5 ms·
> Up here in Canuckistan, we do have private insurance. You must, for example, privately insure your own dwelling against things like fire or burglary. "You mu
by lutusp 14y ago
> Up here in Canuckistan, we do have private insurance. You must, for example, privately insure your own dwelling against things like fire or burglary.
"You must"? Not really, unless you have a mortgage. If you don't have a mortgage, if you actually own your house, you aren't required to buy insurance, and you may be much better off self-insuring.
And now for the best-kept secret in the insurance business -- if an insurer evaluates your true risk and offers a policy, it's not worth it. Why? Because on average, you will have paid out much more in insurance payments than you will get back in the event of a claim. You would be better off putting the insurance payments into an investment that (a) will grow over time and (b) can be used against future loss.
Do you doubt this? Ask yourself why an insurer would be willing to issue a policy on which he expected to lose money. Are insurance companies profitable? Yes, they are. Any questions?
If you have a mortgage, you are required to buy insurance. If you don't, by all means ask yourself why you are willing to give your money away to an insurance company instead of investing it by yourself, for yourself.
More detail here: http://arachnoid.com/wrong/index.html#Insurance http://arachnoid.com/wrong/index.html#Insurance
EDIT: If you cannot afford to lose the insured item, then the above doesn't apply. I should have said this at the outset.
- raganwald 14y agoPoorly worded, I meant that if you wish to insure it, you must insure it privately. Thanks for pointing out the balderdash.
- lutusp 14y agoIt was just an excuse to jump onto one of my favorite soapboxes. But if you can edit the article, by all means do it -- I don't like to see insurance portrayed as mandatory, or the obvious action of a responsible person. That's only true sometimes, and most people can't say when that time is. A classic scene, when a retailer is offering one of those useless electronic service plans: customer says, "Do I benefit from this offer?". Salesman: "Absolutely!". Customer: "Then why are you offering it to me?"
- raganwald 14y agoI can corroborate your conjecture somewhat. My mother bought a seven bedroom(!) home from a slum landlord. He used to buy big old homes in pre-gentrification neighbourhoods and chop them into tiny apartments. Insurers charge a lot extra for such homes because of the neighbourhoods and the supposed high risk of MURBs combined with the older construction. So once he hit his sixth home, he stopped buying insurance and started putting money into a pool of his own. Over the years he had, in fact, needed to draw on it for things that would have been covered by insurance, but he felt that even if he broken even, the paperwork required for spending your own money is a lot easier, you just write the cheque :-)
- Spooky23 14y agoThe slumlord business model works because he's raking in guaranteed payments from the government (60-75% of those apartments are directly subsidized), and he doesn't give a shit about the buildings. So his liability is basically limited to shoring the place up enough so that the Social Services/Public Housing people will continue writing checks, and covering the costs of emergency demolition when the house burns or falls in.
- raganwald 14y agoThat was not the case for this particular individual in Toronto.
- mhurron 14y agoThere are situations where a course of action is in both parties best interests.
- mpyne 14y agoYou're right of course, but the reason I don't invest the money myself is mostly because I do not have the skillset to do so as effectively as the insurance company, nor do I have the time to put into learning how to properly invest money (including diversification) such that it does grow as I would need it to in order to be useful as an insurance policy. I pay the insurance company extra to take on that risk of non-appreciating value for me (and maybe to do so more efficiently than I could, so that I actually pay less).
- cdcarter 14y agoAdditionally, if the incident upon which you need to make a claim happens fairly early in the life of the policy, it's entirely worth it.
- lutusp 14y ago> Additionally, if the incident upon which you need to make a claim happens fairly early in the life of the policy, it's entirely worth it. Yes, but the advice to self-insure is based on the average outcome, not the exception. Insurance companies aren't profitable in spite of the lucky few whose claims take place quickly, but because of the vast majority for whom this isn't true. And insurance companies are very profitable.
- philwelch 14y agoIf you're writing thousands of policies, of course statistically you're going to profit because not all of them will claim before it has paid for itself. Once you pay the first claim, you've already collected 999 premiums at least once. But if you self-insure, you're only writing one policy, which puts all the risk back into it.
