6 ms·
I don't get why you'd ever send a letter like this (except anonymously, or if you were a politician). There is no upside beyond just "Sorry, we're not interest
by rdl 14y ago
I don't get why you'd ever send a letter like this (except anonymously, or if you were a politician). There is no upside beyond just "Sorry, we're not interested -- our new investments are focused on Asia, where demand for tires is growing 200%/yr. Sincerely, CEO." There is downside -- you might provoke some tariffs in EU/France, or disinvestment from the pension fund, or whatever.
- windexh8er 14y agoIt's been shown time and time again that conversation / discussion with honest dissent proves to foster more thought and recourse than "being nice" and not directly engaging the problem. While the letter bordered on over-the-top I'd rather get the honest feedback than nothing at all (i.e. thanks but no thanks).
- joezydeco 14y agoIf I was to pretend I was the Titan CEO and read into the letter deeper, it's almost a backhanded way of saying "look, you're probably not going to find any buyer for your firm and I'll helpfully tell you why because it seems your management and unions are in denial".
- ctdonath 14y agoWhile scathing, it is also very informative. "Not interested" and a vague "lookin' better elsewhere" doesn't get into the reality of "why?" Methinks he did them a great service in being brutally honest. Those trying to solve the obvious problems will make much greater progress with such a letter in hand, rather than the usual apologetic tact. "Helpful are the wounds of a friend..." I'm sure he would, in fact, like to buy a French tire factory, but ridiculous pay for minuscule work makes for an offer no less insulting than his reply.
- rdl 14y agoYes, but there is no percentage in it for him. It's like telling a random fat person on the bus that he's fat. Probably nothing happens, but there is a small chance he will fly into a rage, or will tell everyone that you called him fat (maybe blogging about it, with video!). There's a much smaller chance that he'll suddenly start to diet/exercise, but how does that benefit you? It's different if it's a friend/family member, or if you're hired as a trainer or doctor.
- ctdonath 14y agoThere is a percentage in it for him: I'm sure he would like to own a French tire factory IF they actually had competitive productivity. With a verbal kick in the pants, perhaps the situation will change and he'll get a viable opportunity there. That aside, he's giving someone fair warning they're engaging in self-destructive behavior - a kind act. And no, it's not like telling a random fat person he's fat. He was approached with a request that he purchase the company. It's more like an obese slob applying for a serving-staff position at Hooters or Tilted Kilt.
- nraynaud 14y agoFrance is not the greatest manufacturing country, it's still one of the most productive country in the world, by a lot of measures.
- rdl 14y agoSomewhat ironically, it's also one of the best manufacturers for tires, the product specifically mentioned in the article. Michelin (for passenger car tires) is amazing, although their US-market tires (at least for everything but some specific race/customs) are all made in South Carolina.
- cantastoria 14y agoAgreed. As someone who does a lot of biz dev, I would be thrilled if a prospective partner was this honest with me.
- Shivetya 14y agoOver at the daily mail they added a bit to the WSJ story, namely that even French officials have said the same. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2281645/Maurice-Taylor-Tycoon-reveals-WONT-rescuing-lazy-workers-French-tyre-factory-doomed-closure.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2281645/Maurice-Tayl... As in Christine Lagarde, now head of IMF, did not have good comments about the work her own people do
- gdy 14y agoBecause he is not a money-earning robot despite his position?
- rdouble 14y agoPerhaps he just wants high fives from like minded CEOs. Getting political jabs in when they can seems popular with biz guys with too much time on their hands. It's the executive version of "doing it for the lulz."