10 ms·
Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote
- bsg75 14y agoYahoo! proving it still does not get it? Or perhaps finding ways of shedding employees without actual layoffs?
- pbh101 14y agoCheck this post from StackExchange [1]. One of the things I definitely took away from it is that while working remotely has benefits and affords flexibility to employees and employers, it incurs very real costs that have to be mitigated and accounted for. Making an explicit choice one way or the other can be better than muddling through halfway. [1] http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2013/02/why-we-still-believe-in-working-remotely/ http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2013/02/why-we-still-believe-i...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- citricsquid 14y agoDoes not get what? Remote employees are a commitment, a company cannot just have remote employees without making compromises and committing to doing it right. Mayer is trying to rescue Yahoo, if the remote employees are not providing enough value to justify that investment in remote workers then it makes no sense for Yahoo to retain remote workers.
- sabat 14y agoRemote employees are a commitment So are on-site employees, who can screw off just as much as an off-site one. if the remote employees are not providing enough value to justify that investment in remote workers Then fire them. This kind of draconian move won't get Yahoo anything but an even bigger talent hemorrhage than it already has.
- cglee 14y ago> Then fire them. That's exactly what will probably happen if they don't comply. I think giving people an opportunity to comply before firing is a good move.
- jaggederest 14y agoNo, it's a terrible idea. The ones that don't have any other options will stay ( you retain a higher percentage of people who are not top performers ), the rest that you would want to keep leave ( the best employees can just get another remote job right away ) This is the classic problem with voluntary buyouts and other discretionary layoffs - you only keep the people without other options.
- btilly 14y agoIt happens on its own over time as well. See http://brucefwebster.com/2008/04/11/the-wetware-crisis-the-dead-sea-effect/ http://brucefwebster.com/2008/04/11/the-wetware-crisis-the-d... for a fuller description.
- YZF 14y agoI think he meant fire them if they don't provide value. If they're remote and do provide value keep them remote.
- encoderer 14y agoWha? So they were wrong to give them a warning that they are expected to relocate to an office? They should've just fired them? That's really how you feel?
- sabat 14y agoThey're wrong to equate being remote with not producing value. If people are not producing value for the company, sure, fire them. If they are doing well, then why force them to relocate? What's the business sense in that?
- photorized 14y agoThat won't rescue Yahoo. Look at some open source initiatives - thousands of people "working remotely", while still being able to collaborate and ship. Yahoo's issues lie way deeper than that.
- taligent 14y agoExactly. Every single person talking about how working remotely doesn't work can be refuted by open source. And why does no one talk about how working in an office reduces productivity. I know I get far more done at home.
- bsg75 14y agoYahoo, which once was a place talented people wanted to work at (I have worked with some very bright ex-Yahoo-ers), is fighting for relevance which in part requires talented people. Getting good folks to bet on a potentially sinking ship requires the appearance that it is not an unpleasant place to work. The commitment is on both sides, employer and employee. When many companies are shedding old traditions (like the one Mayer is instating) to attract talent, Yahoo seems to be doing the opposite in this move, less attractive to _current_ employees. If you can't manage remote employees well enough to weed out those who do not produce, or you believe that dead weight will not still be dead weight when you move it in office, you just don't get it.
- mansigandhi 14y agoIf that's true, it's just plain stupid.
- negamax 14y agoYahoo has given ~50% returns since August last year.
- dillonforrest 14y agoLet's not assume that public equities indicate good decision-making! :)
- mkarazin 14y agoI've seen this happening with other companies recently. There may be a small trend away from remote working. I agree its unfair to the employee who was hired on flexibility, but I don't think it is a bad move for Yahoo. It takes a very specific type of individual to work at home with the same efficiency as in an office.
- sabat 14y agoIt takes a very specific type of individual to work at home with the same efficiency as in an office Yes, one who knows how to communicate. But you wouldn't want an on-site employee who doesn't communicate, either.
