5 ms·
> "Yes, suburb Seattle is quite different from urban Seattle, but ALOT more people live in the suburbs." I was careful to disclaim that this isn't a urban vs.
by potatolicious 14y ago
> "Yes, suburb Seattle is quite different from urban Seattle, but ALOT more people live in the suburbs."
I was careful to disclaim that this isn't a urban vs. suburban thing (though it is, to a limited extent) - this is a company town vs. business-diverse city thing.
After all, Google and Facebook were both born and headquartered deep within suburbs. The difference is that Mountain View and Palo Alto are swimming in tech companies - even if your social circles were entirely tech people, it's extremely unlikely they all work at the same place.
Compare with Seattle (stronger in Redmond/Bellevue) where practically everyone works for Microsoft (if you're on the east side) or Amazon (if you're on the west). Even for members of the community who don't directly work for MS, the relationship with MS is so overwhelming that it grossly distorts reality inside the bubble.
There's a lack of perspective because just about everyone works for the same company, subject to the same cognitive biases, with no substantial competition base (or hell, just other tech companies) to give you the necessary occasional whack upside the head.
> " but its mostly a shopping mall. Not much difference from any other big city in the states!"
I very, very heavily disagree. The US has many incredibly interesting big cities, even if some of them are deeply flawed from a financial or civic perspective. NYC and SF are no-brainers, but even the much-lampooned suburban gridlock of LA is (arguably) the cultural center of the entire country. New Orleans, Detroit, Chicago, Boston... I don't think I can seriously describe any of those as soulless mostly-shopping-malls.
This is my personal opinion, but IMO Bellevue epitomizes the worst of forced-urbanization. Its soullessness and emptiness is far from the norm in the US, and definitely not the norm for urbanization in the world.
- rdouble 14y agoThe US has many incredibly interesting big cities The US has far more boring big cities, though. You've already mentioned the interesting ones.
- iso-8859-1 14y agoWhy do you not like San Antonio? Look how great it is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_of_San_Antonio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_of_San_Antonio
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoI like San Antonio, the river walk area is really cool. I'm not sure about the suburban blight around it, I never lived there to experience any of it. But inner tubing down the Guadalupe....
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoNashville, Las Vegas, Dallas, Portland, San Diego, ...
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoEven if you are in Mountain View, say you have friends in San Jose; how often do you see them? Its really not that different. I think you have a very poor understanding of the pudget sound area economy. On the west side, you are just as likely to run into someone working for a startup, Starbucks, or Boeing, or UW, than Amazon. Amazon isn't that dominating. Now, in the east side, Microsoft is bigger, but there are still a lot of other companies, eBay, Google (on both east and west sides, and even in freaking Bothell now), a bunch of startups. Its not quite the monoculture you make it out to be! Now, when we are talking about Bellevue, you compare it to San Jose, not San Francisco, or Fort Worth, not Dallas, or some weird industrial wasteland suburb of New Orleans (of which there are plenty), not the wards or the French Quarter. All of these interesting cities have their souless mostly-shopping mall areas. Looking international, what I've seen the same nearby satallite cities of Tokyo, Paris, Bangkok, Amsterdam, Lausanne, etc...tells me suburban blight is not just an American problem.