10 ms·
Review: BlackBerry 10 is better, much better, late than never
- tlack 14y agoAnyone got the inside info on why they are waiting so long to release these in America? Should have been available unlocked at launch if they really wanted to regain the hearts and minds of the fickle American consumer.
- arbitrage 14y agoIs an unlocked phone really that important to the majority of American consumers? They've showed quite readily in the past that they really don't care that much.
- Dirlewanger 14y agoNo. Majority would give you a blank stare if you mentioned a mobile phone being locked/unlocked.
- illuminate 14y agoI think T-Mobile may help to change that.
- illuminate 14y ago"They've showed quite readily in the past that they really don't care that much." I don't think the telco lobbying interests reflect the consumer's opinion.
- LilValleyBigEgo 14y agoIn the US, consumers buy scarcity. They want to have the thing that no one else in the US has. They want whatever they aren't allowed to have. So smart companies release their products in every other country first, then they save their US release for last. The longer they torture US consumers with not having the product everyone else has the higher their initial sales when they finally drop the product. Smart companies also create artificial scarcity by releasing their product in waves. If Americans think they might not be able to get the product because it will be sold out tomorrow they'll buy it today instead of waiting.
- scrabble 14y agoThe original idea was to use the rest of the world as a testing ground to work out any potential bugs in the software prior to releasing in the US. It could be even worse to release in the US with a critical bug than to release later.
- purephase 14y agoThat's just silly and so US-centric it's laughable (as is the parent). It's not BlackBerry that is causing the delay, the US carrier device testing/acceptance is the stumbling block. If it was up to BlackBerry they would be available now.
- scrabble 14y agoAs someone who used to work for BlackBerry, this was always the stated direction for BB10. Whether or not that's changed in the last few months, I can't say, but while I was there the intention was always to release in the US last to work the kinks out.
- sjwright 14y agoHello, this is the rest of the world. We don't want your buggy untested crap.
- 3pt14159 14y agoI'm in Canada, I'd rather have buggy untested crap than to wait for years for a vendor to bring it to Canada.
- songgao 14y agoIt's not about bugs. I believe it's more for testing the market, and helping learn about how people would react to the product. Microsoft sometimes release products in New Zealand earlier than the rest of the world, because New Zealand is small, and unlike european countries that are closely connected to each other, it's relatively independent to the rest of the world, which makes it a good place to pilot test products. My friend there is pretty happy for always being able to try newest products. It really can be a good thing. You get to hand on it first. And if BB find it going well in the rest of the world, they'll probably raise the price when releasing it in the US.
- bambax 14y agoI'm not sure about gestures (can they be done with one hand?) but the unified inbox ("hub") sounds like a fantastic idea. I don't understand why I can't see all messages from all my email accounts in one window, together with voice messages and texts (Tweets may be a little overwhelming, but they can be filtered out). This really sounds great -- although it's probably not hard to replicate on another platform.
- barista 14y agoWindows phone does this unification in a way that works better for me. All messages (sms, chat, facebook messages) are together All emails are together All social walls (facebook, twitter, linkedin, etc) are together. You can switch the communication medium i.e. reply to facebook message with an SMS and so on. Of course all of these are filterable and configurable. This seems to work better for me as they are most of the times distinct worlds.
- compilercreator 14y agoI got my Z10 yesterday and I can confirm that the phone (and all the gestures) are completely usable with just one hand. The phone size was selected pretty intelligently. I don't think the UI design would have worked with a bigger phone.
- purephase 14y agoIf you don't mind me asking, what platform were you on before? I'm considering ditching my iPhone for the Z10 as I'm so tired of Apple. I really miss the unified inbox in BlackBerry world and the hub sounds promising. App selection is not that important to me.
- compilercreator 14y agoI was using galaxy s2x. A variant of s2 with a 4.5 inch screen. That was hard to use single handed. This is my first blackberry so no idea how it compares with previous blackberry handsets.
- 14y ago
- malkia 14y agoAny word on PlayBook getting the BB10?
- scrabble 14y agoThey've always said that all PlayBooks will receive BB10. Who knows when though.
- manishsharan 14y agoI am not falling for BB again ! In my last iteration of smartphone purchase, I bought a latest-at-the-time Iphone 3GS for my wife and the latest-at-the-time Blackberry Bold. Since then I have watched in envy as my wife could get so much done on her phone than I could on my BB. My BB never did much beyond email and BBM ( I love BBM ) In this iteration, I recently placed an order for Nexus 4 and a Iphone 5. maybe if they are still around in 3~4 years from now, sure I could consider going back to BB.
