8 ms·
No, meteor defense can get in line behind heart disease, automobiles, suicide, gun violence, war, police, and all the other things astronomically (heh) more lik
by erikpukinskis 14y ago
No, meteor defense can get in line behind heart disease, automobiles, suicide, gun violence, war, police, and all the other things astronomically (heh) more likely to kill people, therefore more deserving of our attention.
- jug6ernaut 14y agoAlways love how people throw out "gun violence" as if "gun violence"(as if there is such a thing) is so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence".
- dfxm12 14y agoThere is such a thing as gun violence. It is distinguished as violence involving at least one gun.
- jug6ernaut 14y ago"There is such a thing as gun violence" I'm not convinced. "It is distinguished as violence involving at least one gun." re-read my post, i said >> "so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence"" I'm not saying that it cant be distinguished (as others describe it), I am saying is there a big enough difference that we should focus on it over violence in general. IN MY OPINION! focusing on "gun violence" takes away from the more important discussion on "violence" in general and diverts the discussion to matters non conducive to stowing violence in general. BUT this is not what this post is about.
- dfxm12 14y agoI reread your post. It was the same as the first time I read it. It said "Always love how people throw out "gun violence" (as if there is such a thing) is so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence"." Based on the bit I emphasized, you are implying "gun violence" is not a real concept, or doesn't exist, or something along those lines. Gun violence is real. Further, OP is clearly not commenting on the prevalence of gun violence vs other violence. OP is commenting on things more likely to cause damage than a meteor strike.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoWe don't call out 'knife violence' or 'fist violence' or 'cricket-bat violence'. All are real too.
- arjie 14y agoWell, I suppose it depends on the relative frequency of the crimes. British newspapers are always on about 'knife crime'.
- kamjam 14y agoThat's because in the UK knife violence is a much bigger than gun crime. Having said that, drunken violence on a friday/saturday night is a big problem regardless.
- sliverstorm 14y agoas if "gun violence" is so distinguishable Sure it's distinguishable. It's scarier, so it's easier to get people upset about it. People seem to be orders of magnitude more afraid that they will be gunned down as opposed to, say, killed with a knife or a hammer.
- jlarocco 14y agoMay just be me, but I'd prefer to be gunned down than killed with a hammer. Not that I disagree with your point - it's far easier to avoid being killed with a hammer.
- miles 14y agoIndeed. The fact that guns save lives around the country on a regular basis is almost completely ignored by the media: Guns Save Lives http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/02/guns_save_lives.html http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/02/guns_save_... "If someone gets into your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone? You can call the police if you want, and they'll get there, and they'll take a picture of your dead body. But they can't get there in time to save your life. The first line of defense is you." http://gunssavelives.net/ http://gunssavelives.net/ has a huge collection of articles like these: Son Uses Dad’s AR-15 To Defend Home http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/son-uses-dads-ar-15-to-defend-home/ http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/son-uses-dads-ar... Armed Citizen in TX Stops Shooting Spree and Saves Cop http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/armed-citizen-in-tx-stops-shooting-spree-and-saves-cop-by-making-150-yard-shot-with-a-pistol/ http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/armed-citizen-in-tx-st... GA Woman Kills Would Be Rapist With .22 Pistol http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/ga-woman-kills-would-be-rapist/ http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/ga-woman-kills-w...
- tokipin 14y agoquite frankly, the "gun in your house" thing is a very weird argument. if you actually play out a real-life instance of such a situation, it's not so simple at all. reality is much more nuanced. for example, a gun is about 120% useless if you have it stored and the bad guy has the drop on you, which is likely the case on multiple levels given that that the 'bad guy' is the aggressor and initiator of a rare situation. for example, the 'bad guy' may have a gun himself, and seeing you wielding one may cause him to shoot you, when he otherwise wouldn't have. and it's entirely possible or even likely that he has spent more time at the shooting range than you, or that he has killed people before. nevermind that he, having the mental preparedness that comes from being the initiator, may have the clearer presence of mind and less shaky hands Etc. Etc. the "gun in my home to keep me safe" is a non-sequitur and only makes sense in simplistic cowboy scenarios, and I've even heard statistics saying you're more likely to hurt yourself or a loved one than the bad guy... ...but we don't really have any good ideas about that, because the gun lobby has suppressed research into these things for several years
- roc 14y agoOnly if we assume that our mitigation efforts against those other problems would be lacking for resources, if we sent some resources to work on space object detection/defense. If we're putting as much money and effort into automobile safety as society wants/will allow, there's no 'loss' in taking additional funds to tackle the next problem down the line. And so on.