- sabat 14y agoE.g. -- someone posted a link here to an article in which they describe using Google Hangouts for everything. There's a permanent one that everyone is on all damn day. There are special, throwaway hangouts for asides and meetings and anything else that might be needed. You don't need to be in person, and many people would surprised how effective teams can be even when they're not in the same room. All it takes is good communication, and by that I mean: 1- good communication technology, like a good net connection and good chat software and good cameras, 2- good use of technology for communication (IM software is not sufficient), and 3- good communication practices (which amounts to: communicate early, communicate often).
- UnoriginalGuy 14y ago> It takes a very specific type of individual to work at home with the same efficiency as in an office. Does it? If I want to slack off I find it just as easy in the office as I do at home. Heck I can even have music on at work or stream a video. Frankly for me I find home working far less distracting than work. Work is noisy, people are coming and going, there are calls all around me, at home it is just me in a dark office only interrupted by things aimed specifically at me (Skype, e-mail, etc). But this all boils down to the same old 1900s time mythos. You take intellectual workers and hold them to standards created for factory workers. The theory goes that if I work longer I am more efficient. If they restrict access to distractions then I am more efficient. If they can look over my shoulder I am more efficient. Personally I think this is all nonsense. The only way to track my efficiency is with milestones. The nice thing about milestones is that they are metrics which are flexible. If you fail to meet them you have a two way discussion about /why/.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThis isn't particularly surprising, the policy at Google was (possibly still is) much the same. The theory is that you don't interact enough with your peers if you're not face to face. I wonder if secret calibration scores are next.
- mtrimpe 14y agoWhat are those secret calibration scores? It sounds very Orwellian...
- tankenmate 14y agoShakesperean, stack ranking by another name...
- asveikau 14y agoSounds like something that turns companies into Microsoft.
- jodrellblank 14y agoShipping mountains of high quality popular software at regular intervals? Sounds just what Yahoo! needs.
- g8oz 14y agoMore accurately: missing industry wide shifts because of infighting and backstabbing amongst teams and individuals.
- cgh 14y agoHave you ever worked at or with MS? If so, you'd know that stack ranking is the reason MS has flopped in just about every field it's entered for the last decade.
- gradys 14y agoWould you mind expanding on this a bit? How exactly does it contribute to Microsoft's performance in new fields? This is a completely genuine question. I'm not an apologist just trying to defend MS in a roundabout way.
- smackfu 14y agoYahoo has 11,500 employees. This affects "several hundred". So... Yahoo was not big on remote employees.
- sliverstorm 14y agoBeing a news article, I am assuming they did their best to make it sound dramatic. In other words, "several hundred" probably translates to 307 remote workers. Still technically accurate, but a much less impressive headline.
- javajosh 14y agoIn the midst of cultural upheaval in a large company, this doesn't seem like an unreasonable move, at least in the short term. I can see how the inherent disconnectedness of remote employees might make a general sense of disconnectedness worse for the onsite employees. If Yahoo! can redefine itself clearly, this "disconnectedness infection" would find a far less vulnerable host. (People that were hired under the assumption that they'd be allowed to WFH indefinitely have my profound sympathies!)
- signed0 14y agoI wonder how many of them would have moved voluntarily if Yahoo offered to give them a bonus + pay for relocation expenses.
- 001sky 14y agoKara Swisher has "issues" with M. Mayer. The typical ~snarky undertone oozes from this article (and everything else she writes for All Things D on the subject). She was a great reporter for the WSJ 10 years ago, though.
- textminer 14y agoI've noticed people taking note of and commenting on Kara Swisher's take-charge, arrogant, brusque nature far more often than with many male tech journalists. Unexamined bias, or an expectation that female correspondents be softer and nicer?
- dylangs1030 14y agoIt could also be the converse - that women are conceived as "bitchy" and there is confirmation bias.
- TallGuyShort 14y agoIn this case I don't believe it's sexism for one minute. Allthingsd (and specifically this author, I believe) are very well-known for aggressively publishing and criticizing leaks from Yahoo. Any motivations behind such a tactic would certainly bleed through into the aforementioned writing style.