- kunai 14y agoDid you even read the review? This isn't related AT ALL to the old OS7 Bold or any other Blackberry line, which were awful. BB10 can do much more than an iPhone and be just as productive while providing a rich media experience.
- untog 14y agoIt's still relevant. Increasingly, mobile OSes are less about where they are now than where they will be. Apple have been outstanding in that regard- providing OS updates to really quite old phones. Vanilla Android has been just as great, but individual Android manufacturers less so. MS has been terrible. BB has a history of being terrible. So, Blackberry's past is relevant. No, they might not repeat it, but absent of any other evidence, we can only judge them by past conduct. just as productive while providing a rich media experience. I don't even know what that means
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dean 14y ago"Apple have been outstanding in that regard- providing OS updates to really quite old phones." Yes, like the iOS 4 update for my 3G -- which made my phone so slow as to be almost useless. Came close to smashing it in frustration many, many times. So in my case at least, Apple providing an update to an old phone is definitely nothing to brag about. However, it did force me to upgrade the phone, and I'm guessing that was the point.
- kunai 14y agoLovely. This is really the first true smartphone OS since webOS that I'm actually excited for. The gestures are a little worrisome, however, with a 4-inch display. I have small hands, and it seems the gestures would require use of two hands... Another thing I noticed -- it seems like the UI's colors and typefaces were ripped straight from Android's Holo interface. No big deal, just something I noticed.
- speeder 14y agoGo blackberry!!!! Become another market for me to sell my stuff \o/
- rayiner 14y agoI'm psyched about the Q10. Just release it and take my money!
- MBCook 14y agoI'm surprised they're not promoting it more, it seems like an obvious win for they keyboard loving crowd. Too bad it may be delayed until mid year. http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/02/blackberry-q10-may-be-delayed/ http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/02/blackberry-q10-may-be...
- rcb 14y agoDoes anyone know if BB has the ability to push OS updates direct to customer handsets? Years ago such updates required carrier "approval"/intervention, which meant updates occurred infrequently (usually after significant delay), if ever. Edit: US carriers, specifically AT&T.
- shawn-butler 14y agoNope. [0] However, on unlocked phones you can load whatever image will work. [0] http://us.blackberry.com/support/apps-and-software/desktop-and-device-download-sites.html http://us.blackberry.com/support/apps-and-software/desktop-a...
- Pwnguinz 14y agoNot sure about BB10, but with previous BB's, you could always load whatever image will work. The "Network Carrier" branded version was unnecessary even if you had a branded BB. Somewhat like Android. You can also load tweaked custom OS's, or "hybrid OS's" as they're known in the BB community.
- shawn-butler 14y agoDon't really think that's true. I mean it was in some sense but for example if you loaded a seperate spectrum compatible, carrier "image" it might be fine until the next reboot at which time the carrier service books would get reloaded. So for example, you may have installed the bb maps and on the next reboot away they would disappear to be replaced with a link to purchase "AT&T Navigator", etc. The "AT&T Mall" would reappear, etc. Service book configuration was something fairly unique to BB and allowed carriers to configure the user experience to a pretty significant extent. Doesn't really apply to BB10 afaik so it's just reminiscing about the bad old days, irregardless.
- Osiris 14y agoI welcome any competition into the mobile OS market, especially if it brings a refreshing new take on design and user experience. My devices all run Android and while it's usable, I'm not a huge fan of many aspects of the OS. While I don't plan on getting a BB10 device, I am interested to see if or how its innovations cause other OS vendors to adjust their own user experience.
- dmix 14y agoI'm fine with the Android OS, still not a fan of the hardware. Although its gotten better, Android phones are still nowhere near the physical build quality of the iPhone 4 (including the S3 which I'm currently using).
- eropple 14y agoBattery life aside, I found the Nexus 4's build quality to be quite nice--in the iPhone ballpark. (The battery life was a killer for me, though, so I went back to my Galaxy Nexus.)
- pavanky 14y agoWhen I held the iphone 5 it felt like I could damage it if I held it with a tight grip[ (I am a big man). My One X doesn't feel that way. Perhaps what physical build quality means is subjective?
