15 ms·
Can anyone recommend a good book (preferably on Kindle) that explains climate change and our actual scientific knowledge? The issue seems to be so politicized t
by MichaelGG 14y ago
Can anyone recommend a good book (preferably on Kindle) that explains climate change and our actual scientific knowledge? The issue seems to be so politicized that all sources seem incredibly biased. Sure, there might changes happening, but from history, isn't that what the climate does? It seems that one side portrays it as no big deal, and the other says we'll all die in a few decades.
I'm not looking for something telling me how to behave or react, just something that covers how/what we know for certain. Or is the science and understanding required too far out of reach for laymen?
- tlrobinson 14y agoI would also love to know this. I stopped paying attention to the debate because everything I was reading (admittedly not much, and mostly mainstream stuff) seemed highly politicized one way or the other.
- moultano 14y agoHere are the resources realclimate.org suggests. http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/05/start-here/ http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/05/start-... For the details of the science, they suggest just reading the IPCC reports. Here's a faq from the IPCC that is basic but thorough. https://www.ipcc-wg1.unibe.ch/publications/wg1-ar4/ar4-wg1-faqs.pdf https://www.ipcc-wg1.unibe.ch/publications/wg1-ar4/ar4-wg1-f...
- pdonis 14y agoI would not recommend reading realclimate.org without also reading climate audit and watts up with that: http://climateaudit.org/ http://climateaudit.org/ http://wattsupwiththat.com/ http://wattsupwiththat.com/
- scarmig 14y agoThey're not really comparable. Real Climate is written by academic climatologists. Its last five non-open thread posts were: 1) The Greenland melt 2) What to study? 3) Sea-level rise: Where we stand at the start of 2013 — Part 2 4) Sea-level rise: Where we stand at the start of 2013 5) On Sensitivity Part II: Constraining Cloud Feedback without Cloud Observations Climate Audit is written by a retired mathematician/mining prospector. Last 5 posts: 1) More on Acton’s “Investigation” 2) Acton and “Natural Person Powers” 3) Acton and Muir Russell at Tribunal 4) Duke C Punctures More Attempted UEA Obtuseness 5) More Tricks from East Anglia Watts Up With That, written by a former television meteorologist/newscaster: 1) The Revkin-Gavin debate on lower climate sensitivity 2) NPR finally gets it – does this signal an end to the polar bear as poster bear for global warming? 3) The yearly lukewarm report 4) Here there be Dragons 5) New paper by Richard Tol – Targets for global climate policy: An Overview I think that speaks for itself.
- JPKab 14y agoThank you. I think the biggest red flag I have with the people who question the science behind anthropogenic global warming theory isn't that they are questioning it, but they are doing so in a clearly non-scientific, selctively biased way. I've seen bad science debunked before (we all have), like ulcers being caused by stress(actually caused by bacteria), cold fusion, etc. The folks cruasading against antrhopogenic global warming have all to often picked a position based on opposition to the most commonly proposed solution to antrho global warming(reducing consumption of fossil fuels), and then sought out science to support their position. The problems are obvious: 1) Let's say there is a legitimate argument about reduction of fossil fuel use vs. a geo-engineering scheme to remove CO2 from the atmosphere. This argument never gets to happen because people who are against fossil fuel usage reduction as a solution never admit the problem even exists. (I have to admit, I think reduction of carbon emissions is unrealistic, because the countries which benefit the most from carbon rich fuel consumption in the short term are the poorest countries with the most people. I don't realistically see India decide to keep its people poor and without electricity/transport when they don't have to. People don't give a shit about saving the planet until they have food in their own and children's bellies, and aren't dying of diseases easily prevented by fossil fuel powered infrastructure) 2) The group of people who are currently arguing that the warming is not caused by human activity heavily, HEAVILY overlap with the group of people who were denying that warming was even happening 8 years ago. This is a huge red flag. Do I discredit scientists if they are proven wrong one time? No. But if a "doctor" says vaccines are bad because they cause autism, and when proven wrong, invents another argument against vaccines, I write him off as a quack who doesn't follow the scientific method. And I'm right. These guys are basically saying "Don't cut carbon! The planet isn't getting warmer." Now they have changed their answer to "Don't cut carbon. It's not the reason the planet is getting warmer. " And frankly, I'm getting sick of people who don't even have a single scientific degree attacking scientists. It all reeks of the same attitude I was innundated with as a kid by my classmates because I believed in evolution and dinosaurs.
- jacquesm 14y ago> And frankly, I'm getting sick of people who don't even have a single scientific degree attacking scientists. What about people without a single scientific degree supporting scientists?
- mratzloff 14y agoThere are not always two sides to a story.
- guscost 14y agoHere is an interesting book about the IPCC: http://www.amazon.com/Delinquent-Teenager-Mistaken-Climate-ebook/dp/B005UEVB8Q http://www.amazon.com/Delinquent-Teenager-Mistaken-Climate-e...
