13 ms·
Why a one-room West Virginia library runs a $20,000 Cisco router
- chayesfss 14y agoa company like cisco or microsoft trying to rip off state/local governments? color me not shocked.
- joenathan 14y agoWhat does Microsoft have to do with this?
- obstacle1 14y agoMSFT is big and a corporation, like CSCO; therefore both are evil. Pretty airtight logic.
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoBecause Microsoft is just as happy to sell overpriced packages of unnecessary functionality to clueless or corrupt government employees as Cisco is, and they have the extra property of arguing fervently against the use of free/open source software that competes against their offerings and would save even more.
- paganel 14y ago> What does Microsoft have to do with this? I don't have a source handy, but around 2004-2005 Steve Ballmmer came in a short visit to my country (somewhere in Eastern Europe), he had a even shorter meeting with the Prime Minister of that time and sure enough not 6 months later a Government programme was launched and all the schools and public libraries in my country had to be equipped with Windows machines. This was around the time when people thought that tools like Open Office actually had a chance of toppling the MS Office suite.
- poloniculmov 14y agoHey fellow countryman! What good would it do for kids in our country to learn Open Office, an office suit nobody uses in a workplace?
- mgkimsal 14y ago30 years ago, why would anyone have bothered to use MS Word when nobody used it in the workplace? Everyone used WordPerfect or WordStar. If you had a generation of kids who have experience with openoffice, it'll be much more likely that openoffice would be something that would be adopted over time - newly formed companies using it, gradual shift away from MS Office, etc. MS knows their history, and will continue to seed generations of users with low-cost/free stuff to keep their dominance going. If they quit doling out free copies, something like openoffice would gain a larger foothold in schools and eventually businesses in < 10 years. Would MS Office be entirely replaced? Of course not, but it would not be the default/automatic choice for everyone without question.
- poloniculmov 14y agoI don't think that's public education's role.
- mgkimsal 14y agoWhat isn't? Indoctrinating students in MS Office? Or OpenOffice? Or Apple products?
- poloniculmov 14y agoExactly. It should just teach the industry standard, which in this case is MS Office. It's not the education systems' role to push for open source solutions.
- polymatter 14y agowell, I am happy that some people might realize this was a bad idea after that auditors report showing approximately all $5 million was wasted. And also that Cisco's claim that "the state had reviewed his spreadsheets and not objected" is not a reasonable excuse.
- iamjason89 14y ago"The auditor began digging, speaking to many people in West Virginia state government who had been involved with the project. The Department of Education told him that it "did not request or require that the routers for the state's schools have internal dual power supplies. Education would not have made this requirement because unless a school has two power sources the feature of dual power supplies would have no use." A network engineer for the Department of Education confirmed that he had not requested such a feature." Education would not have made this requirement because unless a school has two power sources the feature of dual power supplies would have no use. Oh is that how redundant power supplies work? You need two power sources, eh?
- caw 14y agoFor full redundancy, yes. You get redundant power supplies by plugging both into the same power feed. However, you can gain some extra redundancy by plugging each power supply into a different circuit, and reducing the common point of failure (shared power source).
- nickzoic 14y agoTwo UPSes. Although I've got a good war story on that one too, I had a machine with redundant PSUs emit a stream of smoke from one of the PSUs. It was happily up and serving while smoking out the machine room until the operator (rather sensibly) grabbed both power leads and pulled, at which point both fire and ssh went out ...
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoIt is if you are in a situation in which the building power source is much, much more likely to fail than the power supply is, which is definitely the case in a rural school or library. You have to get to a pretty high level of sophistication (i.e. backup generators with automatic failover) before a redundant power supply has any value.
- hmottestad 14y agoIt would kinda be like buying a really expensive 24 port router and then just using 2 ports.....oh wait....that's what they did already. Dual power supplies is a bit overkill. Although I remember my high school admin got a central router with dual power supply, but when you plugged both in at once (from the same source) they drew too much power on a reboot and flipped the fuse after every blackout.
- joshlane4 14y agothis kind of nonsense is what people want to prevent the federal government from doing...bring on the sequester!
- tzs 14y agoIf this is the kind of nonsense you want to stop, that approach is ineffective to the point of idiocy.