- timrpeterson 14y ago@textminer, wrong. kara swisher is just a jerk. jerk-iness knows no gender.
- gertef 14y agoSwisher is married to a Google VP. That is the conflict of interest.
- rm999 14y agoI certainly understand not hiring remote workers, but the transition will probably destroy value, especially if exceptions aren't allowed. A previous company of mine instituted a similar policy, and it was somewhat painful for my small team because we lost an experienced member who by all measures was amazing at her job. Fully replacing her probably cost a man year in value between the extra work for the rest of us and training someone new. And of course it was painful for her, as she had to find a new job after being promised her position was secure.
- jchrisa 14y agoMy startup sells database software to other coders. I think for this kind of startup, remote people are essential. They can get a perspective on your product and the perception of it in the marketplace, that you just can't get when you set in a room with the makers all day. That is, they see the world more like our users do, so it's often the remote folks who come up with big innovations.
- bborud 14y agoAm I the only one who thinks we should know more before we get our panties in a bunch?
- tantalor 14y ago> employees... must either comply without exception or presumably quit Why quit? More likely they would be terminated with benefits.
- unreal37 14y agoMore likely they will have to quit if they don't want to drive into the office every day... They all have an office they belong to presumably. It's not a big stretch to ask them to go there Monday to Friday.
- stephencanon 14y ago> They all have an office they belong to presumably. It's not a big stretch to ask them to go there Monday to Friday. I work for a different large company in SV, and live 3,100 miles away from my office. Suffice to say, it would be a big stretch to go there Mon-Fri.
- tantalor 14y agoLet's suppose they decide to continue working from home despite the policy change, so the company fires them. Is it for cause?
- jpdoctor 14y agoAlmost certainly. It is a rare employee employment letter that will have such a thing immutably set in stone. The most likely scenario though is a layoff package. Even at a few weeks pay, it's still less than the legal costs.
- danielweber 14y agoDepending on the details, it may be constructive dismissal. But it really depends on the details.
- mathrawka 14y agoAnd turning down that job offer to work remote was a great idea. I was worried that they would suddenly require me to work from their HQ all of a sudden, and that was my only reason for turning down the job. I feel sorry for the current employees that got sucker punched... but honestly, a majority of the good ones are long gone.
- talklittle 14y ago> I was worried that they would suddenly require me to work from their HQ Out of curiosity, were you given any indication this would happen? Or were you drawing from Google's similar policy?
- mathrawka 14y agoIt was just the feel of the conversation. This was 2 years in the past though. Me: "I'd like to work remotely from Japan" Them: "We can't allow remote positions now" Me: "I can't move to the US for family reasons" Them: "Let me check with HR" One week later Them: "We will let you work remotely, when can you start?" Just something was off it felt like. There was more talk than that of course, and a meeting when I was actually at HQ in CA for other reasons.
- eurodance 14y agoAs an engineer, this makes me have less desire to be with Yahoo. This move is like something a parent would do to a group of kids they couldn't trust to do their job without supervision. How about they just bring in, or fire the bad remote employees? Why risk punishing quiet, smart guys (who might be slightly introverted) who serve important purposes? Our company has remote employees, and most of them are brilliant.
- MartinCron 14y agoI have mixed feelings on the subject of remote teams, but I have very very strong feelings about this sort of bait and switch. Having a "no new remote workers" policy would feel a lot better to me than this.
- unreal37 14y agoThe article doesn't say that people were hired and promised 100% remote work. More likely, they have an office with their name on it already and they just have the ability to work from home whenever they want and so they never come in. I don't see this as a bait-and-switch unless there's something to back that up.
- damncabbage 14y agoWhen I worked there, I took the job because of the flexible work-from-home-when-you want policy, which I hadn't encountered for. I'd certainly be feeling baited-and-switched right now if I hadn't already left.
- rburhum 14y agoThat company is dying and it needs drastic changes to get it back to what it once was. Those changes are bound to piss off a lot of people, but the alternative is to continue on the same downhill route. Mayer is trying to change the cultural problems she perceives. I have a different opinion about that particular change she is making, but that doesn't matter... Good for her. I hope it works.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- edderly 14y agoMaybe this tells you more about Mayer's lack of trust of Yahoo's (maybe former) managers that she wouldn't trust their recruiting decisions. Personally, I do believe that remote employees can work well but it is a very selective decision.
