5 ms·
This seems a well timed move by Schmidt. Google share price has had a lot priced into it recently (Jumps on self driving cars, google glasses etc) and the Ine
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
This seems a well timed move by Schmidt.
Google share price has had a lot priced into it recently
(Jumps on self driving cars, google glasses etc) and the
Inevitable drop in QE means the price is going to have to slow. Not decline, just grow slower.
That's not to say google is in particular trouble, but their growth markets for the future are BIG markets, fibre, cars,
home automation - All markets that need lots of pump priming, lots of infrastructure work and that will eventually become ubiquitous.
There may not be a lot of profit in the markets or google may not be able to capture it but there will be a lot of cash, and that maybe google's destiny - PG&E.
Just my two cents (been reading up on profitability and ROI of 19C railways - fascinating)
- taligent 14y agoTheir work on Google Fibre is definitely an interesting one and there is a huge opportunity there if they can get navigate their way around the massive players there already. But Google is playing smart by lobbying governments to open up competition. The car opportunity is pretty much non existent for them. All of the top 20 car manufacturers have had projects for years and Volvo, Toyota already have plans to launch in 2014. They may look to someone like Tesla for a partnership but they are niche.
- wamatt 14y agoInteresting that you're appear so dismissive of Google's self driving cars. I'm not claiming you're necessarily wrong, but I am intrigued about the other self driving options and how they surpass Google's solution? It would appear to be a widely held belief, that Google is the pioneer and leader in the field, at least with respect to the software/AI.
- taligent 14y ago> It would appear to be a widely held belief Among people who don't know much about the automotive industry. The software/AI is secondary to the ability of the solution to work in hundreds of millions of cars in hundreds of countries (all with varying regulations) under an infinite array of conditions. The car companies have decades of experience at this. Google has none. And even worse they have a penchant for beta software and a concerning inability to ship products properly. So whilst Google's software may be technically better (I don't know) in the grand scheme of things it is a meaningless consideration.
- yid 14y agoSigh. Stop rationalizing your pet Google peeves. > The software/AI is secondary to the ability of the solution to work in hundreds of millions of cars in hundreds of countries (all with varying regulations) under an infinite array of conditions. No it doesn't. It's perfectly fine if it works even with one car model if that spurs demand and further development. It's perfectly fine if the self-driving system initially only works in "good" conditions, since a driver should always be prepared to take over. It's perfectly fine if the system detects ice or snow and sets off a shit-ton of alarms warning the driver to take over. No initial offering of a brand new technology ever deals with every imaginable scenario. > The car companies have decades of experience at this. The car companies have decades of experience designing mechanical and electromechanical systems. Their software expertise sucks. Other than the Tesla, have you seen the dismal state of modern car software? Even BMW uses a system of rotary dials, and "apps" are just now becoming commonplace. Robust self-driving cars involve an unimaginable amount of software complexity. There are machine vision algorithms, sensor fusion algorithms, estimation and planning algorithms, learning algorithms, and probably a bevy of common-sense heuristics. There needs to be extensive testing of these algorithms, and careful bounds on their latency and reliability. These are computer science problems, not automotive problems. > Google has none. Google has cash. They can acquire people and expertise. See [1] > And even worse they have a penchant for beta software and a concerning inability to ship products properly. May I be bold enough to presume that the vast array of smart people they've hired might have realized that Gmail and self-driving cars require different approaches to software development.... [1] http://www.wired.com/autopia/2012/11/ron-medford-google-nhtsa/ http://www.wired.com/autopia/2012/11/ron-medford-google-nhts...
- notdrunkatall 14y agoQuite right. Just like TSLA is going to beat the big car companies at electric cars, so too will GOOG beat them at self-driving ones. The electro-mechanical and mechanical aspect of a self-driving car is the easy part; it is the software that will be where the real innovation occurs, and Google has arguably more software expertise than any other organization on the planet, and much, much more than any car company. If anyone can win that race, it's Google.
