3 ms·
Where do you see yourself in this dichotomy of "measure everything" versus "subjective considerations are important, too"? As pointed out elsewhere in these co
by jimbokun 18y ago
Where do you see yourself in this dichotomy of "measure everything" versus "subjective considerations are important, too"?
As pointed out elsewhere in these comments, Apple represents something like the opposite prioritization of Google. The argument for "subjective" design is that it is impossible to build up a good, coherent design by testing out each aspect empirically then putting all those things together. Consider the classic Slashdot review of iPod: "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame." The consideration of each aspect in isolation missed the design trade offs that made the iPod great overall.
I suppose Google misses out on that, but it's not clear that they or their users care. I do think, though, that Google has a unique approach to usability. Which is "Here's a box. Type some stuff in, and we'll figure out what to do with it." Google "search" is actually several different applications, and Google routes to the ones it thinks best suit what you typed. Chrome's single address/search bar follows this philosophy.
It's interesting to think that what distinguishes Apple and Google, more so than the product spaces they operate in, are the balance of empirical and subjective factors in their engineering cultures.
- jfarmer 18y agoIt's not that Apple is subjective. Design isn't and shouldn't be objective. I see it like this: design-thinking tends to be top-down and borrows from fields like psychology and anthropology, while data-driven-thinking borrows from the harder empirical sciences and is based on continuous measurement. Neither is "correct" and both can be executed to produce a great company. Apple, as you say, is on one end of the spectrum. Companies like Amazon and Google are on the other end. It's important to understand how you're making decisions and why you've chosen that process as opposed to some other one. It sounds like neither Google nor Doug have done that.