- crusso 14y agoSince the sequester is really just a reduction of an increase and not really a cut, how is it ineffective? Seems like it's the only thing that even kind of looks like a cut that might go into effect in our lifetimes. Funny how the Feds were fine with a 2% increase in payroll taxes for consumers but a 2% cut in the increase of their budget is going to bring on Armageddon.
- pekk 14y agoI don't understand why people speak so fondly of things like education cuts. Reducing the absolute size of the budget and increasing revenue are both important for continuing to reduce the deficit. But almost every real problem with government is caused by the relative allocations of funds and how departments are managed, not the mere existence of funding for things like education or public health.
- tzs 14y ago> Since the sequester is really just a reduction of an increase and not really a cut, how is it ineffective? It may just be a reduction of an increase if you look at the TOTAL Federal budget, but for many individual agencies it is an actual deep cut to their budgets.
- nikcub 14y agoI have first hand experience with this, although in Australia. My first job was working for a IT development and solutions shop (this is over 17 years ago) where they won the bid to rollout the internet and network gateways across a large number of Australian government schools. We were doing similar work for private school at the same time, and the process for the public and private school could not be more different. For eg. in the tender process, which I was part of, for private school we would use cheaper Taiwanese routers. For the public schools it 'had to be Cisco'. The only time we ever used Cisco, outside of large enterprise clients with 1000+ seats, was with public school tenders. The private school would get a $500 white-label router, the public school s would get a $6-15k Cisco router with additional VPN module costs. We would charge a higher consultant rate on the Cisco jobs, and would bill 3 days instead of 1. We won the contract because we were 50% cheaper than the other tenders who all wanted to install 3 and 5-series routers. How we got to the point of being able to even tender is another story that involves somebody in our organization sleeping with somebody at the government organization. The other tenderers were accustomed to dividing the work up amongst themselves at inflated prices, they didn't even know who we were and we received a lot of abuse for breaking up their little scheme. (Edit: a further idea of how this worked, the 3 people in the gov office responsible for tenders all had very nice cars and holiday homes while the rest of the office was working away on below-average wages. You could see what was going on just by looking at the car park) So a dozen of us roll out hundreds of these routers in public schools and after a month we find that we rolled out the wrong version of IOS, one that was vulnerable to a simple security attack. Instead of forcing us to upgrade all the routers remotely, or out of our own pocket, we instead won another few-million-dollars worth of work to send a person out and apply the upgrade to each router (which took 5 minutes, we charged a full day plus travel). The routers weren't even being used properly - the topography was net connection -> cisco router -> internal server -> switches. The internal server would do all the DHCP and everything else. These expensive routers were being used as bridges, although they were pitched as having 'forward compatibility' incase the school wanted to implement features such as user accounts (they did, although again they used a custom server, not the router). When these projects are audited there is nobody who is technically competent enough to make an argument against who would be on the side of ditching or shrinking the projects. Some of the smarter teachers knew what was going on but didn't mind since they got access to fancy equipment (we would create user accounts for them). My first, and not my last, experience with government bureaucracy and budgets. I would estimate that the private schools got more out of us at a tenth of the cost. Since then I had an even worse experience with the government health department, where 6-figure invoices were written and paid for goods that didn't exist (that department has since been broken up and the subject of a large corruption enquire). No surprise that I became very anti-government size and spending. Edit: to add, we were so 'disruptive' to the backdoor deals that we were uninvited from conferences, kicked off panels, not invited to the mixer events where gov buyers met providers, a couple of years later we lost our accreditation[0] temporarily until we appealed to the Government Minister. On site we would be locked out of network cabinets, not given IP information for the net connections, etc. Our jobs were made difficult by competitors and others because of our pricing and methods. They couldn't figure out how they didn't get rid of us, because they didn't know that one of our guys had a solid relationship with somebody at the government (that person wanted to clean things up). Usually we wouldn't have been allowed anywhere near these projects and if we did win one we wouldn't be allowed back in for not playing with the system. [0] 'accreditation' for government tenders needs to die, it is a formal method used to keep honest operators out of what is essentially a cartel. The Australian government is getting better in this regard[1], they now have an open tender website but I believe it still requires some form of accreditation that has a person in a department standing between application and approval. [1] although not too much better. NBN Co., a government owned company that is building a $40 billion nation-wide fibre network recently suspended tender process because every single bid came in over the expected price: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/in-depth/high-prices-force-nbn-to-suspend-cabling-tender-process-and-look-elsewhere/story-e6frgaif-1226031831542 http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/in-depth/high-price...