- OldSchool 14y agoIt didn't seem possible but I now like Yahoo even less. A 38 y/o CEO of a company that sells the "connected" world won't use the same connectedness within the business? This is why you don't leverage yourself to the hilt and live paycheck to paycheck - so you can quit a job if it sucks.
- cgh 14y agoAs someone who has worked full-time remote since 2006, I agree completely. There are plenty of ways to be a part of the team and be remote - in fact, I doubt 30 minutes goes by in my day when I'm not either on the phone or IM'ing with someone about some issue. It's the equivalent of stopping by my desk to talk about something.
- alexanderh 14y agoAs someone who lives in a small remote city, and is broke and really cant consider moving right now, the thought of less job opportunities out there in other states at good companies that would allow me to work remotely really discourages me. This was one of the biggest promises of the internet. The only way I would be able to climb out of this place is if I could start by working remotely somewhere. There are no tech jobs where I am.
- LarrySDonald 14y agoYahoo has been in it's death throes for quite a while. I'm sure they'll survive in a sort of AOL sense, but they are quite desperate to stay relevant. News is likely their last outpost and even that is starting to slip very fast. It's sad to see, what used to be a crack directory, social hub (besides AOL one of the first true social networks), email, map and IM providers is now barely an afterthought and throwing the next cool "stand back I got this" manager to the wolves. But I can understand the frustration. Google and Apple both would have been happy to snap it up at one point, but it's too late and there is zero value left in the company besides the really nice Yahoo! name, and there's no big name to sell it to beyond perhaps AT&T or someone else that may want the infrastructure for something.
- agent86 14y agoThe one part I do not understand about all of this comes when you have a company with multiple locations and work that crosses locations. Say you have east coast and west coast facilities. If people only worked within their local facility, I can see the reasoning and advantages. What I don't understand is where the value is when the work crosses facilities. What you would need to do to bridge the gap between the workers in the different facilities is the same thing you should do to bridge the gap between remote workers. How is having people that need to work together in separate facilities any better than the people working remotely?
- edderly 14y agoFunny thing is, the different facilities are probably more problematic than remote workers. It can be more prone to politics and the organisation as a whole pulling in different directions. The exception is where the remote does have some well defined autonomous reason for existing, for example a sales office. In comparison remote workers obviously are usually tied to a particular office.
- TallGuyShort 14y agoThere's a shortage of people who still want to work at Yahoo. I used to be one of them but they pulled a similar stunt with me and decided to change the terms of my hiring long after I had accepted an offer. Obviously we don't have all the details, but I don't think this was a smart move to attract new talent.
- mikec3k 14y agoBest comment: "Yahoo continues its impressive drive down the fast lane of the information superhighway. In your father's Oldsmobile. With the left blinker on. At 45kph."
- waltz 14y agocan someone explain to me why yahoo is still relevant?
- cgh 14y agoIs Yahoo Finance still pretty good?
- opinali 14y agoThey still have tons of users / page views: http://advertising.yahoo.com/article/my-yahoo.html http://advertising.yahoo.com/article/my-yahoo.html
- stevewilhelm 14y agoHere are about a billion reasons: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=YHOO+Income+Statement&annual http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=YHOO+Income+Statement&an...
- sybhn 14y agoAs much as i hate to say it, probably the right thing to do to get a fresh grip on allocation & performance. I work at a place that frowns upon WFH and really wish it wasn't the case, my team would be 50% more productive if WFH few days a week. From my experience, lazy/bad managers find it much harder manage remote team, and often advocate no WFH policies.
