, that literally throwing literature and philosophical dilemmas at kids it not going to achieve much. Sure, we've been doing it for millenia - but it does not automatically make it right.
- rorrr 14y ago
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"Why such a desperate trend to make everyone grow their own food again? " Because most of them have no idea just how grim the life of a subsistence peasant farmer really is, and how that differs from the lucky few who get to sell boutique "organic" produce to rich people.
- gambiting 14y ago"Because most of them have no idea just how grim the life of a subsistence peasant farmer is" You could say the same about oil rig workers or coal miners and they are going to use both coal and oil when they grow up. Should we teach kids how to do these professions too? Where should we stop? There's many "grim" professions, things that need to be done in life, yet school kids are usually shown none of them. So what?
- Turing_Machine 14y agoI think you're misunderstanding me. I don't think people should have to be subsistence peasant farmers.
- gambiting 14y agoThey don't. As I mentioned earlier - high-yield industry scale farming might be evil, dishonest or capitalistic. Doesn't matter - it is what allowed us to not be farmers. Few hundred hears ago you had to be a farmer to survive - today you don't have to, because there is enough food for everyone on the market. IF you can find another job, that is. But if you find a different thing to do, then you don't have to be a farmer, you will be able to buy food.
- XorNot 14y agoHigh-yield farming also isn't any of those things. There's a difference between outcomes and practice (or indeed, general American administrative incompetence).
- ivanmilles 14y ago
- aethertap 14y agoI run a small farm, and I've been a professional programmer for about 12 years. I agree with what you say - kids should definitely have the opportunity to learn both. Of my two pursuits above, farming is much newer to me and I've found an amazing amount of skill transfer from the world of programming to the world of farming. Granted, my sheep don't understand when I yell at them in haskell, but the approaches to problem solving, whole-system thinking, and consideration of edge cases I think are enormously beneficial in almost any profession. I do think that today's kids would benefit not only from knowing a thing or two about how to raise some food (very different from actual "farming") and also from having much more contact with the natural world. I also think that many kids would benefit from learning the "art" side of programming - the stuff that's fun and interesting, like solving puzzles, appreciation of the hard-to-define idea of elegance, reverse engineering, etc. Nothing else I've learned to do has had quite the impact on my ability to consider many angles in a situation and reason a way to get from one state to another, and at least for me it's been a fun process to learn it all. My real complaint when anybody says "Everybody should have to learn X," is that I think it should be "Everybody should have a chance to learn X." Coding was the best path for me to learn to think about complex, abstract things and apply that thinking to the real world (including farming). For others, it may not be so.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Granted, my sheep don't understand when I yell at them in haskell From my own experience, try Assembly or Ook, they're both more geared towards mammals. Haskell is for communicating with machinery, that's your mistake right there ;) On another note, what I found when working land is that time flies by, you can zone out just as easily ploughing a chunk of land as you can while writing code. And it's inspiring. Another thing that it shows you is how much wildlife there is on an otherwise visually empty piece of land.
- meaty 14y agoI don't have a farm but I have a quarter acre of land in london on which I spend a fair amount of time growing vegetables (there are actually 5 of us). We don't have any grass to give you an idea. The skills are definitely transferrable , particularly time and planning skills. Mathematics and engineering skills are almost vital for success as well. However the most important things it gives me are peace, tranquility and space to think. I can go for a wander and come back with a fully modelled system and some potatoes :) All skills gained are valuable in an uncertain future.
- Heliosmaster 14y ago> Why such a desperate trend to make everyone grow their own food again? Because people forgot in a hanfdul of years (that's what it is, compared to the span of human history) what was slowly learned over the course of centuries and millennia. And the result? That kids nowadays almost think that foods magically pops out from the shelf at the supermarket. Specialization (in the sense that nobody does everything, everyone does his small part) is definitely good, unless you forget what everything is about and depend on others too much. Nobody expect people to go back to farming, but at least to know how is done. You never know.
- tomjen3 14y agoWhy does it matter where stuff comes from? I haven't the foggiest idea where my wood flooring came from, where my windows came from, or where my TV came from, nor my water, electricity, or the waste disposal guys who pick up my garbage. Yet for some reason it matters where my food comes from? Really, why?
- nmridul 14y agoTake it this way. While playing a computer game, my non-technical friends don't know how the game was written, how the buttons were designed, how the server is handling all those multiple players, or how the protocol handles all the communication. They don't try to see behind the scenes and so they just appreciate the game and nothing more. As a software engineer with whatever limited knowledge I have about those things, I'm able to appreciate the game at even more levels. When I see a perfectly flowing graphic I wonder how the coding was done and how much effort the developers put in for creating it or how did they even come up with such a use case. Or take the case of movies. Once you start understanding about the planning that goes behind the scenes and how such a great movie was made, you start to appreciate it even more. Whey did they keep the camera there ? Wow, they could have changed the lighting to this corner.... Same with life. The more you understand, the better you appreciate it.
- arthurrr 14y agoThe more you understand, the more you realize that most people aren't very good at what they do. Not that they are bad at what they do, either. It just takes the magic away.