21 ms·
As 3D Printing Becomes More Accessible, Copyright Questions Arise
- andyzweb 14y ago"You can't stop the signal"
- gtt 14y agoWith enough money, you can. Unfortunately.
- leoedin 14y agoIs that the case? Piracy is still a fairly rampant problem for the music and film industry. Any reduction in piracy seems to be due to convenient and cheap digital music stores presenting a better option than piracy, rather than any progress in actually stamping out piracy. You could stop piracy almost completely - deep packet monitoring, extensive web filtering, fast and harsh penalties and the complete cooperation of the government probably could cut it to essentially zero. I think most governments (and even rights holders) recognised that taking it to that level wasn't worth the consequences. Maybe 3D printing will be different, but I'd imagine that like with music, there will be very little public appetite for harsh penalties for downloaders, and so they probably won't happen.
- betterunix 14y agoSure, they still claim "piracy" is a problem. Yet I cannot help but notice the fundamental shift that occurred over the past decade: fully decentralized systems are basically dead, everything now involves central servers that large numbers of downloaders depend on in one way or another. I think the RIAA and MPAA can safely count that as a win, because it gives them a single point of failure to attack. The biggest threat to the RIAA and MPAA was fully decentralized peer to peer (e.g. Gnutella); those systems could not just be sued out of existence like Napster or removed from existence by government action like Megaupload. By scaring everyone away from such systems and towards Bittorrent (with its trackers) and cloud storage, the industries contained the threat. Just centralizing the search systems was a big victory for them -- they can effectively use the DMCA to make it harder to even find the files you are looking for. Cultivating a producer-consumer mindset, even if it involves TPB, is good for the RIAA and MPAA: it makes it much easier to introduce their own download services. To put it another way, the copyright industries have always had to deal with infringement. What they feared most in the early 2000s was not infringement, but infringement that did not require any heavy-duty equipment. Coypright, the DMCA, and related laws are designed to be used against businesses, not hoards of individual people. "Happy Birthday to You" is routinely heard in homes and offices, but never in restaurant chains or movies, for that reason: the copyright on it cannot be effectively enforced against small gatherings of people, but it is easily enforced in the case of business use.
- leoedin 14y agoI think you're giving the MPAA/RIAA more credit then they're due. The driving force behind centralised peer to peer systems has always been convenience, curation and quality rather than fear. Gnutella and similar couldn't provide the same experience that bittorrent based systems did. Users got tired of not getting what they thought they were getting, and so when a technology with a superior user interface (torrents) came along, they adopted it. Although recently there have been successes in removing torrent sites, a large number ran for many, many years with no real challenges. I don't think the RIAA/MPAA are advanced enough to "cultivate a producer/consumer mindset". Their actions in the last 10 years against all sorts of infringement methods (napster, kazaa, TPB, suprnova, Jammie Thomas-Rasset and others) are demonstrative of a rights organisation which didn't really know how to react to the huge piracy increase in the early 2000s. The record companies realised that their business model (sell CDs) was being obliterated by piracy. It took them years (and the lobbying of Apple and Amazon) to get to a point (todays DRM free digital download market) that they could compete. It wasn't so much that they managed to get rid of piracy, but that they provided a more convenient solution to consumers' demand (getting music) than piracy. My original comment was made because, in reply to "You can't stop the signal", gtt said "With enough money, you can. Unfortunately". I would consider the results of the last decade of music piracy to be a fairly good indication that in fact you truly can't stop the signal. The only way that rights organisations have made any progress against piracy is by providing their own, higher quality, signal. That is something that I believe will translate into the 3D printing domain.
