4 ms·
Or they could pay their tax bill. On revenues of $6B in Australia, they paid only $40M in tax, claiming only $99M in profit. http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/p
by vacri 14y ago
Or they could pay their tax bill. On revenues of $6B in Australia, they paid only $40M in tax, claiming only $99M in profit.
http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/political-news/labor-mp-takes-aim-at-apples-tax-bill-20130206-2dycv.html http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/political-news/labor-mp-tak...
- icelancer 14y agoAre they being prosecuted for tax evasion? If not, sounds like they are paying their bill. Take it up with your politicians.
- louischatriot 14y agoThat's a pretty hyprocritical statement. Big companies know how to legally pay almost no taxes, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement And that's probably not "our" politicians who are to blame.
- icelancer 14y ago>legally So it sounds to me like they are paying their tax bill. The fact that it's not as high as vacri or you may like is not their fault.
- rednukleus 14y agoBig corporations lobby to have tax laws that result in a low tax liability for themselves. Tax laws for large multinational corporations are also tend to get into grey areas, where it's hard to tell if something is legal or not (not saying Apple are necessarily in that grey area). The fact that big multinationals are not paying as much tax as many people think is fair is undeniably the fault of both those companies and politicians.
- icelancer 14y agoThe corporations are just acting on their incentives. The opportunity exists, therefore they're going to take advantage of it. Returning maximum value to shareholders is something that most (all?) corporations are trying to do. To not take advantage of government loopholes would be neglecting fiduciary duty. It's not the corporation's job to police morality. That responsibility theoretically belongs to the state. If they're inept and/or corrupt, so be it.
- rednukleus 14y ago> To not take advantage of government loopholes would be neglecting fiduciary duty. Not true. Taking advantage of loopholes is sometimes illegal, and sometimes a grey area. > If they're inept and/or corrupt, so be it. So why don't we all just give up then? Companies have a duty to earn as much money as possible regardless of morality, lobbying to get whatever laws changed they feel like in the process, and politicians can do whatever they want once they are elected. In my view letting corporations determine law, law determine morality, and accepting it without complaining is an exceptionally bad idea.
- icelancer 14y ago> In my view letting corporations determine law, law determine morality, and accepting it without complaining is an exceptionally bad idea. I absolutely agree. But as I said prior in the thread, expecting private corporations to not act in their best interest is like arguing against gravity.
- logn 14y agoThis attitude is annoying. They're forming overseas shell corporations with at most a few employees in those offices who claim an extremely high percentage of all IP-derived income. To claim these companies aren't doing anything illegal, simply because we can't prove that a few people in Ireland aren't responsible for all IP, isn't quite fair. Just because you've arranged fancy license agreements with your Ireland offices doesn't mean those contracts are valid or conscionable. These companies pay almost no taxes yet feed off our public universities, court systems, patent and trademark offices, copyright offices, public airwaves, highways, federal banking infrastructure, etc. It's sick.
- tedunangst 14y agoAnd all of the Apple employees driving on those highways pay income tax.
- logn 14y agoThose employees would be paying income tax at any job. The benefit is squarely to Apple owners. I really don't get the attitude of people who defend these companies paying almost no taxes. The same people must support billionaires paying 10% tax while the rest of us pay 25%+.
- gte910h 14y agoThere is a scheme in Australia where you don't have a separate cap gains rate, but you get direct credits for actual tax paid by a corporation. That could work out wonderfully in the US: The rich would pay taxes, somehow then.
- icelancer 14y ago> These companies pay almost no taxes yet feed off our public universities, court systems, patent and trademark offices, copyright offices, public airwaves, highways, federal banking infrastructure, etc. It's sick. You misunderstand me. I absolutely agree that it's sick. But it is 100% legal because the government allows it to occur. If you are expecting private organizations to not act in their own interest, you're basically fighting gravity.