- redshirtrob 14y agoI'd like to know how much of that $5 million savings would have been burned up in the capacity studies. My guess is a lot. Given the choice between a fixed cost and an unbounded cost (being the capacity study referenced throughout the article) I'm not surprised they went with the fixed cost. I'm not saying WV didn't get swindled, but I can sure see how this might have happened: WV Rep: Do we really need these $20k routers for all our locations? Cisco: We really couldn't say what your exact needs are without a proper study. WV Rep: What will that cost? Cisco: It's really hard to say. We'll have to visit all of your locations and speak with the IT Manager there. We'll have to measure average and peak load. Of course, we'll want to plan for future growth so we're not at this same point in two years... The real crime is that they didn't open the RFP to multiple bidders. A little bit of competition can go a long way.
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoActually, the real crime is that they don't sue Cisco to be allowed to exchange the original routers for new ones with appropriate capacity along with a refund in the price difference, with Cisco eating the depreciation and the legal fees. The grant implementers should also be fired for cause, to wit, incompetence).
- vidarh 14y agoHere's a capacity study for you: E-mail all the IT managers, and ask them: - How many users do you have? - What is the total size of the community you serve? - Do you need new equipment? That would have quickly revealed that many of them had so few users that these routers were total overkill, and had so few potential users that even 100% simultaneous usage in some cases would not max out the capacity, and that some of them did not have a need for new equipment. I agree with you that multiple bidders would be essential. But a tiny little bit of due diligence and investigation on the behalf of WV would have gone a long way. That said, sometimes this is what backfires too: I've seen a government contract recently where a lot of extra work was carried out to meet the requirements of a "security consultant" that refused to sign off on a system because of "issues" that were clearly generated only to ensure that he could pad his list of "problems" he identified to help justify his fees.
- noonespecial 14y agoIt seems absurd but I'm going to have to side with the state/library on this one. It can literally cost more to make a choice to use the cheaper unit than to just buy the big one. "Some libraries need smaller routers. Ok. Which ones?" could easily run in the millions before any routers were purchased. Unfortunately, that's just the nature of government purchasing.
- jessaustin 14y agoThis is bullshit. They could have put the network engineer from the Department (the guy who confirmed he had not requested dual power supplies) on this for a week, and he would have had a solid estimate for far less. Put him on it a month and he could have had an itemized order with the exact models to order from Cisco or from any of its competitors. If he were busy with other duties, any other network engineer in the state's employ could have done the same. If they were all too busy, a consultant could have been hired on for a month's engagement at two to three times the FTE cost.
- damian2000 14y agoAgreed - it sounded like the Cisco guy just spec'd up the absolute maximum needed for one or two locations, then just decided to roll out the same spec across all 1000+ locations, obviously trying to maximise sales. Cisco was probably shocked when the government approved it all.
- prawn 14y ago"Cisco was probably shocked when the government approved it all." Wouldn't that imply they hadn't succeeded with the same ploy before? I think that's unlikely!
- intended 14y agoI saw it differently. To me this looks like a situation where something was said verbally, and then no confirmation or follow up was given. Wanting to get the quote out, Cisco just made it and sent it. They assumed that it, and any other issues, would get sorted out when the quote got reviewed. The client slept. Cisco said "Good job sales team". It is always the job of the buyer to know what he is getting, for what he is paying.
- jessaustin 14y agoGosh, it seems like state bureaucrats can't figure out how best to spend money, and don't care to hire anyone who can. How might one's political preferences change in response to this shocking revelation?
- dustcoin 14y agoAlmost no one will change their preferences. Liberals will blame "evil corporations". Libertarians and conservatives will blame "big government".