- ibrahima 14y ago> It would appear to be a widely held belief, that Google is the pioneer and leader in the field, at least with respect to the software/AI. To be precise, they swooped up the leaders in the field from the DARPA challenges, but same difference I suppose.
- bmuon 14y agoAll of the top 20 car manufacturers have had projects for years and Volvo, Toyota already have plans to launch in 2014 That's interesting. I haven't read anything like it. Do you have a source?
- taligent 14y agoHonestly there are so many sources its not funny. Toyota/Audi at CES: http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/145035-toyota-audi-showcase-self-driving-cars-at-ces-no-sign-of-google http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/145035-toyota-audi-showca... Volvo shipping in 2014: http://www.engadget.com/2012/12/03/volvo-self-driving-cars-2014/ http://www.engadget.com/2012/12/03/volvo-self-driving-cars-2... State of autonomous cars: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car And remember that the automative industry routinely share technologies within each group. So for example Audi technology may appear in all VW group brands e.g. Bentley, Porsche, SEAT, VW. Extrapolate across all the groups and Google's market opportunity evaporates pretty quickly.
- BitMastro 14y agoAnd once again YOU are so wrong it's not even funny. The sources you cite refer to a range of sensors that will be added to cars starting from 2014, like collision detection technologies. And the Volvo cars you always talk about are supposed to be in a train formation following a human-driven vehicle. A different kind of project from the self-driving cars from Google. Actual self-driving cars by other companies are always research projects with unclear timescales. Your need to despise something just because it's made by Google make you look pathetic. Just stop.
- nyrulez 14y agoBitter much ? Can you point me to some data for your claims and their accuracy records ? So far I have not heard of any real world testing (> 100,000 miles), with an impeccable safety record. Maybe there is and I am just missing it. Maybe you underestimate the technical hardness of the problem and what world class big data and machine learning can do for such a problem with an enormous number of scenarios. This is like going back in time and saying book opportunity is pretty much non-existent for Amazon. B&N and Borders know how to do books, have amazing distribution around the country and they are working on their online book stores anyway (which is not even technically hard to do)
- taligent 14y agoState of autonomous cars: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car And I might forward you to Formula 1 racing which is one of the most technologically sophisticated activities on the planet. The car companies involved e.g. Ferrari, Mercedes, McLaren are constantly dealing with big data, machine learning and real time simulations. http://storagemojo.com/2012/11/02/big-data-in-formula-1-racing/ http://storagemojo.com/2012/11/02/big-data-in-formula-1-raci... The idea that nobody can handle IT apart from web companies is a bit silly.
- BitMastro 14y agoThe sources you cite refer to a range of sensors that will be added to cars starting from 2014, like collision detection technologies. And the Volvo cars you always talk about are supposed to be in a train formation following a human-driven vehicle. A different kind of project from the self-driving cars from Google. Actual self-driving cars by other companies are always research projects with unclear timescales.
- adventured 14y agoInevitable drop in QE? The Fed is going to increase QE substantially soon, not decrease it. They can't hold down the 10 and 30 year rates with the tens of billions they're throwing at it now, and the US Government can't afford to pay higher rates on (soon to be) $20 trillion in debt. The Fed also doesn't want to allow mortgage rates to rise much, because that would nuke the housing market inflation they've worked so hard to get moving. The Fed has trapped itself in a death spiral that requires ever larger amounts of QE, and they have no intention of stopping (much less reducing their balance sheet). They speak to that in order to buy time, but they're lying and they know it. The $85 billion per month they're monetizing now, will move to $125+ billion in the coming quarters. With the currency wars going on now, the Fed will have to significantly increase the destruction of the dollar in order to stay with the other devaluing currencies (in order to prop up exports through artificial means that is). That will push asset and commodity inflation up until something explodes, essentially repeating the last two bubble cycles the Fed created (late 1990s and mid 2000s). They're running the same playbook over and over again, refusing to learn from their mistakes. The alternative is to stop propping up the economy with cheap money, which would lead to an immediate intense recession that no politician is willing to accept. So the outcome is obvious.