3 ms·
You seem to be assuming zero capital costs for fusion plants and hydrocarbon synth capacity. Think about how cheap those would have to be in order to make oil b
by fulafel 14y ago
You seem to be assuming zero capital costs for fusion plants and hydrocarbon synth capacity. Think about how cheap those would have to be in order to make oil burning economically unprofitable. And what about after oil price adjusts to decreased demand.
The vast majority of oil production is profitable at very low oil prices (it was still making oil sheiks filthy rich at < $20 a barrel). So you'd need to get something like $5/barrel synthetic oil to stop a free market system from pumping up and burning the fossilized oil.
- justincormack 14y agoOil costs are way higher than $20 a barrel now. Extraction takes a lot of drilling and so on even in the easy places.
- fulafel 14y agothat's the marginal cost of new hard to reach oil. the existing established wells are on average cheap. eliminating just the hardest few percent of production doesn't help with our co2 problem.
- apendleton 14y agoRight, but I think the point was that oil prices will plummet in the presence of cheap fusion power because fossil fuels will no longer be competitive for electricity generation, drastically reducing demand and freeing up capacity for the remaining markets where hydrocarbons still make sense (not that all fossil fuels are fungible, but reallocating natural gas resources to power cars isn't a completely ridiculous idea).
- adventured 14y agoOil prices won't plummet with a lot less demand, they'll go higher. There's no real ability for the oil industry to compete on price much below $50 to $60 / barrel energy equivalent. Even Saudi Arabia needs $85 to $100 oil just to pay for its budget these days. Since they can't actually afford to chase energy costs down, the industry would simply fold for the most part. The volume benefit that oil derives is a critical part of its formula. If you remove the volume, you lose the efficiencies of the oil ecosystem as well. That means losing the pipelines, tankers, and global supply counters to the OPEC cartel (as many nations would give up on oil). Most likely oil would move to being an expensive niche product, only supplied by those who can drill & ship it the absolute cheapest.