- lutusp 14y ago> You're right of course, but the reason I don't invest the money myself is mostly because I do not have the skillset to do so as effectively as the insurance company ... That's what the insurance companies say -- you can't possibly invest the money as well as they can. But you can -- just put the payments into a market index fund, a fund that tracks a market indicator like the DJIA. Such funds have almost no, or no, overhead because no one has to decide anything -- such a fund grows in step with the market indicator that it tracks. And guess what? There are very few mutual funds that do as well as a bonehead market index fund, one in which there's no fund manager to screw things up and charge you for the privilege. Here's why: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficient-market_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficient-market_hypothesis Second reason -- it's true that insurance companies invest your payments wisely, but it's not true that you benefit from their ability to invest your money. Only their stockholders benefit. > I pay the insurance company extra to take on that risk of non-appreciating value for me (and maybe to do so more efficiently than I could, so that I actually pay less). Not if the insurance company makes a profit. And most do, with your money.
- thedufer 14y ago> if an insurer evaluates your true risk and offers a policy, it's not worth it This is kind of a silly argument. You're paying a little extra to avoid the situation of something happening before you've saved enough to replace it. I go by a more specific, but actually workable, rule: "if an insurer evaluates your true risk and offers a policy _and you can afford to replace it right now_, it's not worth it". For example, I don't buy insurance on electronics - if I couldn't afford to lose it, I would find something cheaper. But I would certainly insure a house, unless I had a couple hundred grand lying around.
- lutusp 14y ago>> if an insurer evaluates your true risk and offers a policy, it's not worth it > This is kind of a silly argument. No, that is a silly argument, because it doesn't offer an explanation. Consider those electronic service plans that retailers are always trying to get you to buy. They's not worth it. How do I know? Because the retailer wants to sell it to me. Therefore he must come out ahead in the transaction. Therefore it's not in my interest -- I would be better off paying for a repair myself, or replacing the item. How difficult is that? It's the same with insurance. If you cannot afford to lose the insured item, by all means insure it. For every other case, think a little harder and you may realize there's a reason the insurance company is so eager to sell you a policy.
- thedufer 14y agoYou're saying exactly the same thing I said. I'm not sure why my version is silly, except that you cut out the explanation part when you quoted me.
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> You would be better off putting the insurance payments into an investment that (a) will grow over time and (b) can be used against future loss. Unless "future" happens to be "next tuesday", and "loss" happens to be "catastrophic fire".
- lutusp 14y ago> Unless "future" happens to be "next tuesday", and "loss" happens to be "catastrophic fire". That's why people should learn statistics and probability. By buying insurance, you're betting that your house will burn down pretty soon. The insurance company is betting it won't burn down very soon. On average, the insurance company comes out ahead. How do we know? They stay in business, a business paid for with your money.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI'd argue that by buying insurance, I'm not betting that my house will burn down soon - I'm betting that were it to burn down, I'd be proper fucked without insurance. Probability works in the long run. If I bet you a dollar on a coin flip, my expected return is $0.50, but I will not get $0.50 - I will either get $1.00, or zilch. Besides, when the insurance company loses the house-on-fire bet, they lose some money. When I lose the house-on-fire bet, I lose everything I own if I'm lucky.
- lambda 14y agoYes, insurance is a bad idea for anything that you can afford to replace if you lose it. If, however, losing that item would lead to your financial ruin (such as losing your home and everything in it), then the insurance is worthwhile. It's how you avoid "gamblers ruin". Yes, on average it's a net negative expected value, otherwise the insurance companies wouldn't offer it; but it prevents you from losing the bulk of your wealth in the event of disaster, and being unable to recover from said disaster. It even says so at your link: if you can't afford to replace something, and must have it, then insurance makes sense. So, it's worthwhile buying insurance for those things that you just can't replace: your house, your body. Things that are more replaceable? I have enough money saved up to by a new car if need be. If my car is stolen or totalled, I can replace it out of pocket; so I need only the bare minimum liability insurance, not accident insurance for my car.
- lutusp 14y ago> It even says so at your link: if you can't afford to replace something, and must have it, then insurance makes sense. Yes, absolutely, if you cannot afford to lose the insured item, then you really should get insurance. But that leads to the insurance paradox: people who buy insurance tend to be people who cannot afford to lose their possessions because they buy insurance instead of becoming investors.
- megaman821 14y agoInvesting in yourself only works on average. So you pay off your mortgage and decide to cancel your insurance and start investing the monthly payments yourself. The next day your home burns down and you don't have enough investment money to cover even a small fraction of your home's worth. Of course you can get lucky too. After 30 years of investing your monthly insurance payment you have the full value of your home and its items. Now there is no need to contribute to your insurance fund ever again. Most people don't wish to gamble in this way when their homes are at stake and instead pool their risk with other home owners. The group managing these assets is an insurance company. The home owners are willing to pay a slight premium towards the operating expenses of the insurance company.
