4 ms·
So the balloon descended because it popped. If they put a pressure release valve on it (one designed to work by relative pressure differences, not absolute, an
by ars 18y ago
So the balloon descended because it popped.
If they put a pressure release valve on it (one designed to work by relative pressure differences, not absolute, and I think most are anyway), how high could you get?
I'm guessing to the point where the difference in mass between the helium inside the balloon and the air outside is not enough to loft the camera. But with a light camera that has to be just about outer space, no?
Edit: And despite the risk, I think they should use hydrogen. If I'm not mistaken, it's 1/4th the mass of helium. I don't know how much higher that will take them though, but it has to make some difference.
- noodle 18y agohydrogen would probably be tougher to get their hands on for your average schoolkids.
- jrockway 18y agoYou can make hydrogen with a glass of water and a battery. It is not hard to get.
- noodle 18y agowhile true, its probably easier/safer to go buy a tank of helium. and easier to get the approval of a school
- nradov 18y agoThat gets you hydrogen at ambient pressure. To get the hydrogen into the balloon you have to compress it at least a little bit. Running hydrogen through a compressor can be extremely dangerous if you don't have the proper equipment.
- ars 18y agoWell you could always simply make it _inside_ the balloon. And it couldn't be that hard to buy a canister of compressed hydrogen. But, it's probably much much more expensive (I'm guessing 10x more), so probably not practical for students.
- nradov 18y agoFor balloon buoyancy it's not the atomic mass which matters, but rather the gas density. Hydrogen is about 50% less dense than helium. Obviously there are some safety issues, mostly with handling a pressurized storage tank on the ground.
- ars 18y agoAh yes, I forgot that hydrogen is actually H2 (molecule of two hydrogens), so two nucleons per gas particle, compared to 4 for helium. (And it is atomic mass that matters, but you have to count the mass of each gas particle. In an ideal gas, gas density is the same for most any gas.) I wonder if it will make much difference though, I think air pressure falls off exponentially, so a doubling of buoyancy won't go far.