4 ms·
This highlights a problem which isn't unique to Australia. For example, if a potential employer (or whoever) asks you if you've ever been arrested and your reco
by justin66 14y ago
This highlights a problem which isn't unique to Australia. For example, if a potential employer (or whoever) asks you if you've ever been arrested and your record has been expunged or you've been pardoned, you are expected to lie and say "no". That is how the system works.
It sucks, but learning how to deal with these sorts of things is part of the price one has to pay when they have a run-in with the law. I'm not sure it's analogous to the boat thing. The agent really was wrong to insist on processing the boat with the incorrect information.
- vacri 14y agoIf the employer wants that information, they can stump for a police background check. My private life is my private life, and there's no way that a checkbox on a form photocopied by the hundreds is going to give a balanced view of any arrest of mine. I have never been arrested, but if the employer actually needs that level of employee security - perhaps handling client money? - then it's the employer's duty to protect themselves with more than a volunteered checkbox.
- untog 14y agoSure. But a lot of employers have no such security requirements, yet ask anyway.
- melvinmt 14y agoI'm wondering, isn't asking for your criminal history during job interviews the same as discriminating based on age or race? I mean, even if you were convicted, you've paid the price by doing your time and after that you should have equal opportunities at a job like anyone else, right? Maybe I'm just too idealistic but I never understood why we hardly give these people a second chance. And then people wonder why recidivism rates are so high.
- rrreese 14y agoIf I'm hiring an accountant I probably want to know if they have a history of dishonesty charges. You are free to give such a person a second chance, I'm less keen. I probably don't care if they had some drug charge 20 years ago though. Not sure how that's racist or ageist?
- barrkel 14y agoBecause the US justice system disproportionately punishes black crime, and older people are more likely to have had an encounter with the law.
- nitrogen 14y agoIf you've got nothing on your record, you'll probably be pereived as a good person. If you have any negative history at all, suddenly you become a fundamentally bad person who's just being good right now. At least, you've proven that you are "capable" of doing something "wrong", even if it was just being at school on the day of a protest. What nobody wants to admit is that, in the right circumstances, most people are "capable" of anything.
- mcherm 14y agoIn the US, the law says that employers ARE allowed to discriminate. They can, for instance, only hire left-handed people. Or refuse to hire people because of their eye color. Or because of their criminal background. The exception is a small number of specific traits on which one is NOT permitted to discriminate. Race is one. You MAY discriminate on the basis of age, as long as you're giving a bad deal to a young person... it is illegal to discriminate negatively against someone for being old. There are a few other protected classes (pregnancy, etc), and some states add extra protections above-and-beyond the federal law (in some states it's illegal to fire people for being gay... but in others that is perfectly legal). The one place it gets a bit odd is when they claim that your criteria for discrimination is just a "cover" or has the "same effect" as discriminating on the basis of a protected class. For instance, refusing to hire people because they live in a certain neighborhood is legal, but in court they would try to show that the neighborhood was predominately non-whites and so you were REALLY discriminating on the basis of race. The good news is that ALMOST ALL employers go well above and beyond what the law requires. Both to protect themselves from ambiguous cases AND because they are basically decent human beings, they go out of their way not to discriminate on anything other than basic ability to perform the job. But even so, some areas like criminal background get considered.
- danielweber 14y agoEmployers can be held legally responsible for the actions of their employees in certain circumstances, and hiring a ex-felon (when you knew, or could have known) doesn't look good to a jury. I think this sucks. Since graduation I've never been asked if I'm a felon or been arrested, so it wouldn't matter to me, but for lots of the working class, "no felons" is a common screening technique for employers, and it makes it really hard for people who have done their time to society to re-integrate.
- Dylan16807 14y agoThat's not a lie. The actual meaning of the question question is if you have officially ever been arrested. And the answer is no, that arrest is no longer official. Getting the payment denomination wrong is an actual falsity. Though it would have been easy to make a note when signing.
- justin66 14y ago> That's not a lie. The actual meaning of the question question is if you have officially ever been arrested. And the answer is no, that arrest is no longer official. That's completely incorrect. An "official" arrest (what is its opposite? I wouldn't want to experience an unofficial arrest) doesn't stop being "official," although the record of it might be deleted or sealed. Nobody can make an arrest retroactively not happen, they can just remove the record of it. But this brings up something important, and it might be the cause of your confusion. An arrest is just an arrest. It can happen to anyone, and importantly, it can happen to a person who is innocent both in reality and in the eyes of the law. Arrest records don't really mean what a lot of people think they mean: it's the courts, not the police, who decide guilt and innocence. This is why asking people about arrests, or using arrest information for pretty much any purpose except police investigation, is fundamentally flawed.
- Dylan16807 14y agoIt's true that arrest information is useless, I was thinking more about harsher things being expunged. And they do stop being official, in a sense. They are no longer tied to you as a current person, they become a burden of the past you, ending at the point of expunging.