- lutusp 14y ago> Investing in yourself only works on average. No, not true. On average, you are much better off investing the insurance payments than paying for insurance. If this were not true, insurance companies would be reluctant to offer you a policy. But notice that insurance companies are always willing to write a policy -- which, by its very existence, must benefit them on average. > Most people don't wish to gamble ... But buying insurance is as much a gamble as not buying insurance. The difference is the number of players who are gambling with you. Obviously if you cannot afford to lose the insured item, that's different. My advice is for possessions the loss of which doesn't cripple your life. > The home owners are willing to pay a slight premium towards the operating expenses of the insurance company. My point is that the owner would be way ahead by investing the insurance payments rather than handing them over to an insurance company.
- NateDad 14y agoYou are why universal healthcare is so essential - because most people are really bad at calculating their own risk vs. reward. Risk: $1000 a year in home insurance that could be used to buy something else. Reward: the 1 in 1000 chance that your home burns down, you aren't completely boned. The risk is relatively small. $1000 a year isn't going to change your life. But the safety that it buys you is huge, because it prevents your life from being devastated should something unlucky happen.
- btilly 14y agoThis is horrible advice and I hope that nobody is swayed by it. If you understand the nature of repetitive investments in a risky environment, you'd know that the correct long-term financial strategy is to constantly aim to maximize the expected value of the LOG of your net worth. That is because small losses that leave you with working capital are fairly easy to recover from, while large losses that leave you with no working capital completely hose you. If you have enough money that a particular loss would not severely impact your overall financial health, insurance does not make sense for the reason that you say. But if the loss is large enough to financially wipe you out, then insurance can make sense both for your long-term financial well-being and the insurer's long-term financial well-being. Therefore the correct approach is to only buy insurance for things whose loss would wipe you out financially.
- lutusp 14y ago> Therefore the correct approach is to only buy insurance for things whose loss would wipe you out financially. I agree, and I added this clarification to the original post.
- NateDad 14y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. Insurance works because not everyone's house burns down. Only some people's do. The people whose houses don't burn down pay for those whose houses do. investing to repay for your house should it burn down only works if you know you're not going to have your house burn down for 30 years. What if your house burns down the day after you buy it? if you had insurance, you'd be fine. If you put that initial $500 (or whatever) in an investment, you have.... $500.
- lutusp 14y agoYou're missing the point that, on average, insurance benefits the insurance company, not the policy holders. How do we know this? Because insurance companies are eager to sell you a policy. If the policy benefited you on average, insurance companies would go out of business on average. But ... they don't. > The people whose houses don't burn down pay for those whose houses do. Yes, and I don't smoke in bed. Why should I pay for the risky and unhealthy habits of others? But more importantly, I'm better off investing my money against a future loss than handing it over to an insurance company. This is only true if I can afford to lose the insured item, but many people buy insurance without asking themselves this basic question. > What if your house burns down the day after you buy it? This is all about probability, not focusing in on the worst possible case. Insurance companies naturally enough want you to focus in on the worst possible case. But in the long term, and statistically, you're better off self-insuring -- unless a mortgage requires you to carry insurance, or unless you simply cannot afford to lose the insured item.
- NateDad 14y agoYour life is not a statistic. You are not the average. If I gave you $20 to play russian roulette, would you do it? It's only a 1/6 chance of death. On average you'll be up $20, right? I'm guessing most people would not do it. The risk of death is simply not worth the reward. You keep talking about "things you can afford to lose". Houses NEVER fall into that category. So why do you keep bringing it up? We're talking about houses, not the DVD player you buy at Best Buy.
- 14y ago
- snowwrestler 14y agoThe primary reason to have homeowners or auto insurance is not replacement, it is liability. If a child plays in your yard and dies from a fall, or rusty nail, or if your neighbor slips during a party and breaks their hip, you could conceivably be sued for a whole lot more than just the replacement value of your house. Even if it is just a nuisance suit, it could take a lot of lawyer time (money) to make it go away. I insure for liability; the replacement benefit is almost a bonus.
- OldSchool 14y agoIf you own 1000 or more mortgage-free rental houses perhaps you could consider self-insuring. If that one mortgage-free house is the one you live in, chances are good that it's less painful to pay say 1/500th of the structure's value (don't include the land) per year to insure it and its contents against fire, theft, storm damage, liability, etc, than to take a hit from any of these and have to pay out of pocket. For perspective, property taxes are probably 4-10x more than insurance and you're stuck with those forever.