- janlukacs 14y agoi think people should give it a chance, too much negativity due to fanboyism.
- fusiongyro 14y agoIs it fanboyism, or could it instead be: - I need a phone that works - I only need one phone - I don't want a phone from a defunct manufacturer - App availability is more significant than platform quality The first one means I don't want to debug your beta product. The second one prevents me from experimentally getting a bunch of different phones and seeing which one I like better. The third gives me pause when dealing with Blackberry, who have been having huge corporate troubles for years. The fourth is a reminder that if I were to switch there are lots of apps I'd be giving up with no replacement (SmartGo Books comes to mind). The idea that Apple has everyone brainwashed is really quite absurd. Overpriced? Maybe. Overhyped? Probably. Bad? No.
- zmonkeyz 14y agoIt's sad when people hate on every piece of tech that isn't their favorite. If they would have came out with a new Bold with OS 7.5 people would bitch. They develop BB10 and people still bitch.
- KeyBoardG 14y agoI was put off just in the new BBM, where some options were hidden under the left swipe menu, other the right swipe menu and yet more under the top swipe menu. Not to mention options hidden under the button bar at the bottom. I don't want to spend my time looking all over in apps for an action. They need to set strict guidelines on where things go.
- purephase 14y agoI sat down with a handset a few months ago with a QA guy at BlackBerry and had basically the same feedback for them. Apparently, it is something they're working on. I haven't seen the OS since launch so I don't know if this was addressed, at all. They're hardly alone in this regard. iOS/Android suffers from the same problem.
- sgt 14y agoIt's also QNX based, so should be pretty rock solid, being a microkernel based RTOS with a small memory footprint. Also (interestingly), its network stack is based on NetBSD code.
- easternmonk 14y agoBlackberry has done a good job. It may not be iPhone/Android killer but it is definitely at par with the best in the league. Had BB come up with this 2 years back it would have been great. But I am willing to give them a chance. I hope the voice and screen sharing works good.
- zmmmmm 14y agoIt's great to see a fully gesture based phone. I've always thought this would be the most natural way to interact with a touch based device, and it's always the gesture based apps and interactions that I enjoy using most on my phone. My only hesitation is whether gestures interfere with normal use of the phone. Will it confuse interactions in the game I am playing with the swipe to go back to the home screen, for example? If it does, it's going to be hugely problematic. But if it's done well it will be the most enjoyable and natural interface out there, I think.
- icki 14y agoI'd have to agree with you that gesture interactions tend to feel more natural then typical button pressing (e.g. pinch-to-zoom), but can be a little awkward for first time users. A customer who stops by a mobile phone kiosk while walking through their local mall might not know how to handle a BB10 device without assistance from a sales associate. However, gestures often become second-nature, and users rarely find themselves asking "how do I do this again?" Swipe-upwards to unlock/return to homescreen requires initial contact with the screen's bezel, which should mitigate the number of times this gesture is unnecessarily actuated.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> Swipe-upwards to unlock/return to homescreen requires initial contact with the screen's bezel Hopefully that works well. However when playing games it's pretty easy to hit the bezel when you're aiming for something on the edge of the screen. I always used to have this problem (and still do) on Android phones with their capacitive / on screen buttons.
- fi0660 14y agoIt works surprisingly well in Nokia N9. I think games are also allowed to disable the gestures while the game is in non-paused state.
- muyuu 14y agoMy old Blackberry Curve 3G, which I use alongside an Android phone, still gives me a battery life of 3 days solid under normal usage. Will they match that?
- helloamar 14y agoI trusted blackberry from the bold 9000, with that trust I got a playbook thinking they will add more apps but after waiting for more than a year I got the iPad4, Now I have a bold 9900, time to change my phone in a couple of months ,now the bb10 arrives I'm waiting for the apps that keeps my business running if it didn't show up I'm going to get the iPhone
- adjin 14y agoI thought it has a lot of interesting ideas. Although much of them can be emulated by any other platform, if BB proves to continue innovation especially in the business/corporate sector it could gather quite a following.
- tcdowney 14y agoI just found out about their 10k Developer Commitment last Friday and a few close friends and I are scrambling to get a Blackberry native app finished in time for the upcoming submissions deadline. Never having done this before all I can say is that it's been fun! :) BlackBerry 10 is much nicer than I had anticipated and, although I won't be moving away from Android, I am excited for BlackBerry to make a serious effort at returning to the market. :)