- stanleydrew 14y agoI can certainly understand why current employees hired under the assumption that they could work from home are upset. But the fact of the matter is that if working from home isn't in your employment contract, then you shouldn't really count on it being acceptable forever. A company has a right to change its mind, in the same way that an employee might. If an employee of Company X demanded to work from home two days a week for some reason otherwise he'd quit, Company X managers would weigh the cost of losing the employee against the cost of having him absent two days a week. And then they would make a decision. I don't see how this is any different. Yahoo! has decided that being on site is a priority. Current employees may feel differently. These employees should weigh the cost of moving or commuting against the cost of finding new employment and make a decision.
- ryguytilidie 14y agoAll of that makes sense, but imagine you were hired away from a job at a great company within the last year. You probably can't go back, you haven't vested and you're essentially being pushed out after you were lured there with the promise of being able to work remotely. I understand that these people are free to quit, but that doesn't mean Yahoo! hasn't put them in a bad situation.
- stanleydrew 14y agoI agree it's worse when a company does it to an employee. Being forced into changing a job can have major negative effects on an individual's life, whereas Yahoo! will probably be just fine if any single person decides to quit. It doesn't change the fact that it can happen, and this is a good reminder to the rest of us who have things promised verbally in an employment offer to have that stuff in writing. I am writing this as a warning to others and my future self.
- autarch 14y agoI think remote works best when everyone on a team is remote. At my current employer, we have 6 people on our tech team. All except 2 of us are in different places. This forces us to figure out how to work effectively using chat, wiki, project management tools, etc. When only a few people on a team are remote I've found that it just doesn't work as well. I imagine it could work but it would take very strong discipline from the people in the office.
- dlowe 14y agoI've been telecommuting for 10 years. When I'm the only remote employee, and there isn't a culture of remoteness, I believe it's my job to have the discipline and do the extra work to stay connected, not the rest of the team's. It's a challenging dynamic, but it's not impossible, and I just don't think it's reasonable to expect the entire team to adapt to the exceptional case, instead of the other way around.
- codex_irl 14y ago+1 to that. I have been working 100% remotely, full time for a client based in Europe for 4 years now - I've never met the people on my team in person & we only have a 3 hour overlap in terms of working hours. I expect myself to be at least as productive as when I was in the office and then some - to eliminate any doubts people might have. Its very easy for my boss to tell how I'm doing....just take a look at my git log. Not sure I could ever commute 5 days to work & sit in a cubicle or open plan office (those places remind me of a Chinese factory floor)....they would have to pay me a LOT of money to endure that again.
- lsc 14y agoyeah, when I was at yahoo, the one guy who worked from home (well, we all did on occasion, but the one guy who always worked from home) was really, really good; My feeling was that he was good enough that he was able to say "let me work from home or I walk" - I don't know if he would have been more effective if he was in the office all the time or not, but he was probably the most effective person on the team as it was.
- 14y ago
- googoobaby 14y agoThis is simply stupid and arbitrary as well. I was hired into a mostly remote group by a very large, nominally staid, East Coast tech company and it works very well. We're in constant communication with our own group and with the vast majority of non-remote people around the world. I can't imagine having my life structured like this and being told to move across country or else.
- flipstewart 14y agoThis is a very sneaky way of performing mass layoffs.
- christopheraden 14y agoI work at a Fortune50, and I have to admit that if Mayer manages to turn Yahoo around that this will set a dangerous precedent for other large companies. The ability to work remotely is a huge perk to having a tech job, and if other corporations see Yahoo killing WFH and then managing to save such a large sinking ship, they might infer causality. Until Yahoo actually becomes successful as a whole again, this is just them thrashing about desperately. I'll be worried if we start to see success in Mayer's methods.
- mindcrime 14y agoI work at a Fortune50, and I have to admit that if Mayer manages to turn Yahoo around that this will set a dangerous precedent for other large companies. The ability to work remotely is a huge perk to having a tech job, and if other corporations see Yahoo killing WFH and then managing to save such a large sinking ship, they might infer causality. That's an interesting point. Up until now, I've thought of the Yahoo situation as a "I don't have a dog in this fight" kind of scenario... ie, I'm a mildly interested outsider with no stake in the whole thing. And since I usually like to root for the underdog, I have been hoping for a meaningful recovery for Yahoo under Mayer. This is making me reconsider that position a bit.