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 14y agoI agree! I strongly suspect that if I lived in Denmark I would support the Danish system: clearly it's working well for them! When I lived in e.g. Singapore and Japan I witnessed those (different) systems working better than ours in many ways, to their credit. The few relative drawbacks I noticed I attribute to the different preferences of the populations (i.e. they aren't really drawbacks in the citizens' estimations). Just as clearly, our system of public officials and lobbyists does not work very well. Most Americans would claim to prefer that there be less wasted money. We just can't get there from here.
- mpyne 14y agoWell, think about it economically. What's the incentive for those who are skilled and capable to go into the public sector instead of private enterprise. Elections suck, the press sucks, your fellow public servants suck, having to deal with the general public, etc. etc. Some days I wonder how we don't seem to encounter tons more corruption and incompetence at all levels of the U.S. government.
- bluedino 14y agoRemember the wasteful spending back in the UNIX workstation days - a Sun 10 in every administrator's office for e-mail, and nobody ever had the training to use the things?
- hmottestad 14y agoMy high-school admin bought a Mac Pro with dual CPU. It was powerful enough to run all the school servers at once, yet he only used it to remote desktop into the real servers.
- WestCoastJustin 14y agoProbably going against the grain here, but what about the operations staff who are charged with supporting these 1,164 routers? What about warranties and parts replacements? There is a price for standardizing on a piece of hardware at such a large scale. When you standardize, sure there is going to be hardware overkill in some places, but in the big picture this is just a price of doing business at this scale. What is the price of service calls out to this location when the hardware is down? You have a tool-chain that supports this hardware, you have experts supporting the network (security, patching, etc), and you have contracts in place to make sure it is operational.
- rdl 14y agoThere's a point in standardizing, but they probably should have standardized on 2-3 different branch router products, vs. one.
- WestCoastJustin 14y agoYeah, I agree. I'm just saying I can kind of see where they are coming from.
- prawn 14y agoWho, Cisco? I wouldn't be excusing their actions in a hurry. Everyone in this deal should be advising as though they are spending their own money. You can spend a lot of money, but would you if it were you own and you had other things to consider in a budget?
- rdl 14y agoCisco was acting in their own commercial interest, which would be fine if their counterparty weren't either corrupt or incompetent. It's reasonable for an enterprise deployment to try to standardize on some components, which costs something in size-inefficiency. It's ok to spec a 2-5x bigger product for some sites if most other sites are bigger, and if the big/small products are wildly different, etc. But that's clearly not the case here. Arguably the state should have had in-house competence to spend money on the taxpayer's behalf, or should have engaged a contractor with fiduciary responsibility to design/spec the work (and excluded from bidding).
- EvanAnderson 14y agoI haven't something quite this egregious happen firsthand, but it fits the pattern for the interactions I've had when working for a "partner company" reselling big-name networking gear.
- homosaur 14y agoCorruption is awesome when you're on the nipple end of the government tit. Nice work if you can get it, Cisco.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoCisco may not have anything to do with it. It may be down to a salesman in the middle who is on commission. I once saw CCTV cameras deployed with Jena lenses, I guess for similar reasons. The auditors (if there were any) weren't knowledgeable enough to know better. edit: After further reading, Cisco did in fact shamelessly participate in this gigantic boondoggle.
- scotty79 14y agoIn my country government officials are usually paid to be this stupid. I can't imagine USA government officials are this stupid for free. I know ... never attribute to malice what can be sufficiently explained by stupidity, but come on! Someone sure got at least a nice car out of it.
- sneak 14y ago> I can't imagine USA government officials are this stupid for free. Hooo boy.
- sneak 14y ago> I can't imagine USA government officials are this stupid for free. Hooo boy.
- tdoggette 14y agoI chuckled. It is, in fact, quite easy to imagine that American bureaucrats (as a collective) are that stupid. I'm not discounting the other possibility, though.
- dontstealmyname 14y agoThis is the first thing I thought of when I read this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XTSCRoYyM-Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XTSCRoYyM-Y
- shalmanese 14y agoPrevious discussion on the issue with a lot of the same arguments that have been rehashed here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3962029 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3962029
- mrb 14y agoCisco: "the criticism of the State is misplaced and fails to recognize the forward-looking nature of their vision" My sarcastic retort would be: "no, you fail to recognize the forward-looking nature of their vision because you did not recommend this other even more expensive and more powerful router!"