- betterunix 14y agoI do not think it is accurate to say that Gnutella could not provide the same "experience;" at the height of its popularity, Gnutella was basically the same experience as we have with TPB and file hosting services today. People still have to navigate around trojan horses when they download illegally, people still have to deal with long wait times, people still encounter seemingly good results that fail to deliver what they want (with torrents and file hosting). "Curating" is only relevant with the officially endorsed services, and those services would never have been able to compete in a world where people thought of things in terms of peer-to-peer sharing. The reason you saw Gnutella and the like die was the wave of lawsuits from the RIAA, which led to people being terrified to upload anything. Peer to peer does not work if people are unwilling to share. The RIAA also successfully killed the companies that were trying to make peer to peer more usable by developing spam filters and improving robustness (e.g. Limewire). It is not as though the concept of people downloading music was introduced to the RIAA by Napster. Several months before Napster started, the RIAA began work on SDMI, an attempt to thwart music downloading. The RIAA knew that people were downloading music over the Internet: anonymous FTP, IRC, Usenet, etc. It is not that the RIAA did not know how to react to the increase in copyright infringement; they were already working on a way to fight downloading. The record companies did not think for a moment that their business model was being "obliterated" by downloading. They were working on DRM because they believed that downloading was the next technological change that they would need to exploit to stay in business. Home taping had been dealt with years earlier, after all, so why do you think they were afraid of downloading in and of itself? What the RIAA was really afraid of was peer to peer. The RIAA's executives view the world in terms of one-to-many interactions: one producer serving the needs of many consumers. What made them panic was the idea that music could be spread without any centralization at all. With nobody to sue, buy out, tax, or otherwise deal with, the RIAA was basically left with none of the weapons it previously wielded. The only strategy left to them was to kill the idea of peer to peer sharing, by scaring people away, and get people to think like customers again. The point of suing college students, grandmothers, and other people whose net worth was not even a blip on the RIAA's RADAR was to scare people away from peer to peer, and back to systems that allowed the RIAA to use its legal weapons. That they eventually managed to create competitive download services is a separate issue; they were going to do that anyway, just like they eventually exploited FM radio and eventually exploited cassette tapes. They understood that computers could be music players long before peer to peer, they just needed a few years to figure out how they could make money from that. As long as people believe they require the services of some industrial-scale operation to obtain their music, the RIAA is not afraid. As for stopping the signal with sufficient money, I think you absolutely can do that, and I think you are going to see it happen within your lifetime. Eventually, you are going to buy a locked-down device that can only connect to your ISP's movie and music streaming sites, and a few other "approved" websites, and only use "approved" protocols; in exchange, you'll pay less for an Internet connection (anyone who wants more will be directed to "business class service," which will cost twice as much for half the throughput). Your computer will not allow you to download anything you did not get permission to download, and will not be able to upload anything audio or video related. You will not be allowed to run unapproved software. Shortsighted people will say it is more secure and will say that their grandmother does not need anything else. Yes, there will be jailbreaks, but you'll have to know someone who has a computer that can even download and run the jailbreaking software (think mod chips). That's what money can buy. Lots of corporations with lots of money are working to make that a reality, and in the absence of a "killer app" for uninhibited Internet use (like, say, a peer to peer network) it will only be matter of finding the right price point and features.
- otibom 14y agoI hope we fix copyright before we can 3D print food and organs.
- runarb 14y agoThey are all ready printing out candy: http://www.good.is/posts/3d-candy-printing-an-interview-with-designer-marcelo-coelho/ http://www.good.is/posts/3d-candy-printing-an-interview-with...
- hipsters_unite 14y agoIt's fascinating that physical goods manufacturing might soon have to deal with the same problems as the content creators at the bleeding edge.
- jrockway 14y agoThey are certainly quick to use the word "illegal" where others would say "fair use". I'd be more interested in the answer to the question, "what are you going to do about it". Sue someone who made Yoda into a vase? Sue Thingverse for letting people copy your precious, precious innovations? Sue Makerbot for being popular enough to register on your radar, even though 3D printing and CNC machines have been available for decades? It should be interesting to see. But like creators of music and movies, creators of physical items may be disappointed with the law's effectiveness in this area.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 14y ago> They are certainly quick to use the word "illegal" where others would say "fair use". The article is reasonably balanced. We don't know yet if the courts see this as fair use or illegal because it hasn't been tested yet. But the DMCA notices are working; Thingverse has had a few and they've taken things down. So, "as 3-D printing becomes more accessible, copyright questions arise". Rights holders may try a big grab early on to attempt control and to influence concepts of what's acceptable. "Want a Yoda? Buy this plan. But you're not allowed to transform it." As you say it's not likely to work. I'm pleased that 3d printing got started with no DRM. But it's sad that rights-holders are not recognising the power of the masses to create and develop their properties. "Here's a model of X. Let's see what you can do!" and then putting the results on a website would generate sales.
- monochromatic 14y agoIn what way does printing a bust of Yoda involve fair use at all?
- jrockway 14y agoIn the same way that taking a snapshot of a building does not infringe on the building designer's copyright.
