14 ms·
Hello Firefox, this is Chrome calling
- untog 14y agoFantastic news. I feel like the basic videochat model we see in WebRTC demos is only the beginning of the possibilities here. When all browsers support WebGL and WebRTC I'll be fascinated to see what people more creative than myself can create.
- nwh 14y agoChrome now has WebGL enabled for everyone that supports it, which is a big leap towards getting the majority of users on compatible browsers.
- Quarrelsome 14y agoDo you know if IE will implement it?
- riffraff 14y agoOpen Croquet 2.0? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croquet_Project http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croquet_Project
- IgorPartola 14y agoImagine how much more awesome this will be when we also have IPv6. We will have no more need for things like ICE [1], just direct point to point communication. Oh, and multicast for giant video chat sessions. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_Connectivity_Establishment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_Connectivity_Establ...
- loeg 14y agoMulticast on the internet is a nice dream. Will it actually happen with IPv6? My understanding is there is a barrier to adoption — basically all routers involved need to be aware of the multicast initiation/join/leave protocol, and basically, there's a bunch of old hardware/software out there that isn't aware. Is all IPv6-capable hardware capable of this (given that IPv6 came out in ... 1998)?
- 0x0 14y agoI had the impression that the biggest hurdle for multicast to happen on the internet is the insane memory requirements for routers to track all the multicast memberships (as well as being extremely open for abuse -- imagine one client subscribing to every multicast stream out there and never leaving, that would flood the incoming pipes for that ISP)
- __alexs 14y agoIPv6 is also pretty much a requirement due to the whole multicast MAC address collision thing I believe.
- Ironlink 14y agoWhile I don't know anything about how multicast is specified, I would certainly hope that it is possible to implement in such a way that each router only needs to track the memberships of it's direct neighbors. They would then themselves advertise that membership in order to serve their neighbor's request. As for the abusive client, I say if the ISP has any sense of self preservation, they should be interested to police this themselves. For example, knowing how much bandwidth the client is paying for, they could refuse additional or even cut existing memberships of that client once that limit is reached.
- wmf 14y agoThe problem is that a router's direct neighbors may be subscribed to millions of multicast groups and nobody has enough TCAM to track those memberships.
- temp453463343 14y agoThat's never going to happen b/c there is too much legacy infrastructure and the benefit is marginal. All current home routers are configured to do NAT, so you're not going to be able to have a Skype 2.0 be P2P b/c then you'd need to explain to millions of people how to reconfigure their routers. Also P2P opens a whole new can of worms when it comes to security.
- IgorPartola 14y ago> That's never going to happen b/c there is too much legacy infrastructure and the benefit is marginal. It is going to have to happen, or there will be no internet. > All current home routers are configured to do NAT, so you're not going to be able to have a Skype 2.0 be P2P b/c then you'd need to explain to millions of people how to reconfigure their routers. Current home routers will be replaced within a year or two. They do not last that long. Some people are starting to not have dedicated routers, instead renting equipment from the ISPs. > Also P2P opens a whole new can of worms when it comes to security. Firewalls have been around for a long time. We'll survive.
- ttflee 14y agoI'm quite pessimistic about the infrastructure, considering the speed of acceptance of IPv6.
- temp453463343 14y agoYou're also assuming that there won't be NAT with IPv6; I don't know that that is a safe assumption. "Current home routers will be replaced within a year or two." Yeah right! My grandma isn't gunna be changing her router. And she'll be pissed if her stuff stopped working. At then end of the day, if you have the choice between making a NAT friendly product that everyone can use and a non NAT friendly product that has some extra privacy - you'll be choosing the NAT friendly option. "Firewalls have been around for a long time." The thing in windows that everyone disables? NAT is transparent and fool proof. How can you ensure a 3rd party won't be able to connect to your fancy new P2P chat client? Security holes are pervasive in networking code so without NAT and a with a bit of sloppy code, the "bad guys" can at any time connect directly to your computer. Can you imagine the chaos that would happen if there was a zero day bug in a P2P Skype. With NAT 99% of your problems are gone. It's physically impossible to connect to a computer that doesn't have port forwarding. Unless the US gov't comes in an enforces a switch to IPv6 (like it did with digital TVs and all those subsidized converter boxes) directly connecting to computers isn't going to happen.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jstalin 14y agoWell, it's encrypted, so that seems like a reasonable alternative to the potential of being spied upon when using Skype.
