2 ms·
I have never completely understood this. My wife went to a prestigious ivy-league school. I went to college here and there at the cheapest places I could find.
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
I have never completely understood this.
My wife went to a prestigious ivy-league school. I went to college here and there at the cheapest places I could find. Now she gets hit up for money all of the time, and I never hear from the three colleges I attended.
Assuming we studied the same thing with the same perceived value (we didn't, but this is a thought experiment), why should she feel obligated to support her experience and I not feel obligated to support mine?
I guess the rub here is "perceived value." Can a case be made that the perceived value in the same education from a different institution be worth supporting all of your life? If so, don't we already do that with federal research grants and tuition support for students?
I have the same confusion when school kids come by raising money for a new gym or something. So I pay taxes to the local government that then allocates money to the school, but that's not enough, so then the schools use my kindness towards kids to raise even more money for their pet projects?
It's not enough that colleges are now big businesses, that most professors don't spend their time in the classroom, that tuition costs have risen far faster than inflation -- now we're expected to hold some special place in our wallets for them as well?
I guess. I guess if you're really that sentimental about your college.
I am not.
- ars 18y agoIt's because ivy-league schools are too expensive for the average student, so they get donations, but the cheaper schools are not, so they don't. See also my other comment, elsewhere in this thread.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI believe you are saying that because certain places overcharge for the same experience, they should be more worthy of charity. If this were the case, then the more they charge, the more worthy they would be, no?
- jimbokun 18y ago"If this were the case, then the more they charge, the more worthy they would be, no?" This seems to be the psychology behind it, yes.
- ars 18y agoNot exactly. First, people have an innate "feel" for exactly how much these experiences are worth, and thus should charge. They don't charge more than this. This makes sense of course from a capitalistic point of view. Second remember that is the very same people who went there who are sending the donations - it's not the random public. The people who went there are uniquely qualified to judge if it's worth the money - and they are the ones who decide to donate and allow others the experience. It's is basically a finely tuned system that makes the fee exactly what it should be - they can not just raise it and be worth more. Many people would consider those schools a waste of money - but they are not the ones who go there. The people who go there are exactly those who consider them a good value, and it's those same people who feel that others should be given the opportunity to have that experience. And since the amount is high, and they know not everyone can afford it, they donate.