- wheels 14y agoHeart disease and car crashes don't have the ability to derail significant economies in short shrift. There's pretty obviously a huge difference between singular, concentrated disasters and amortized "normal" human death.
- jholman 14y agoI think that as long as we're talking about sub-extinction levels, I disagree with you. WP estimates roughly one million car accident deaths per year (worldwide est for 2007). Heart disease numbers are more like 30M/year, although lots of those people were very old, so it's hard to estimate what's preventable. Compare that with a hypothetical meteor that kills one hundred million people, in a confined geographic area (that's 1/7 of Europe, or 1/5 of N America, or just half a dozen large Asia cities). What're the odds of that meteor? Even the once-per-millenium Tunguska event wasn't large enough to do that much damage. But suppose once-per-millenium meteors WERE deadly enough to kill 100M people, that's still 1/10 the deaths per year. If it's more spending-efficient to prevent the deaths from heart disease, do that. If it's more spending-efficient to prevent the deaths from meteor impact, do that. On the other hand, extinction events are worth treating with extra care. Which in fact is exactly what meteor watches do, which is why they only look for entry diameters over 100m. Seems reasonable! Extinction events have happened 5 times in the last 540 million years. They're pretty rare. Maybe we should just roll the dice. Off-topic: That's not what "shrift" means. Maybe you'd like "short order" or just the clearly "in a short time".
- sehugg 14y agoThough there is a tradeoff in resources vs. other human concerns, I think the math is a bit more complicated. We're not only trying to guard individual human lives but the health of civilization. Just the knowledge that a major asteroid impact was imminent, with no way to address it in time, would be severely destabilizing to global society.
- wheels 14y agoTo be clear, I'm not actually saying that a meteor defense system is a reasonable idea. I don't know enough about the topic to say anything interesting. My point was rather that you can't compare a catastrophe with disease / accidents simply in deaths-over-time. Catastrophes have dramatic economic consequences as well.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoThere is no line. There's just fad and fashion. What's the disease-of-the-year? Pour money into that! Never mind obesity etc. Or meteors.
- wdr1 14y agoMeteors have wiped out 90+% of the planet's life on several occasions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cretaceous%E2%80%93Paleogene_extinction_event http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cretaceous%E2%80%93Paleogene_ex... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian-Triassic_extinction_event http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian-Triassic_extinction_eve... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cretaceous%E2%80%93Paleogene_boundary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cretaceous%E2%80%93Paleogene_bo...
- T-hawk 14y agoWell, not directly; any single impact certainly didn't hit and kill life forms all over the globe. They induced environmental changes that gradually caused species to fail to survive. "Sudden" in geologic terms means at least hundreds or up to tens of thousands of years. An intelligent species like humans can and will react and adapt in that kind of time frame. We're already on that path; we can already at least detect and predict any object big enough to significantly disrupt the planetary ecosystem.
- cryptoz 14y ago> An intelligent species like humans can and will react and adapt in that kind of time frame. We're already on that path; we can already at least detect and predict any object big enough to significantly disrupt the planetary ecosystem. We've detected such a series of objects and have willingly not tried to prevent them from dramatically altering our ecosystem, but are encouraging and quickening the damage they do. Detecting and predicting is not nearly enough. Action is required and there is absolutely no evidence to suggest that humans will take that action. I strongly disagree that a species such as humans 'can and will react and adapt'. So far we have shown that we are the exact opposite: we are the ones causing global environmental catastrophe.
- 3minus1 14y agoThis is a really bad comparison imo. The difficulty of sustainability and non-pollution is that it requires everyone to work together to not consume. If even a few parties decide to not cooperate they can consume everything that's left and the other people will lose out on their "share." In the case of an asteroid it's in everyone's interest to prepare as best as he/she can and cooperation actually helps. There's really no downside to preparing as much you as can.
- blhack 14y agoYou should just add the word "bad" to that list. We can't work on anything until we eradicate bad! $foo is so much less important than bad! /s
- rmc 14y agoAlthough those things do kill more people every year, and they are predictable numbers. We have figured out how to get along. However a meteor is currently unpredictable, and we have no plan for what happens if it hits somewhere big. The effect of all the heart attacks next year have been taken into consideration, a meter or strike to London, less so.
- dj2stein9 14y agoExcept none of those things can realistically kill every person on the planet. Nuclear war would maybe be the only threat I think has a higher likelihood of making mankind extinct than a meteor, which is why graphics like this scare the crap out of me: http://visually.visually.netdna-cdn.com/NuclearWeapons_4fa46b5cd6d31.gif http://visually.visually.netdna-cdn.com/NuclearWeapons_4fa46...
- chakalakasp 14y agoDon't be afraid; it's not drawn to scale.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]