- TranceMan 14y agoSo if we encrypt stuff we are not spied on? Naive....
- sdp 14y agoEncrypting data certainly increases the barrier to entry for spying.
- TranceMan 14y agoNo it doesn't, it means if somebody doesn't really want to spy on you they just will not waste their time....
- artichokeheart 14y agoIsn't that the definition of a raised barrier? Even if it isn't very high.
- amckenna 14y agoYes it does. Adding encryption, even if it can be broken through sheer computational power, still increases the price tag associated with spying, therefore increasing the barrier to spying.
- homosaur 14y agoYeah, but what does it matter then? I can stand outside the bank safe all day and stare at it but unless I know the code I'm still just looking at a locked box. Strong encryption is the same way, feel free to stare at my VPN stream all day, it won't help you.
- 14y ago
- shmerl 14y agoIt's good to see this moving forward. A few questions need to be addressed in order for this to become really useful. How is XMPP/Jingle supposed to work over WebRTC? I.e. in order for the browser to connect to a standalone VoIP client for example (think of implementing Google Talk plugin in pure JavaScript). From what it looks like, this can require some support for this scenario in XMPP servers (not unlike they need something to support XMPP over WebSockets). So this is really an important piece of the puzzle which needs to be ready.
- jallmann 14y agoInteroperability with V/VoIP protocols will still require a translation layer somewhere. That can be on the browser, or on the server, but you will still need some server-side component to relay the signaling information through (eg, websocket proxy), or a browser-interoperability mechanism (for xmpp, BOSH). If the remote endpoint doesn't support WebRTC's flavor of SRTP, then you're going to have to relay media through your server. If SDP offer/answer is still being considered for WebRTC, then that should simplify interop a bit since media negotiation shares a common denominator with most other V/VoIP protocols (which is really the only relevant part when we're talking about WebRTC). Of course, all that is moot if both endpoints can't agree on a codec to support. Opus is brand new, and no one cares about VP8. Hardware devices are not likely to be compatible anytime soon (without a transcoding layer in between), which leaves softphones.
- shmerl 14y agoThat's what I meant - most probably some server support will be required. I hope ejabberd and others will address this. Until that WebRTC won't be useful for building web based XMPP/Jingle clients. Regarding codecs - most XMPP/Jingle clients support VP8 and Opus is catching up too. It's not like there are many of them around anyway. Farstream supports both if corresponding gstreamer components are present.
- jallmann 14y agoIIRC, ejabberd is agnostic about the XMPP messages going through, you should be able to use strophe.js to craft the proper Jingle packets from the browser's offer/answer session description. Given codec and SRTP compatibility with clients, eg GTalk (which I don't know about), you should be good to go.
- kaolinite 14y agoAwesome technology but christ that conversation was awkward. Can't wait to play with it though.
- dbaupp 14y agoI feel like DataChannels are the best part of the WebRTC standard (or would be, if they were usable): a true p2p connection allowing transfer of arbitrary data without plugins or anything. This gives multiplayer games, file transfers, realtime chat and collaborative editors (let your imagination run wild...) and the only thing a server is required for is establishing the connection (and saving state). This functionality is much more exciting than simple video or audio chat.
- FuzzyDunlop 14y agoI agree, and it's easy to tell just in the way you can describe it. The first thing video/audio chat brings to mind to anyone is 'Skype in the browser'. That's still cool and there is definitely more potential than that, but just having an arbitrary connection is a lot more open ended and exciting.
- comex 14y agoUnfortunately, if this page is accurate, DataChannels don't really work yet: http://www.webrtc.org/chrome#TOC-Data-Channels- http://www.webrtc.org/chrome#TOC-Data-Channels- A shame, because I have a use in mind for them. :)
- phowat 14y agoIt works on some alpha release of both Firefox and Chrome. There are already some file transfer apps if you're curious, although I haven't tested myself: https://github.com/lindstroem/FileTransfer https://github.com/lindstroem/FileTransfer and https://github.com/peer5/sharefest https://github.com/peer5/sharefest . Also, the folks from easyrtc ( https://github.com/priologic/easyrtc https://github.com/priologic/easyrtc ) have already started working on adding DataChannels to their library.
- tracker1 14y agoA bit-torrent like client in the native browser would be interesting... wonder where Opera is on this one.