- js2 14y agoMeh, I'm much more upset by the mountain top removal going on in WV, clearly visible in the satellite picture of Clay, WV included in TFA.
- jrockway 14y agoYou can blame Cisco for that, too. See, one of their interview questions is "How many teaspoons would it take to move Mt. Fuji," and they needed to do a small initial study.
- nicw 14y agoThis almost happened at the California State University (CSU) level. An RFP went out, Alcatel bid $22MM, Cisco $123MM. http://www.networkworld.com/news/2012/102512-cisco-csu-263711.html http://www.networkworld.com/news/2012/102512-cisco-csu-26371... ""Everybody had to comply with this spreadsheet," he said. "Every campus had two border routers, two cores, and two server farm switches. All the vendors had to propose exactly the same solution" based on the average number of servers deployed at each CSU campus. "All of this is based on exactly the same data to all of the vendors. It's exactly the same formula for all of the vendors.""
- rachelbythebay 14y agoOh, the FCC E-Rate program. So much corruption, so much waste. There were people who would purchase something for a school with the most % of kids on free or reduced price lunch, since that was used to set the "FCC match" percentage. So, if 90% of the kids were on that plan, we'd only pay 10% of the actual cost. So, they'd order something for the school with the highest percentage and would then park that equipment there for a year (to fulfill the requirement that it must be used there). A year later, they'd move it somewhere else. I wrote about this particular router instance last year and linked it with my own FCC story from the year before that. http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/05/08/router/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/05/08/router/
- yergi 14y agoThis is so old that it was on the frontpage of Digg before Reddit was popular.
- trout 14y agoVisualizing this conversation.. IT Director to Sales Guy: "We just got $20M in grant money for getting broadband across the state. Can you get me some numbers?" Sales guy to engineering team (partner or internal): "Hey I need lots of boxes. They've got 1300 sites." Engineering team: "Ok.. what do they need?" IT Director: "Pretty sure my network guy says everything has to have redundant power supplies and at least 1 ethernet connection. To do a survey for each site would take over a year due to bureaucracy, and I've got 3 months on this grant" Engineer to Sales guy: "Ok I built out those routers. Do they really need redundant power supplies everywhere? 3900's seem big." Sales guy: "Ya, that's what they said. Anyways this came out below budget. Thanks!" IT Director: "Looks to be under budget, meets our needs, thanks!" .. meanwhile IT management/engineers aren't involved. Somewhere, someone didn't slow this project down to do due diligence. That or somewhere buried in some document is a requirement for redundant power supplies, but that sounds less likely the case.
- vacri 14y agoThat is also a valid point - if the way your system is set up, it would cost more than the difference to send someone out for the survey to verify a cheaper model is enough, just throw in the higher model. Though in this particular case, it's clearly not what happened.
- intended 14y ago> Somewhere, someone didn't slow this project down to do due diligence In it a nutshell. If anything, there should have been multiple flags raised. 1) A ball park figure should have been estimated on what this should cost, broken down by equipment type. 2) That should have made it clear that switches would be fine for multiple use cases, and the overall estimate should have dropped. * 3) Back and forth with provider as haggling over components proceeds. Massive attention to detail would be shown here. 4) First quote received from Cisco. Due diligence proceeds, issues raised. Customers says NO, just to buy negotiation room. (fine they have a grant, maybe not so aggressive) 5) Updated quote, go back to 4 if issues. 6) Quote acceptance. Now monitoriing of execution. There should have been many opportunities for flags to have been raised, even before the quote was received. And most definitely after it would have crossed the ball park figure. * It looks like the clause for redundant power was what tripped it up. Someone said we need X, and then somehow it became the TRUTH for all routers/switches. So its entirely possible (if not likely) that Cisco said "based on your constraints, these are the only components which match your requirements", and the Government bought it. Which is face-palm/head-desk territory.
- ericcumbee 14y ago"did not request or require that the routers for the state's schools have internal dual power supplies. Education would not have made this requirement because unless a school has two power sources the feature of dual power supplies would have no use." What if one power supply fails? I expect better from ars.
