4 ms·
So what were actually her arguments, other than just calling libertarians anarchists, her enemies, and mocking them? She just seemed really pissed off at them f
by mtgx 14y ago
So what were actually her arguments, other than just calling libertarians anarchists, her enemies, and mocking them? She just seemed really pissed off at them for whatever reason. But I don't think I saw any real argument in that interview.
This interview also made her seem a lot less smart than Republicans have made her out to be (just based on this interview, I haven't read anything else of hers). She seemed like your average Fox News moderator.
- danielhughes 14y agoThat was a collection of questions and responses from different sources and times. It wasn't an interview transcript. I made the same mistake as I was reading it and at one point started to wonder why the "interviewer" was asking the same question over and over.
- richardjordan 14y agoShe made the argument as a simple point - that they're anarchists and that anarchy begets collectivism. I think the broader purpose of the post, though, is to point out the irony in folks who think of themselves as Rand acolytes and Libertarians. This is a common position, and I hear it a lot in Silicon Valley/startup circles. Personally I don't think much of her ideas, I find them simplistic and in some places naive and immature, other places disingenuous. I think many Libertarians suffer similar failings and propose positions that are vastly simplistic in the context of the real world. I know that many smart people I respect disagree with my position, and that's fine, I'm not looking for argument on those points. So, as a critic of both groups it doesn't bother me to see them lumped together. But it's amusing that Rand wanted nothing to do with that.
- phaus 14y agoI'm not criticizing, but what's a better alternative to the two mainstream political parties we are currently saddled with? I'm asking because while I don't belong to any political party, there are aspects of libertarianism that do appeal to me, such as dramatically reducing government spending, government waste, government corruption, and actually observing the constitution.
- richardjordan 14y agoSadly I don't think this is a great forum for useful dialogue on that topic, but the two parties seem to be taking turns driving the bus into the ditch and heckling from the sidelines. I do think that the key is in market mechanisms and efficient markets need strong regulatory control (a market is just an efficient computer for processing collective decision making, and without proper programming it won't deliver answers to the questions you think it's answering), and libertarians often fail to appreciate the value in this leading to laissez-faire market rigging.
- gnosis 14y ago"So what were actually her arguments, other than just calling libertarians anarchists, her enemies, and mocking them?" Well, let's see, from the first paragraph: - She called Libertarianism "a mockery of philosophy and ideology" - She accused Libertarians of "slinging slogans and trying to ride on two bandwagons" Later, she accuses them of entertaining "amateur political notions" and "rushing into politics in order to get publicity". She says that Libertarians - are based on "half-baked ideas, and in part on borrowed ideas". - "spend their time denouncing me, while plagiarizing my ideas". - "are perhaps the worst political group today, because they can do the most harm to capitalism, by making it disreputable." - would "like to have an amoral political program" I could go on quoting her, but maybe if you actually read the article yourself you'll see what her "arguments" are.
- phaus 14y agoMost of these statements are so vague that she might as well not have made them. That was his point. The article doesn't give any real insight into her thought process, unless her thought process was indeed as shallow as this collection of interviews makes it out to be, which I doubt.
- nollidge 14y agoThose aren't arguments, they're opinions.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]