- 14y ago
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoLooks neat. One thing I wonder about tech' like this, is that it is encrypted from you to the service, but there is no assurance of privacy. Someone who runs a service like this can easy drop in on your calls and ease-drop. Which is a legitimate concern if someone wanted to use this either in a corporate environment or for very private calling (e.g. husband and wife, doctor and patient, etc). No current video tech' really offers much in the way of assured privacy. Skype used to but it has been largely rolled back since Microsoft took over.
- untog 14y agoMy understanding is that it's possible to not have a 'service' and instead form connections from one person directly to another. That decentralization would be a privacy boon.
- taeric 14y agoWell, without knowing the details of how they think two computers can reliably form a secure link without foreknowledge of each other, this doesn't exactly sound bullet proof. Self signed certs or something similar can only go so far. Hell, CA verified certs don't exactly go as far as most should be comfortable with.
- ianb 14y agoUnfortunately, no: both browsers need to exchange volatile information to establish the connection. It includes information like how to traverse NATs to get to the other browser. You need some more centralized service to exchange that information and bootstrap the process.
- isaacwaller 14y agoI believe WebRTC is peer to peer.
- dbaupp 14y agoAs others have pointed out, the data doesn't go through a central service, but is actually p2p. The only thing a central service would be required for is establishing the connections so that the browsers can find each other on the internet.
- j45 14y agoIt looks like it works very smoothly and the fact that no account or additional software is needed is great!
- christiangenco 14y agoI was very amused at how Hugh Fenning just read the script the whole time.
- Jabbles 14y agoNote that Chrome (or the application) chooses to reverse the self-view so that it acts like a mirror, whereas Firefox (or its application) chooses to display what the other person sees. It's a hard choice to make.
- timdorr 14y agoActually, not really. It's all HTML 5 video elements on the page, so this is all you need: .mirrored { transform: scaleX(-1); } And you can make a button to add/remove that class as needed. However, I do hope the implementations are consistent as to which way it flips the video.
- bajsejohannes 14y agoChanging it is easy. Adding options is an easy way to avoid choices. But Jabbles' point still remains: It's a hard choice to make.
- untog 14y agoI don't think it's a hard choice for the browser to make- send the data as it is captured by the camera. How that is displayed is something else, but as timdorr demonstrates, it's not difficult to toggle.
- criley 14y agoIt's a hard choice for the human who has to pick one or the other and justify that decision.
- untog 14y agoIn what way? The developer should have no problem justifying the decision. "It's what the camera sensor sees". I absolutely understand the application in webchat and why you would want it to be mirrored at a page level, but I'm at a loss to understand why the browser implementation would try to reflect that.
- taeric 14y agoI have a terrible confession to make. I can't bring myself to be too excited about this, yet. I can already make a video chat from my Linux box running either Firefox or Chrome to my mother running IE. What, exactly, are the benefits of this?
- macleanjr 14y agoNo third party plugin is required to be installed.
- taeric 14y agoI get that, though I do not necessarily get what makes that so awesome. Essentially, my browser is already a third party plugin to my computer. I think I would be more excited if this were distinct plugins running in the respective browsers. Would be much more indicative of a truly free environment, instead of just two of the top contestants doing something.
- hayksaakian 14y agoIt's so that if you tell your mother to get google chrome, she does not also have to get a separate plugin.
- taeric 14y agoYou aren't exactly making this sound more free. I would honestly prefer it if I could just buy her a large TV and we could setup video calls with it. (They already have cameras built in nowdays.) Hell, why stop at the TV. Her phone likely has all that is needed for this. Does this go any further to making that happen? I guess I can see how it does. I mean, the idea is that this protocol can be used to communicate between two vendors. But, that can already be done. It is done, on a regular basis. What, exactly, makes this special?
- Bjartr 14y ago
- rsingel 14y agoPlease don't let the DoJ see this video. They will want a backdoor at the protocol layer.
- Finster 14y agoVery cool, but there's still a lot that each group needs to do to be truly interoperable. You can see a rundown of the issues on webrtc.org: http://www.webrtc.org/interop http://www.webrtc.org/interop Most of it can be worked around, but for a web developer, there's still a lot of wiring that has to get untangled for it all to work as seamlessly as it appears in the video demos. Definitely some cool technology, though.
- tocomment 14y agoI'm not following what this is. Can someone explain it like I'm five?