- danso 14y agoI wonder what the impact will be on bespoke craftspersons, such as those who make their living on Etsy? I would think that as the "essential" products in life and home living become trivially cheap to manufacture and get-on-demand, those who can produce high quality one-of-a-kind items -- and who can repair them -- will be in higher demand, in the same way that top developers still command high salaries despite the glut of offshore programmers.
- betterunix 14y ago3D printers cannot knit a sweater. 3D printers cannot carve wood. That may change some day, and we can cross that bridge when we come to it. What I see 3D printers doing is replacing foreign labor for the production of cheap parts. "Made in China" will be as old-fashioned as sending a letter via postal mail. Toys will be printed at home, that obscure nut that your car maker insisted on using will be printed in your garage, etc. Your home decorations will be printed, and you'll be able to replace them at will. Despite the availability of cheap goods made by low-paid child laborers in developing nations, people still pay top dollar for crafts. I doubt that will change because of 3D printers.
- thirdtruck 14y agoOn a side note, they have created a robot that carves complete chairs out of tree trunks using a chainsaw.
- noptic 14y agoDepends on the printer. Not all use plastic. Soem use a lasr to cut the modell from a solid block. You can 3D print a complete chess set out of steel this way :). This is far to expensive for home use, but I gues you could use it to create fake car parts, and sell them for half the price.
- lutorm 14y agoThere are also machines that assemble metal parts from powder by distributing powder and then using a laser to melt it, layer by layer: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_laser_sintering http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_laser_sintering (If you used laser cutting, it seems it would be hard to make non-convex parts, since you can't stop the laser at a certain depth.)
- belorn 14y agoA rather interesting podcast/video is Adam savage talking about recasting (http://www.tested.com/art/movies/451613-still-untitled-adam-savage-project-recasting-11272012/ http://www.tested.com/art/movies/451613-still-untitled-adam-...). Recasting and the legal issues around 3D printing is close to, or is exactly the same thing. Thus listening to someone who has copying stuff from movies as a hobby, work professional with people who produce movies, and who's income is depended on creating stuff on the screen, its a very interesting podcast to listen to.
- notmarkus 14y agoYou wouldn't download and 3D-print a car.
- phren0logy 14y agoWhy not? Serious question. Maybe not today, but one of the new 3D printers includes arms to assemble the parts produced. I wouldn't be ready today to trust my safety to extruded plastic doo-dads, but I don't wee why I wouldn't eventually use a car 3D printed out of the proper materials.
- Kliment 14y agoI believe this is a reference to the absolutely idiotic advertising that the copyright industry shows exclusively to its paying customers.
- tomjen3 14y agoIt used to be that there would be FBI warnings on disks that went something like "You wouldn't steal X, you wouldn't steal, Y, you wouldn't steal a car, downloading is stealing." Which of course is an issue if, like me, you totally would copy a car.
- betterunix 14y agoOh heaven forbid! A new technology that would let people manufacture goods in their home might push the copyright industries further into obsolescence! We must need a new set of laws to stop this monstrosity, before it is too late and the balance of power shifts yet again! Businesses need to wake up: new technologies mean changes to the market. Governments need to stop trying to stave off the death of old businesses, and just let those businesses die. Greater harm is done to society when we try to stop the progress of technology than when we let obsolete businesses kick the bucket.
- jonascopenhagen 14y agoCopyright isn't a bad thing per se. Millions of businesses - not just large/old ones - depend on it in order to avoid the design they've spent countless hours and dollars on being copied.
- gutnor 14y agoAlso the whole open source movement depends on copyrights.
