2 ms·
Don't you think Kansas City had a municipal franchise agreement in place with telecom/cable providers before Google stepped in? Surely some modifications had t
by joezydeco 14y ago
Don't you think Kansas City had a municipal franchise agreement in place with telecom/cable providers before Google stepped in? Surely some modifications had to be made to allow a competing company to lay fiber.
In fact, that probably explains the whole "Hey kids! Get your town to enter the Google Fiber Lucky City Sweepstakes!" that was used to roll Google Fiber out. The winning city bought into the fiber idea so hard that the next step of kicking out the franchise agreements would be a snap.
- rayiner 14y agoGoogle signed one of their own and it looks like the got a pretty sweetheart deal on it: http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Google-Can-Ditch-Kansas-City-After-Two-Years-120807 http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Google-Can-Ditch-Kansas-C... Lamenting about how political telecom can get is somewhat naive. Of course it's political. It involves digging up public/private property under municipal permission. It invokes the same contentious debates that all infrastructure projects invoke: richer neighborhoods versus poor one, urban ones versus rural ones, "not in my backyard," etc. As long as telecom involves digging up public land or using public spectrum, it will be intensely political.
- joezydeco 14y agoDigging up yards is something local politicians could care less about. That's why easements exist. They're dug up all the time for electricity, gas, telephone, street lights, etc. The political tradeoff comes from the franchise agreement. Your citizens want cable tv, and Comcast only wants to wire up the higher-end neighborhoods because they'll buy more services. Is that how you want to be portrayed? So you tell Comcast to make the deal: wire up the whole town, even that neighborhood 3000 feet up the hill, and we'll guarantee that nobody else can interfere with your physical plant investment. Comcast sleeps soundly at night, and so do the politicians.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoFranchise agreement == monopoly. Cable TV pays off their 'physical plant' investment in a couple of months, and spends the rest of their years raking it in. Every small town in Iowa, the biggest house in town? The cable franchise operator.
- rayiner 14y ago> They're dug up all the time for electricity, gas, telephone, street lights, etc. All of those things are done under municipal authority. You can grant Comcast an easement to wire up your house, but what about digging under public streets or across your neighbor's yard? Also, I don't disagree with the second part, but a fair characterization includes the fact that those people up on that hill have twice the votes per capita as the people living downtown.
- joezydeco 14y agoYou, as a property owner, don't grant easements to utilities. Those are owned by the municipality. You can't delete them.
- rayiner 14y agoWhere do you think those easements come from? At some point, the municipality agreed to invoke it's eminent domain authority to let some utility lay cables, pipes, sewer lines, etc. That gave that utility a monopoly on service. In return for these monopolies, utilities extracted concessions like requiring the utilities to service everyone.