3 ms·
Partly it's brilliant (progressive tax rates on corporation profits encourages corporations to split themselves up) Partly it's not thought through (tax on gro
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
Partly it's brilliant (progressive tax rates on corporation profits encourages corporations to split themselves up)
Partly it's not thought through (tax on gross income not profit - but that would tax Dell on a thousand dollar laptop when they might make 20 bucks)
And partly it's plain crazy - taxing a company till it becomes smaller is like having agent provacteur for cartel prosecutions
- nextparadigms 14y agoThen Dell should find a way to be profitable in that business, or create new businesses that are more profitable. I think if the revenue tax was implemented in all countries, it would also solve the problem of companies shifting profits from one division to another to avoid paying much in certain countries. If you had 1 billion dollar revenues from a country's citizens, then you pay say 2% of that in taxes.
- shepik 14y agoIf that kind of tax was implemented in all countries, this would render almost all phone manufacturers (except, well, you know, Apple) unprofitable. In fact it would not: they'll just raise prices, and we, as customers, will effectively pay this tax, not businesses.
- pwg 14y agoBut ultimately, at the end of the road, are not all taxes levied against businesses effectively paid by their consumers in the ultimate price of the product/service provided by the business? The business does not make money appear from thin air. Any money that goes from the business to the tax authority has to have originally arrived in the business from a customer buying the product or service offered.
- juan_juarez 14y agoTaxing on gross is bad when your value add is simply integration. In the case of building computers - you take a bunch of components from individual producers, slap them together & call it a new product. The actual work done is very little & the margins are small but the total cost of the finished product has to reflect the cost of the components. Putting $10 of labor and $5 of infrastructure to make $5 of profit on top of a $1000 device become unfeasible. Reading the article, they claim an operation like this is an ideal remedy to being "too big" yet their proposed tax plan makes it untenable.
- jerrya 14y agoOne problem with taxing on profit is that you encourage accounting tricks. Consider the reputation of the movie industry where actors and authors and everyone up and down the line are screwed because they took a percentage of the profits and it turns out according to the studio accountants, their megablockbuster never actually turned a profit.
- aetherson 14y agoBut taxing on gross means that you penalize low-margin companies. Take two basically identical companies. They sell, say, computers. One company has a "luxury" brand and they sell 1 million units at $2,000 a piece with a $500 profit on each. They have gross sales of $2 billion and profit of $500 million. The other company has an "economy" brand and they sell 5 million units at $1,000 a piece with a $50 profit on each. They have gross sales of $5 billion, and a profit of $250 million. The luxury company is taxed at 1%, and the economy company is taxed at 5%. The economy company's entire profit is eaten by the tax, so they must raise their prices to $1,050. The luxury company may or may not raise their prices at all -- if they do, they raise them to $2,020, maintaining their profit level. We have effectively propped up the luxury company's business model. They have reduced the price differential between themselves and their competitor, and the people paying the difference are the tax-payer. Why did we do this? Do we like corporations having very high profits? I'm not aware of that as being a national goal.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoWhy are the two companies taxed at different rates? Surely they should both be treated equally - or is it a gross tax that has effective net rate of 1% of 500 million for luxury company - which seems a very small fraction to tax at ?
- chongli 14y agoThe article advocates for a progressive tax; that is, one which increases with gross income. The luxury company has a gross income of $1 billion while the economy brand company has a gross income of $5 billion. This is why they'd have different tax rates.
- jrs235 14y agoIn your Dell scenario then Dell would have to pass the tax on to the consumer in the price of their laptop. "Simple" as that. If the rate is 2% then Dell would have broken even on the $1000 laptop, so if they wish to make some profit they'll need to raise their price slightly.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]