- ericflo 14y agoWhat if there is actually causality there?
- fzzzy 14y agoHow would it be possible to determine that it wasn't just correlation? It's not like we have 5 yahoos we can run a controlled study on.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoIf they crash, can we assume causality there too?
- dba7dba 14y agoOnce you allow a wholesale remote working in a big company, you really should NOT reverse it. The management may see it like a cost saving measure like cutting salary by 5-10% or capping max vacation days one can take. However there are so many OTHER IMPORTANT factors in an employee's life, such as mortgage, kids, family, etc etc that the employees have to deal with. And these are things people on regular salary cannot change on a whim. For people with millions of bucks in bank, sure such changes are easy to make. But for most, it's very hard to deal with.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoRemote is how the future of work looks. Pulling remote workers in is a sign you cannot measure the value of the output of remote workers - and it is not going to get any easier when they are filling up your corridors
- droithomme 14y agoAbsolutely true. Inability to handle remote workers is a undeniable red flag of incompetent management structure that has no clue how to manage, what is productive work, or how to evaluate who is contributing.
- wladimir 14y agoThat was, at least for me, the promise of all this communication technology, and one of the reasons for me to go into software: to work from home or any other place, spend more time with people I care about, no more commuting, no need to sit in a boring fluorescent lighted room for 8+ hours a day. It really feels like business is taking a wrong turn lately. Back to reduced independence of workers and patriarchal policies. They decide what's good for you, and the office is a nice cosy place to be with your fellow workers, sit in this chair and you'll be sooo productive! Instead of deciding someones merit on the quality and timeliness of their work. I suppose it's a sign of the times, to not take even small risks anymore, even if people end up better for it. Not to look at individual merit but take rash decisions. It's all about squishing the last bits of productivity using "proven" methods (dating from the industrial revolution?), which may just as well be self-defeating in the end. After all, remote working does allow picking the person with exactly the right experience to do a certain job from all over the world.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoSame here - I now actually spend time with my children (which has its own set of challenges but ...) I want my company to succeed - and I want to to succeed as a distributed remote company - mainly because I think that giving people back the time spent on commuting will benefit the communities they live in disproportionately It's also why I resent subsidising railways :-)
- eplanit 14y agoThis article is as much a statement about Yahoo as much as it is about remote vs. on-site work. Personally, I question Yahoo's long-term relevance anyway. As each year goes by, it seems they lag further and further behind, and are not part of the real momentum anymore. I'm curious if others agree. The most news I have heard about Yahoo in the last year or so was really all about the celebrity status of Mayer, being pregnant on the job, etc. Does anyone here foresee something relevant coming from that shop? (edited to fix typo)
- alaskamiller 14y agoI remember working at Yahoo in the late 90's as a barista and watching all the people walking around with HTML for Dummies books under their arms while enjoying their free espresso and chai thinking nah, these guys won't make it. I remember my friends working at Yahoo in the 2000's being all excited about the cult worship, good perks, then getting cynical about being stifled because they copied everything AOL was doing with project matrix management thinking nah, these guys won't make it. I remember being at Google watching Marissa Mayer's user profile being delete right after the announcement got out that morning thinking nah, these guys won't make it. But then I keep remembering, my mom still reads Yahoo Taiwan, uses Yahoo Mail, and sends me Yahoo News links. Then I keep remembering about the hundreds of products with plenty of inertia keeping the overall organization going. Yahoo's in a great position. They still have good talent, have good traffic, and most importantly they can position themselves to be Apple's best friend by simply being Google's enemy. Flickr, IntoNow, legacy stuff like Mail, Sports, Trave are still pretty diamonds that needs polish and TLC. They just gotta shore up profit to stay alive while out Google Google.
- jmccree 14y agoI can't help but think flickr (pro member here) missed the "social boat". Yahoo acquired them for $35 million. Instagram was $1 billion. If they had jumped onto sharing photos on twitter/facebook at the right time, facebook might not have ever even IPOed.