- wilfra 14y agoNice commission for that sales rep. This is the dark side of enterprise sales. Microsoft and many others have surely done many such deals over the years - and paid out handsome bonuses to the reps/execs who made them happen.
- MertsA 14y agoJust nit picking but there are several places in the article that are incorrect such as "The West Virginia legislature at peak times can have over 600 internal users and numerous guests accessing "multiple Web servers, up to eight simultaneous live audio webcasts, multiple SQL servers, and multiple Google search appliances located in the Legislature's server farms." Despite all this, the legislature doesn't even use a router but instead runs a cheaper Cisco switch... and it has never exceeded capacity." It's pretty clear that not only does the author not know networking basics, his sources don't either.
- papsosouid 14y agoWhy is that clear? Cisco sells plenty of "layer 3 switches", they are switch hardware with basic routing functionality available in the IOS. It is entirely likely that the quote is referring to a catalyst 29xx or something which is like 1/10 the cost of the routers the article was talking about.
- guynamedloren 14y agoThis makes me sick to my stomach. The worst part is that there's nothing we (the taxpayers whose hard earned money went to to pay for these things) can do about it, nor is there much we can do to prevent it from happening in the future. I really really hate to admit it, but that's the truth.
- pekk 14y agoDid you consider any of the tools of democracy? Although it can take time, that should work just fine if most people actually agree on what to do. If you are in a minority of the population which wants to unilaterally impose its will on everyone else because they are more important, however - then I guess that democracy is no good and only an armed coup will do. Let's hope that people don't start thinking that way, because then we are all in trouble.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoWhat's worse than overpaying millions for a few routers? Overpaying billions. At the federal level, specifically to prevent such things from occurring, there's this huge byzantine procurement process. A process that is literally worth tens of billions of dollars to game. So if you have product foo and want to see a zillion copies of it to the feds instead of some freeware or cheaper solution? 1) Convince somebody on the inside of the procurement system that yours is the best product, 2) they write up the specification so that no other products will qualify (many times just copying directly from your brochure) even though it's technically an "open" bid, and 3) have somebody with lots of procurement knowledge help guide the paperwork through the system. At the end of the day, it's all just paperwork, no matter how much money is involved. And that's just what I've observed in IT. I'm guessing IT is the worst, since all the products somewhat look alike. But I'm not sure. Quite frankly, its way too depressing to think about much. BTW, the best way to do #1 is simply hire people retiring out of the procurement system. Yep, there are laws against direct hires, so you hire somebody from DoD to help shepherd a Commerce Department contract, or a DHS procurement expert to help with a DoD job, and so forth. If you do this correctly, the poor schmucks left handling the paperwork will be so happy that you can offer extensive support in making sure everything is done correctly that this is another huge plus in favor of your getting the bid.
- stdbrouw 14y agoThe trouble is that you actually do need some of this flexibility in the procurement process. If your department needs Photoshop, you don't want some goofy non-technical auditor telling you that he googled around and thinks GIMP will do just fine. Or you want one particular contractor because just last year they did an amazing job on something that was pretty much exactly what you need.
- jimmaswell 14y agogimp generally would do just fine, wouldn't it?
- yason 14y agoNothing is as expensive as free money.
- Tichy 14y agoStartup Mountain camp anyone? This sounds like a great place to host a hacker convention now?
- jeffdavis 14y agoI was surprised how much blame this article lays at the feet of Cisco. What did they do except sell the customer what they wanted? Sure, they might have been more noble if they put on the breaks in the name of the taxpayers, but that could hardly be expected. It takes a lot of nerve for someone who just wasted my money (federal dollars) to try to blame it on the other party for fulfilling the order.
- megablast 14y agoIt is not one or the other, it is both of them. If Cisco wants to be treated like untrustworthy rip off artists, then they acted the right way. People will take note.
- ripter 14y agoIf I go to an Apple store and buy a $3,000 computer is it apple's fault that I only needed an iPad? Hell no. I'm the one that ordered a $3,000 computer, signed off on the agreement, and forked over the cash. Cisco acted like a business, you can't blame them for that.