- scarmig 14y agoThe IPCC report on the Physical basis of climate change is gonna be your best bet. http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/contents.html http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/contents... (There are doubtlessly a couple people queueing up to say the IPCC's part of some grand socialist conspiracy or had some minor error that's since been corrected in the errata section.)
- run4yourlives 14y agoWhile I'm not a "denier" per se, the IPCC has made some monumental errors (hockey stick, anyone?) in the past that have really hampered their ability to be a source of non-political "good science".
- snowwrestler 14y ago> The test in science is whether findings can be replicated using different data and methods. More than two dozen scientific papers, using various statistical methods and combinations of proxy records, have produced reconstructions supporting the broad consensus shown in the original 1998 hockey-stick graph, with variations in how flat the pre-20th century "shaft" appears.[12][13] The 2007 IPCC Fourth Assessment Report cited 14 reconstructions, 10 of which covered 1,000 years or longer, to support its strengthened conclusion that it was likely that Northern Hemisphere temperatures during the 20th century were the highest in at least the past 1,300 years.[14] Ten or more subsequent reconstructions, including Mann et al. 2008, have supported these general conclusions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy
- schoper 14y agoThe collected historical temperature data series are messy. You plot them and it looks like noise. A simple average will tell you nothing. The regression analysis that goes on in these reconstructions tends to follow something like this algorithm: 1) Compare your collected data series to each other to determine a "reliability" index for each data series. 2) Construct a series as a weighted average on this reliability index. 3) Iterate, using your new series to calculate the reliability index. There are substantial issues with the above approach, having to do with sensitivity to particular kinds of signals. For a while, the Climate Audit folks got a lot of mileage over a data set that was put in "upside down" in one of the reconstructions. Rather than claiming "data error," the author defended it based on the idea that the above process would just give it a negative weighting! Regardless, you should see why the above could easily be susceptible to issues. Further, the disagreement between these reconstructions and what our limited historical sources tell us about the MWP, etc., makes them further suspect. This is a problem for the global warming model because it means that we don't know what the historical standard deviation for temperature is. So we can't say whether the last 3 decades warming is "within normal deviations" or "unprecedented."
- donpdonp 14y agoNASA's Climate Change Site has compelling, long term environmental measurements, and scientific analysis. The Key Indicators page is especially eye-opening. http://climate.nasa.gov/key_indicators http://climate.nasa.gov/key_indicators
- gd1 14y agoLies, damned lies and charts eh? The CO2 can be put in a better context here: http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/PageMill_Images/image277.gif http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/PageMill_Images/image277.g... Age of the Earth: 4.5 Billion years. Time we've had weather satellites up: 30 years. Geologic time, it's cool, wrap your head around it. Fun fact, C3 plant life dies at 220 ppmv or lower CO2. Wheat, rice, soybean, cotton, tomato, barley, potatoes - all gone. No ifs and buts about that one, photosynthesis ceases. That's how dangerously close we were teetering to extinction, with the world's carbon entrapped underground. Luckily, along comes man to dig up fossilized carbon and free it back into the carbon cycle where it came from...
- eqreqeq 14y agoThis is very interesting. I wish that somebody with some expertise had replied to your comment so that I could learn more about this. Apparently everybody is stump.
- jshen 14y ago"Sure, there might changes happening, but from history, isn't that what the climate does?" The fact that the climate has historically changed does not lead to the conclusion that humans can't affect a change in the climate. Nor does it lead to the conclusion that everything will be OK if humans are affecting change.
- tlrobinson 14y agoThe parent never implied either of those things. All he was saying was essentially: "The fact that the climate is changing does not lead to the conclusion that humans are causing that change"
- jshen 14y agoMaybe he was saying that, but maybe not. He didn't directly say either, so I don't know why you are certain he was implying what you stated.
- mratzloff 14y agoI'm reminded of 18th-century views about animal species extinction (that human-caused extinction could not occur). By the 19th century, that belief had changed. Today, we accept implicitly that human-caused extinction is a fact of life. The rate of extinction for North American freshwater fish species is 877 times the background extinction rate[1]. Of course, there are still people who oppose preservation efforts... Humans are literally an extinction event. Why is it so hard to accept for some that humans are also responsible for climate change? [1] http://economistsview.typepad.com/economistsview/2012/08/our-not-so-fishy-future.html http://economistsview.typepad.com/economistsview/2012/08/our...
- 7952 14y agoThe evidence concerning climate change is interesting from an intellectual point of view, but a huge distraction in a practical sense. There are numerous reasons for closing a coal fired power station that are more immediately provable than global warming. The polarized debate is no alternative to a mature and nuanced understanding of the environment. You will never get that from one book. "Break Through: From the Death of Environmentalism to the Politics of Possibility"[1] is an excellent discussion on the politics of these questions. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Break-Through-Environmentalism-Politics-Possibility/dp/0618658254/ref=tmm_hrd_title_0 http://www.amazon.com/Break-Through-Environmentalism-Politic...
