3 ms·
Kinda stupid and short-sighted, I think. The technology won't work the way it's shown, it's just not feasible. What happens when you send a thousand tiny bombs
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Kinda stupid and short-sighted, I think. The technology won't work the way it's shown, it's just not feasible. What happens when you send a thousand tiny bombs or guns into a city? How do you make sure that they don't end up accidentally killing civilians (through malfunction)? How do you make sure that you don't accidentally end up arming your enemy since they can be captured with a simple net? How do you handle MAV's being counteracted by other MAV's and anti-MAV systems? How do you manage the torrent of data from an MAV swarm?
This is just a half-assed fantasy.
- worldsayshi 14y agoYou don't have them going on a shooting spree unguided. Even an evil military superpower will have a human making the last call on pulling the trigger. Have the drone sending a video stream as soon as it discovers a target that seem remotely interesting. Let the operator choose what get to live another day. Point being, a single operator can potentially control many drones spread out over a large area.
- yk 14y agoWhat is the benefit of a human in the loop, if he is just trained to push a button when the red light flashes? AFAIK this is essentially the situation with current bombers, a computer locks the target, and another one calculates when the bomb should be dropped. In such an szenario the 'human in the loop' is just PR, since the protocols are specifically designed to minimize the impact of said human.
- worldsayshi 14y agoDiscerning between threats and civilians to a high enough certainty should be a challenge. And throwing out a bunch of drones that goes about semi-randomly doesn't have to be a liability unless they also shoot people and destroy things semi randomly.
- dimitar 14y agoThe biggest problem I see is powering those little things. Their flight time will be measured in minutes with the current batteries. However, given the already remarkable proliferation of military drones I'm willing to take even speculation very seriously.