4 ms·
Noncircumstantial evidence is evidence which directly supports the point for which it is introduced, without any inference required. Circumstantial evidence is
by gamblor956 14y ago
Noncircumstantial evidence is evidence which directly supports the point for which it is introduced, without any inference required.
Circumstantial evidence is evidence which requires a logical inference in order to support the point for which it is introduced.
That is roughly how evidence is explained by judges to juries in courtrooms.
For example, the victim's blood on the defendant's shoe is noncircumstantial evidence because it directly supports the point that the defendant was present in the vicinity of the victim's body. However, finding at the crime scene a brown fiber which is same type of fiber used to stich the defendant's very expensive, limited edition gloves, would be circumstantial evidence because you have to logically infer that the fiber found comes from the defendant's gloves. Alternatively, finding gloves that are identical to the defendant's gloves is also circumstantial evidence unless there is other evidence showing conclusively that those particular gloves are the defendants, i.e., footage of the defendant leaving the gloves there or something.
- mikeash 14y agoIt all requires inference, though. The legal system just pretends that some inference comes "for free", and some doesn't. You never have "the victim's blood on the defendant's shoe", you have blood which you have reason to believe belongs to the victim on shoes you have reason to believe belong to the defendant. The only actual difference between your two examples is that of degree, i.e. the evidence linking the blood to the victim is much stronger than the evidence linking the fiber to the defendant.
- Dylan16807 14y agoWhat about when the defense agrees that it is in fact the victim's blood? Many things in a trial are stipulated to be true.
- dllthomas 14y agoInteresting question, but doesn't quite seem to be the difference between hard and circumstantial evidence.
- Dylan16807 14y agoNot by itself, but if you use it to discount negligible uncertainty then you can use it as a method to reach 'direct' aka non-circumstantial evidence.
- dllthomas 14y agoI don't know. It seems like the defense can stipulate things that are nonetheless circumstantial evidence. Like, if the defendant acknowledges being in the area at the time, the prosecution no longer needs to deal much with evidence that establishes that, but that's still not "direct evidence" of the crime. However, the main point of this thread of discussion I think was that even things that legally are considered "direct evidence" - say, testimony of an witness to the crime - do nonetheless involve some inference...
- psb217 14y agoYour choice of examples actually supports the statistical nature of the distinction between circumstantial and noncircumstantial evidence. That the blood on the defendant's shoe came from the victim's body is based on a probabilistic test. That the blood on the defendant's shoe arrived through physical co-presence of the shoe and the blood's source body (whether or not it was the victim's) is also only "hard" evidence in the sense that other explanations are relatively improbable. The difference between the probabilities involved in the above inferences, and the analogous inferences ineluctably underlying any hard evidence, and those involved in circumstantial evidence like your coat fiber, are purely quantitative. In some sense, hard evidence is that which can be accepted "beyond a reasonable doubt", while circumstantial evidence is that which does not pass such a test. Unfortunately, "beyond a reasonable doubt" escapes precise definition. Yet, courts need to function, so we tacitly agree that sufficiently large quantitative differences are (legally) indistinguishable from qualitative differences. (EDIT: I'm saying the same thing as mikeash, whose response appeared while I was writing my own)
- gamblor956 14y agoYou guys still aren't getting it; circumstantial evidence is not about the probability that the evidence is what it claims to be, it is about the necessary inference about what the evidence proves if the evidence is what it claims to be. Noncircumstantial evidence directly supports the point for which it is introduced if the evidence is what it claims to be. The victim's blood on the defendant's shoe directly supports the point that the defendant was in the victim's presence when the victim was dying if it is established that the blood is the victim's blood. Circumstantial evidence requires an additional inference beyond this step. The fibers are circumstantial because the fiber doesn't prove anything except that the someone wearing those gloves might have been at the crime scene at some point in time. You require the additional inference that the fiber was left at the scene at the time of the crime, which the fiber by itself does not prove but which can be "circumstantially" proved in combination with other evidence. For example, if the defendant, or some other witness, claims that the defendant was never at the scene of the crime at any point in time (specifically, but not limited to, periods prior to the crime), the presence of the rare fibers from his rare gloves is circumstantial evidence that the only time he was at the scene of the crime was when the crime occurred. In other words, the circumstances surrounding the fiber are the proof, not the fiber itself.