- betterunix 14y agoThat would be a fine argument in a world where the means of copying are heavy industrial equipment or otherwise uncommon in the home. That was the reality of the world from the invention of the movable type printing press until the PC. Now the means of copying books, music, movies, and software are a common household appliance, and yet we continue to cling to laws that were passed when only an industrial operation could make copies rapidly, all for the sake of keeping those industrial operations alive. Times have changed, and businesses need to change with the times. Kodak went out of business because they failed to adapt when digital cameras became small, cheap, and easy to use. New businesses now exist that make money because of digital photography. New businesses will rise to prominence because of 3D printing, assuming we do not kill 3D printing because of laughably dated concerns about copyright. Someone is going to sell you the raw materials that your 3D printer uses. Someone is going to run a search engine that finds the 3D models you are looking for and will tell you what materials you need (hopefully there will be many search engines competing with each other). Until we can manufacture integrated circuits in our homes, we will depend on Intel, AMD, TI, and others to make the electronics that run our 3D printers. Sometimes we just need to accept that the old ways of doing things are not profitable anymore. If we always worried about the businesses that are harmed by new technologies, we would still be using Roman numerals: http://www.storyofmathematics.com/medieval_fibonacci.html http://www.storyofmathematics.com/medieval_fibonacci.html (Edit: the ban on positional number systems was issued mainly due to pressure from businessmen who favored Roman numerals and general doubts about a numbering system that allows values to be inflated by tacking digits onto them: http://www.stevesachs.com/papers/paper_90a.html http://www.stevesachs.com/papers/paper_90a.html http://www.jstor.org/stable/2490013 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2490013)
- rangibaby 14y agoTPB has had a "physibles" category for more than a year now :-) https://thepiratebay.se/blog/203 https://thepiratebay.se/blog/203
- SEMW 14y agoInteresting they use a Star Wars example. There was a major copyright case on my side of the pond - in the UK - in 2011 about whether a Star Wars stormtrooper helmet was a sculpture, covered by copyright, or just a movie prop (so covered only be industrial design rights, which unlike copyright only last 10-15 years). It was held not to be a sculpture. So if you're in the UK, you can 3D-print stormtrooper armour without worrying about being sued by Lucasfilm. The court didn't give a concise definition of 'sculpture' - they listed some relevant factors, but mostly left it to the common sense of the trial judge. Quote: "it is inappropriate to stray too far from what would normally be regarded as sculpture. ... Not every three dimensional representation of a concept qualifies". http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/decided-cases/docs/UKSC_2010_0015_PressSummary.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/decided-cases/docs/UKSC_2010_... (Emphasis: this is under UK law, not US. I think the opposite result was reached in the US, but don't quote me on that. IANAL).
- Nrsolis 14y agoWhy is this a thing? The CAD files that serve as the input to the 3D printers are closer to deserving patent or trade secret protection than copyright. Copyright protects "creative, intellectual, or artistic forms", not inventions or tangible things. (Don't get me started on "design patents"). We're definitely in new territory here, but 3D printers dont change anything other than the speed/ease by which a "thing" can be created. Before the Internet, there was tape-dubbing and the Xerox machine. Are there fewer songs or shows now? Fewer Books? Why are 3D printers any different? A little primer on intellectual property law for the laymen would be instructive here.
- SEMW 14y agoThe theory is: - Sculpture is generally protected by copyright in Berne convention countries. - Copying includes reproducing a work in any material form. The fact that the process of making a copy involves CAD files isn't relevant: the result is a material reproduction of yoda. - Speed & ease isn't relevant either - hewing a copy of a copyrighted sculpture one from stone over a decade is just as much an infringement as 3d-printing is. A copy is a copy. (The difficult legal issue is what exactly a sculpture is. E.g. the UK has a narrower definition than the US, and in the UK yoda may not qualify as a sculpture - see my other comment). IANAL, just a UK law student
- Nrsolis 14y agoIANAL, either. But sculpture somehow brings to mind the idea that a "work" had an artistic component as opposed to a functional one. For instance, it might be infringement to "print" a copy of Michelangelo's David, but not a part of a handle to a door. In the latter, it's not a work of art, so merits no protection vs. design protection that it might get if it was a patentable invention.
- SEMW 14y agoI've commented on that issue elsewhere in this thread (about a case on whether Star Wars stormtrooper helmets are copyrightable in the UK): http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5250739 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5250739
- digitalengineer 14y agoI'd love to see what 'Banksy' could do with 3D printing. http://www.banksy.co.uk/indoors/Crb.html http://www.banksy.co.uk/indoors/Crb.html
- jonemo 14y agoFor anyone who wants to read in detail about the legal aspects of 3D printing, I'd suggest "What's the deal with copyright and 3D printing" by Michael Weinberg of Public Knowledge. He only gets a short soundbite in OP's link, but really deserves a full segment. Free download: http://www.publicknowledge.org/blog/so-what-deal-copyright-and-3d-printing http://www.publicknowledge.org/blog/so-what-deal-copyright-a...
- cma 14y agoAs 2-D Printing Becomes More Accessible, Copyright Questions Arise
- spullara 14y agoMy guess is the first thing to be locked down is the printing of 3D printers.
- snarfy 14y agoCopyright is to "promote the useful science and arts". When it stops doing that, its purpose is in question.