- koide 14y agoRemember when we videochat with Grandma using Skype? Well, for that to happen she has to use Skype and so do we. There is no other use for that program but to videochat. Now, we can videochat using the same program we use to play those silly Flash games instead. And we don't even have to be using the same program, she can use Firefox, and we can still use Chrome. This also opens new things you can do that you couldn't before. Given that Chrome or Firefox do a lot more than just videochat, we can now embed videochat in all the other things the browsers can do, like in games or live support.
- benaiah 14y agoThe first guy is talking to the second guy, even though they're very far apart. We used to have to use a special part of the computer for this, but now we can use the regular part that we use for most of our other stuff. We also used to have to ask another person every time we wanted to talk to each other this way. Now, some of the time, we can talk to each other without asking him first. Explaining it like you're ten might be more useful: You know Skype? Well, now we can do that on the Internet [Ed: I know, but you're ten, so bear with me]. Also, we can send the video straight from one computer to another. We used to have to send it far away, to another computer, and then he would send it to the person we were talking to. We can also hide what we are saying from other people. Pretend you're mailing a letter to Grandma. Before, we had to mail a postcard to our mean aunt, who would send it to Grandma. Now, we can put it in an envelope and send it straight to Grandma's house.
- hellopat 14y agoI haven't really been keeping up on WebRTC, so forgive this fairly ignorant question. Will the framework allow me to create a one to many connection? ie. presentation mode where one person could broadcast their audio / video to many viewers? Or is it simple a 1:1 connection?
- sunwooz 14y agoI was really looking forward to this! Would it be possible to have more than one person connected in a html5 mmo game?
- lifeguard 14y agoFF is not worried. Chrome has a conflict of interest when it comes to ad blocking. FF will always do it better. And ad networks are a major infection vector, so more users are needing ad blocking than ever before.
- zanny 14y agoThis has nothing to do with the article. Though, since I just love me some flame bait, Google will never take ad block out of Chrome because someone would just fork Chromium and keep it in.
- davidw 14y agoWhat kind of video codec/protocol/format/platform/whatever does it use? I was having a devil of a time trying to get something up that's real time-ish, lately: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/14623963/stream-low-latency-video-to-chrome-on-nexus-7 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/14623963/stream-low-laten...
- kyro 14y agoYes, please, please, please kill Skype. Kill it mercilessly. Using it has been the worst experience I've ever had with an application. I've been in a long distance relationship for a few years now and Skype has sadly been our main mode of video communication. The app crashes when I search chat history, can take upwards of 90+% of my CPU, literally forcing me to shut down every other application I have running. The forums are full of complaints, all unanswered. We've tried gChat and the plugin either goes undetected or slows down my machine as well (although not as bad as Skype). I'm running a 2010 MBA, so I've got the resources. So death to Skype, and open arms to WebRTC.
- lightyrs 14y agoHave you tried Google Hangouts? I've had some success with that lately over Skype.
- dudus 14y agoI would expect Google Hangouts to use webRTC when available and use the Talk plugin only as a fallback.
- neutronicus 14y agoI love Google Hangouts, and prefer them to Skype, but they bring my laptop to its knees. Multicolored pinwheels everywhere.
- irollboozers 14y agoMeetings.io was our go-to service for a while, it was just so insanely better than Google hangouts and skype. It showed so much promise, until sadly they were acquired and now it sucks.
- gcb0 14y agoi tried and it's a pain to install the plugin. never works on my debian-sid.
- donniezazen 14y ago
- bitwize 14y ago"Hello, Mike." "Hello, Joe! System working?" "Seems to be." "Okay, fine."
- pteredactyl 14y agoThat's cute.
- dschiptsov 14y agoA final good bye to all those crappy flash-based chats.
- borplk 14y agoDoes this mean direct peer 2 peer connection within browser? Under what conditions can there be direct peer-to-peer connection? For example is it possible to have a chat application that is purely peer-to-peer?
- kumail_hemani 14y agoLooks great, is the Google Dart team working on getting this integrated?
- gkhnarik 14y agoIt is also supposed to work Chrome to Chrome right? It says the room is full. Anybody get same error?
- tbenst 14y agoPhew, just restored equilibrium by upvoting only this submission
- cmatthieu 14y agoWe are in the process of adding persistent chat and conferencing to Twelephone (http://twelephone.com http://twelephone.com). These features, in addition to our existing audio/video calling and presence using Twitter as a directory service, should put our free service near feature parity with Skype. We're using HTML5 WebRTC with encrypted peerconnections and soon datachannels. Stay tuned...