- alaskamiller 14y ago
- mrbird 14y agoRemote work can work well, but it unfortunately puts more pressure on management. Basically, it requires a disciplined, thorough, and consistent style of management. (Notice that these are all good things, no matter where your team is.) Many organizations, unwilling or unable to achieve this, resort to a more informal style that includes dropping by, looking over shoulders, and generally using visual confirmation that employees are doing what you think they should be. It's a shame, because there's an increasing amount of research that shows that people are happier, more productive, and even healthier when they can work from home. Successful incorporation of remote work boils down to a few things that sound simple but are difficult in practice: 1. Evaluate performance and progress as much as possible by results that are objective and measurable in some way (this goes for company goals as well, not just personal). 2. Communicate the same way with everyone, whether they are remote or local. If people in the office chat in person, but only email with their remote colleagues, they will definitely end up being marginalized. 3. Avoid any discussion that could, indirectly or directly, stigmatize people for being remote. If you have full organizational support for the above, remote work can be very productive.
- aurelianito 14y ago> It's a shame, because there's an increasing amount of research that shows that people are happier, more productive, and even healthier when they can work from home. Can you please link this research from here? All the research I read said that collocated teams kick remote teams asses.
- dripton 14y agoThe Ctirp study last year showed that remote CSRs at a Chinese travel agency were more productive than the ones in the office. Of course that might not be applicable to other jobs.
- amorphid 14y agoMaking the assumption that Mayer slash Yahoo wouldn't implement a policy like this on a whim, I bet this comes out of a bigger plan. If one had a mandate to do X, studied how to do that, and found X would be more likely to succeed with a team working purely onsite, then you just do a cost benefit analysis and make a decision. You'll find out later if you're decision was a good one, so hopefully on the front end you've got good data, judgement, and moxie to effectively make bold decisions!
- jerhewet 14y agoSo how many work-days per year is Mayer in her office at Yahoo? Oh. I see. That's different.
- chollida1 14y agoI probably shouldn't feed a troll, but I'll try to reason. A CEO's job is just flat out different from an engineers job. The CEO's job is often to be the public face of the company, to go out and make deals, to talk to key investors, to raise money in some cases. Or put another way, a CEO of a publicly traded company wouldn't be doing their job properly if they were in the office every day.
- cpeterso 14y agoFrom what I've read, probably 365 days.
- javascripter9 14y agoCan people please chime in with the names of any companies they know to be actively looking to hire remotely so we job seekers that don't want this yahoo move to become a trend know where to apply?
- sultezdukes 14y agoI had a talk with my supervisor a few days ago about working from home vs being in the office. We're "open office", which sucks in its current form, but I've come to realize has some definite advantages. The problem is when you have these black-n-white policies. When we're in bug-fixing, hardening iteration I estimate that I'm almost 2x productive working at home, than I am commuting in and dealing with the chit-chat and distractions of being in open office. The bottom line is that it's completely retarded for a CEO to make that kind of decision on a company-wide basis. Middle managers should be making that kind of decision.
- 6a68 14y agoUh, Mozilla is happy to hire remote folks worldwide :-) Just sayin'
- vidoc 14y agoI'm not too surprised by the move, I worked 6 years at yahoo and have always been amazed at how naive the company was with WFH. It may seem hilarious, but I strongly believe the company actually thought those employees would a) work and b) be at home! It was not uncommon to see people getting 2 or 3 days per week at home. I personally rolled with 2 per week for several years and it was great. I'd do a few emails in the morning, and that was about it for the day. I'd generally go play a full round of golf or spend the day biking.
- lttlrck 14y agoAnd look where Yahoo is now...
- squid_ca 14y agoThank God companies never hire consultants, use suppliers, open branch offices or collaborate with other people that aren't located IN THIS VERY BUILDING or they would never be able to get anything done.