- jofer 14y agoIf you're looking for more of a narrative, "Thin Ice" by Mark Bowen is an excellent read. While it's not comprehensive, it does a good job of laying out the science. It's a third biography, a third climbing novel, and a third popular science writing, but it's very well done.
- run4yourlives 14y agoThe problem is that nobody really "knows" what is going on. Climate science is still very much a work in progress. This is the sad truth of the matter. Trying to figure out whether or not humans are a direct cause of climate change is like trying to figure out if exposure to a certain household product gives you cancer. People get cancer all the time from various sources, and while certain folk can point directly to said chemical being a carcinogen, even if that agreement exists it starts to open up a whole new debate about whether or not there is enough of a link to matter. From what I can tell, ignoring the single idiots on either side, we've got: 1. A general consensus that the world is warming; 2. A slightly less strong consensus that humans are contributing to this warming; 3. A majority (but not a consensus, IMO) extending that to humans being the most direct and primary cause of warming; 4. A strong consensus that we should reduce our overall carbon emissions (for obvious reasons), regardless; 5. A small but significant scientific group arguing that we are not the primary cause of warming, even though we may be a contributing factor; 6. A large contingent of non-science laymen that feel that because 5 may be a valid opinion, the entire study of climate science is bunk; That's basically the best I've found. There are zealots in every camp above. There are also those that feel that each individual point being right means we should either ignore everything else, be it science or consequence. Given how complex the earth's climate is, and how little we know about things like the sun, earth's climate history, and the long term effects of particular chemical compositions in our atmosphere, I feel we won't progress much past our current stage in enough time to make much a difference overall. IMHO, if we believe that climate change is real, we should be focusing all efforts on dealing with it as best we can.
- moultano 14y agoYour post is unsupported by evidence, and seems to be just lazily taking the middle road in an attempted to appear enlightened. The two sides of the "debate" are not equal. There is not substantial disagreement that the climate is changing and that humans are directly responsible. See the consensus report here for the net effects of different factors on the climate. The net effect from human activity is the largest component. http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/spmsspm-human-and.html http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/spmsspm-...
- pygy_ 14y agoIt may reflect my own biases, but, seeing things from Europe, I have the impression that the issue is only politicized in the US. Human-made global warming is taken as fact here. The only ones denying it are (with a few exceptions) oil producers, guzzlers, and those who protect their interests, none of which are active in local media.
- richardjordan 14y agoBeing from Europe but living in the US this is pretty much how I see it too. It's a "controversy" in the US because of the mess the political system is in, and because there's such a strong religious movement which funds and propagates any attacks on science that bubble up to the surface. If there were a scientific consensus that an asteroid was flying at us and with all likelihood, in a decade or two, would wipe out all life on the planet - the only solution being all governments working together and raising huge amounts of $$ to head off disaster - the same faces would crop up attacking the science, and reminding us that if God wanted us to die he'd have sent a plague of locusts.
- pygy_ 14y agoI thought that the conservative christian base was being manipulated through religion, by the likes of the Koch brothers... Maybe I underestimate the power of obscurantism.
- richardjordan 14y agoSo as far as I can tell, in the time I've been here, there are a bunch of cynical leaders of the religious right. They get their funding and push whatever agenda is asked of them from folks like that. But also you have the desperate need by the institutions themselves to denigrate science in order to stop it clashing with fundamentalist interpretations of their religious texts. For example, more belief in science might lead to people accepting that Evolution is science and Creationism is nonsense. Climate change allows both the cynical moneyed political interests whose wealth relies on resource extraction (which is a hugely politically corrupt industry), and the religiously inspired underminers (made up word alert) of science to have common cause. That's a powerful political force. If you could find a way to rope in the NRA you'd have the trifecta. Maybe run a report saying "Climate Scientists want to take away your guns"?
- josho 14y agoStorms of My Grandchildren by Dr. James Hansen. http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1608195023 http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1608195023 The author is a member of the National Academy of Sciences, a professor in the Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences at Columbia University and director of the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies. The book walks through the science with detailed explanations why the science is sound. It is an eye opening read and framed as what the world will be like for our children. Do give it a read.
- Kototama 14y agoMaybe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_opinion_on_climate_change http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_opinion_on_climate_c... is a good starting point?
- emmelaich 14y agoA friend lectures in the history of climate change -- I'll try and get her reading list and report back here. It's not particularly oriented on recent human caused warming but does include it.
- ahi 14y agoSee "A Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming" Written by a prof at UMich School of Information, it discusses how we know what we know about climate change. http://www.amazon.com/Vast-Machine-Computer-Politics-Infrastructures/product-reviews/0262013924/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1 http://www.amazon.com/Vast-Machine-Computer-Politics-Infrast...
- scaphandre 14y agoPerhaps not exactly what you are looking for, but Prof David Mackay (also of Information Theory, Inference, and Learning Algorithms) has a cogent quantitative analysis of energy generation, given climate concerns. I think it's a good read. You can tell he has awareness of the relevant numbers - and doesn't like bull. Free pdf available. http://www.withouthotair.com/ http://www.withouthotair.com/