- dageshi 14y agoOnce a tax system becomes so complicated that you need entire departments of people to work out what the "correct" amount of tax to pay is, you make tax susceptible to optomisation the same as any other part of a business.
- 27182818284 14y agoThe keyword there is legally. Not morally, ethically, according-to-you-ly, etc. And that's what it comes down to. If you want it another way, well, the laws need to be changed.
- vacri 14y agoDid you even bother reading the article? The very first sentence is about a politician pointing this problem out in Parliament. Hell, that a politician is involved is even in the HN-visible part of the URL.
- icelancer 14y agoYour argument is that they aren't paying their tax bill. That's just factually incorrect. I don't know what to tell you.
- vacri 14y agoYou replied with the incredibly intellectually lazy "take it up with your politicians", which is exactly what the article describes is happening, but were too lazy to bother reading even the first sentence of. The politicians are questioning the tax issue, and are implying that there is something fishy in the way Apple does their tax - the MP in question thinks that they are not paying their proper tax bill as a result.
- bnegreve 14y ago>The fact that it's not as high as vacri or you may like is not their fault. Lobbying (also lobby) is the act of attempting to influence decisions made by officials in the government [...] [1] It works pretty well when you are as big as Apple. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobbying http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobbying
- icelancer 14y agoWhat is stopping the government from saying: "No, too bad. Pay X amount of taxes instead of the proposed X-Y taxes."
- Scriptor 14y agoBecause "the government" is composed of the same people being lobbied to by Apple.
- icelancer 14y agoYes. That's the point. We elect those people. We get what we deserve.
- calbear81 14y agoIf governments make ex post facto changes to the tax law, you create a volatile business environment that turns off new investments especially from overseas investors. This is why countries that nationalize previously private enterprises without notice end up screwing up foreign investment. Who wants to start a company in X country if at any time they can say "No, too bad. Pay me 90% in taxes now."
- astrodust 14y agoI'm pretty sure that generated a ton of sales tax revenue.
- teamonkey 14y ago...which the consumer pays, not Apple.
- sputknick 14y agoIf they are only making 100m in profit of that 6b in revenue, then a 40% tax rate sounds about right.
- vacri 14y agoThe point is that Apple in Australia is basically just a retail arm. The idea that a retail arm has running costs of 97% is purely ludicrous - particularly the retail arm of the richest company in the world, the one of whom everyone talks about how much money they have and how dominant they are.
- xenophanes 14y agoHow is it Apple's fault that Australia has accounting and tax laws that you consider ludicrous?
- vacri 14y agoPerhaps you should read my comment again and have another go at finding what it was that I thought was ludicrous.
- deelowe 14y agoWhat tax bill? Though you use the term "bill," you seem to be arguing that they should actually donate money to the Australia government. I've haven't seen any news that would indicate Apple isn't paying the legally required taxes in Australia. If they do choose to donate money, I can think of a few better things for them to focus their philanthropic efforts on than government.
- mrmincent 14y agoto quote kerry packer: I am not evading tax in any way, shape or form. Now of course I am minimizing my tax and if anybody in this country doesn't minimize their tax they want their heads read because as a government I can tell you you're not spending it that well that we should be donating extra.
- vacri 14y agoTo even remotely consider Kerry Packer as an upstanding and completely above-board member of the community is just laughable from the outset. His persona lived large in the world of shady backroom deals, and he loved it. Sure, everyone wants to minimise their tax, but what quotes like this do is paper over the loopholes available to the very wealthy, that allow them to pay far less than a fair share of tax. Besides, using the argument of "but it's legal!" to end the conversation would suggest that no-one should ever make new laws, simply because anything that's currently legal 'must be right because it's legal'. A circular argument. For example: Should we make laws for greater transparency in government? No, because it's currently legal for them to hide their activities, therefore it must be correct!
- t_tsonev 14y agoWell said, mate. The fact that big corporations can get away with this pisses me to no end. I hope at least the shareholders will be paying some taxes :)