- SEMW 14y ago> Cisco acted like a business, you can't blame them for that Any time someone on hn complains about some business ripping them off, some variant of this comment usually gets posted. And it completely misses the point. The point isn't moral blameworthiness. It's sharing of information. Some people may prefer to buy from a company they believe they can trust to give good advice about which of their products will meet their needs best. Others may not care about that and will buy just on the basis of the product. A company happy to sell products they know are overkill is making a business decision, to increase profit in the short term at the risk of losing the former kind of customer in the long term. So reacting to criticism of a company overselling by defending their right act that way in a market is confused. The goal isn't armchair moralising, it's sharing information about them so that people can make more informed choices about who to do business with.
- 14y ago
- jgoney 14y agoBefore I read the article, I was hoping for a feel-good piece about how someone hacked together a massive WiFi system using such a router to supply Internet to some isolated community in rural West Virginia. It didn't turn out to be exactly that.
- meaty 14y agoThis doesn't suprise me. I am related to an ex-sales exec at Cisco UK. They are a bunch of shysters who will desperately oversell anything to anyone. The person in question was responsible for selling such kit to managers who didn't even know what it was but they apparently needed it. You know the sort who populate senior positions in the public sector. They are rife in the healthcare and council sectors in the UK. Incompetent morons waiting to be milked for our cash. The asshat is now selling VoIP and video conferencing solutions to medium sized businesses (via their executives) which is the next cash cow he can milk.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hiddenfeatures 14y agoMaybe I should get myself checked, but is anyone else thinking about the big opportunity here? You wouldn't need more than your average crow bar to get into this thing. I bet they don't have a decent alarm system (if any). Seems like a relatively low-risk, high-reward situation to me.
- gritzko 14y agoWell, just another me-too story. When I was somewhat younger I had to "deploy" one Cisco product which was definitely a result of an "incentivized" sale. That sweet sweet setup involved login-password authorization (assisted by a Cisco router) where the user had to type in "public" and "1" as a password because... the enterprise actually had no end-user accounts and absolutely no possibility to introduce them... As far as I understand, such an incentivized sale was a common practice. Once the management somehow achieved consensus (i.e. the right balance of risks, benefits and favors), engineers were left with making things appear OK. I am inclined to think that Cisco made a strong bet on this kind of a business model at some point.
- g2bsocial 14y agoBurn in hell, CISCO, bunch of pricks.
- g2bsocial 14y agoOK, the "Burn in hell" comment added little value, and so the downvotes from Mods understandable, but take into account I'm a West Virginian, and this is genuinely upsetting to us.
- rlpb 14y agoFrom the article: > the legislative auditor concluded that the company "had a moral responsibility"... Since when do corporations have any kind of responsibility, other than to make as much profit as possible? Expecting anything else is futile. If something needs to be fixed, it is in mechanisms to restrain this kind of behaviour where it is in the public interest. Demanding that corporations have morals is not the solution.
- mgkimsal 14y agoIf corporations have the concept of 'personhood' attributable, they can probably have the concept of 'moral responsibility' attributed as well.
- EliRivers 14y agoIn some countries corporations effectively do have morals and it does seem to work for them. Many German companies see themselves as a partnership between employees, customers and society.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThere is positive corruption and nevative corruption Positive corruption does the right thing (build roads, install broadband into poor communities) but adds cost Negative corruption distorts right thing so much it simply does not happen (communities never get proper triads or sewage because they are the wrong tribe) The broadband is the thing - good. If you don't want government to overpay I suggest Cisco routers is the last thin to look at - start with military contracts
- mich41 14y agoReminds me of new EU members. Joining the EU was advertised as source of funds for development and catching-up with the West and now a benchmark of politicians' "performance" is how much funds are they able obtain for their electorate - the more is spent, the better. In extreme cases one didn't even have to bribe officials to get bogus contracts because if the city didn't find a way to spend all the money it was offered, it would simply get less.
- mgkimsal 14y agoDidn't read the entire post - is there some reason the state or local municipalities can't sell this stuff on ebay, get lower-powered hardware to match their needs, and pocket the diff for the locality's coffers?
- yaddayadda 14y ago"For those keeping score at home, this means that 75 $20,000 routers are depreciating in a state police warehouse somewhere in West Virginia." So we should be seeing 74 Cisco 3945 routers on eBay very soon. (My commission for this idea is 1 Cisco 3945 router.)