- geebee 14y agoOk. I actually do understand why a company might feel that having lots of talented people concentrated in the same area is better than having them all scattered in different work places. I'm not saying that I necessarily share this point of view, just that I wouldn't reject it as an idea. Here's the thing - Google and the various other top high tech companies that are known for this go out of their way to make the workplace a mini paradise. Shuttles with wifi from noe valley, free and great food, extensive gyms and sports facilities, haircuts, dry cleaning, sabbaticals, tuition reimbursement, "take all you like" vacation policies... yeah, it's all designed to get you to stay at work 24/7, but at least they're trying to make it so nice that you'll want to. I worked for a small company that eliminated telecommuting and pulled out the "google doesn't do this" line, but with none of the perks. Uh... If yahoo wants to become a developer paradise, maybe they'll pull this off. If they want everyone to show up and work in a depressing cubicle all day, they'll be losing a lot of talent very soon.
- codeonfire 14y agoI worked at a 'this is not Google!' company for while. I kept hearing that the place wasn't Google over and over. It got to be where you couldn't say the G word. They had a messed up telecommute policy where the privileged group could telecommute while the serfs had to work the cubes.
- thrush 14y agoYou'd think they're doing this for security. I'm taking a security class right now and pretty much I've realized that remote computer systems are super insecure relative to anything on site. With the recent events of security fails like what happened at the nytimes it seems that the risk is becoming extremely high. I think it's a smart move by Mayer.
- nonamegiven 14y agoThe article specifically mentions customer service reps. Don't know what percentage is csr, and what are stereotypical "I can work anywhere I want" devs. But for those remote csrs, besides the upheaval, it's going to be tough working in SV on csr pay. And how much team building do you need to read troubleshooting prompts out of a binder anyway?
- nhangen 14y agoAny chance this is a way to trim fat without actually laying people off? Easier to get rid of the slackers if they quit.
- shawnc 14y agoSounds like you hit the nail on the head.
- donnfelker 14y agoLame ...a great way to cut off your talent pool. Yah-who???
- azov 14y agoLet's assume for the sake of argument that it is proven that onsite employees are more productive then remotes. So what? Some employers will do what Yahoo just did. Others may say: look, I want you to be productive, but more than that I want you to be happy. I prefer having great developers working at 90% of their capacity to squeezing every last bit of productivity from the mediocre ones I'm still able to retain. I hope the second group wins over time.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoRemote work often means out of the daily bustle work - thats one of the reasons folk say "let me work from home for two days, I have to get this done" If you can translate that into a continuous cycle of working on the most valuable not the most urgent problem, and a cycle of picking the valuable problem that turns you on, productivity should go through the roof All the crap that must get done - I am much more willing to do crap when I have hit a home run the day before Edit: this sounds like one expects to do productive work day in day out - I don't think that's true - one should aim for a home run every two-four weeks and be prepared to learn and measure during that period.
- rocky1138 14y agoThis is exactly how I work. You've hit the nail on the head.
- vivekv 14y agoPeople change, policies change. What is the big deal?
- akulbe 14y agoI suspect this will do a great deal to give ammunition to 37 Signals for writing their book about remote work. I'm a huge fan of remote working, and I think that the current corporate mindset against it... and company arguments against it... are mostly just complete bullshit. Of course, working remotely doesn't work in every case, but I'm certain that it would work very well in far more situations than people are willing to admit, or try.
- adrianhoward 14y agoIt's not been a month since the last time I posted my list of research articles on the productivity drop you get from not having teams co-located so I won't post it again in full... but for those who are interested you may find these old discussions of interest: * http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5145358 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5145358 * http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071701 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071701 * http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4800412 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4800412 I'm always on the look out for new non-anecdotal research on the topic if anybody finds any!
- kwalsh07 14y agoI completely agree with Mayer. As a student that took the Babson MBA program, it was a about building the team foundation, understanding that collaboration was key. My whole team was made up of mom, dads, parents of all sorts. The key goal was to assign a task and get it done in a timely manner while achieving our best result. It taught me to push myself, push global collaboration... beginning the foundation, allows for future growth.
- aharner 14y agoIs it just me or do people seem to take a special pleasure in criticizing Marissa Mayer above and beyond what most CEOs receive?