- SpikeGronim 14y agoI saw the exact same thing with Cisco in the NY public school system. They gave my high school something like $50,000 of equipment in a rack to support two machines that submitted grades. We stripped it for parts and put it to better use, it had some really nice switches in it. But it was clearly misspent public money. At least we did put it to use in classrooms, though not as they intended.
- njx 14y agoThis could have been executed by the process "Wired RFP". just look for the this term and you will see references where government RFPs are wired to specific vendor. In other sense, no other vendor may qualify to bid based on the RFP requirement. For e.g RFP bidding/winning criteria is based on point system. 1. Price accounts for 25% 2. Referrals from similar orgs 40% and so on you see, when the price in the RFP accounts less then it is an indication that the RFP is wired to a specific vendor. A small business who is just starting may or may not have 3 or more referrals from a public school or university. In one of the RFP process I sat, the RFP had a typo where they had literally spelled out the name of a competitor company. I pointed out this in the pre-bidding call and the personnel acknowledged that it was a mistake. Government RFP are a waste of time because it is the last step the government does in their purchasing process. They have already chosen the vendor and most of the time the vendor helps them write the RFP. Fixing the RFP process may eliminate some of the overspending.
- emperorcezar 14y agoI grew up in West Virginia. I also was pretty involved in the computer operation at my high school. The "head" of IT was a math teacher they suckered into doing all the work. Anyhow. I remember when they decided they needed a domain server. What they eventually came back with was a two year old model HP tower server that ran over $4k. It was insane. They could have gotten something new for much much less, but all the explanation I could get was that they had a contract and had to buy the items listed in that contract. There is a culture of corruption and it is prevalent in not only the public, but also the private sector. Another story is when I was in a diner years later and heard my old social studies teacher asking for a bribe from someone to get a job in the coal mines. I felt pretty bad because I believe he got his money and thus his power from years before when I told him to buy Google and others stock.
- crazygringo 14y ago> Getting any of the money back seems unlikely at this point, but the legislative auditor does have one solid recommendation to make. The State Purchasing division should determine whether Cisco's actions in this matter fall afoul of section 5A-3-33d of the West Virginia Code, and whether the company should be barred from bidding on future projects. Cisco is a public company with a fiduciary duty to make money. You should assume that companies are going to try to fleece you whenever possible. Unless they committed some kind of contractual breach or fraud, they're not the problem. The fault here is clearly with one or multiple people in the government. This is the kind of gross misconduct for which it feels like firing isn't even close to enough -- this kind of managerial incompetence really deserves at least a short stint in a white-collar prison somewhere.
- papsosouid 14y agoThis should surprise no one. This sort of nonsense is the entire reason cisco exists as a company. Their products are underpowered, overpriced, and their software is incredibly unreliable. Scamming big entities with closed bid processes into buying millions of dollars worth of equipment is cisco's bread and butter.
- marcoperaza 14y agoCaveat Emptor. Cisco is out to make as much money as they can, they have no duty to save the government money. West Virginia's procurement process was irresponsible and wasteful and now they want to shift the blame to Cisco in order to cover their own incompetence. If you overpay for something, it's your fault.
- jlarocco 14y agoHaving worked on a government contract before, this doesn't surprise me at all. They were going to spend all the money the feds gave them. Whether they spent it on over powered routers or "consulting" or something else, it was all going to be spent by the end of the project. There are enough projects overbudget that being on budget looks really good. And there's always a concern with being under budget that next time the feds won't hand out so much money, and you might really need it then.
- ripter 14y ago'The auditor's office sent off a fairly testy e-mail to Cisco noting that the 3945 routers were not appropriate for most West Virginia deployments—even according to Cisco's own literature. "I would appreciate an explanation as to why you believe the 3945 routers are not oversized and misconfigured for hundreds of locations," the auditor concluded, "and, thus, a significant over expenditure of millions of dollars for Cisco equipment."' Did I miss some part where they contracted Cisco to visit every location and assess it's needs and build an order according to that? If you order a bunch of 3945 routers then why is it Cisco's fault for selling you a bunch of 3945 routers?