47 ms·
Only a conservative bastion like the WSJ would describe a declining fertility rate as a crisis: "The root cause of most of our problems is our declining fertili
by lutusp 14y ago
Only a conservative bastion like the WSJ would describe a declining fertility rate as a crisis: "The root cause of most of our problems is our declining fertility rate."
That's true only if we accept the model where growth must be constant and unending. Doctors call that cancer, but economists call it healthy growth.
How is it that all these intelligent people don't understand that population growth cannot be constant and perpetual? That eventually we run out of land to put all those happy consumers?
- DenisM 14y agoI didn't read it that way. I read it as "the crisis of our current economic structure is rooted in demographic trends". One way to avoid problems is to push the fertility up, as discussed in the article. The other way, not discussed there, is to change the economic system. I wouldn't begrudge the author exploring just one possibility out of two, the one he believes to be more likely. Also, it would be better if you skipped the adhom, and addressed the argument directly. It always leads to a more polite, more constructive conversation, the likes of which we all prefer to see here on Hacker News.
- lutusp 14y ago> I read it as "the crisis of our current economic structure is rooted in demographic trends". I couldn't have realistically exaggerated their over-the-top way of putting the issue, so I simply quoted theirs. > I wouldn't begrudge the author exploring just one possibility out of two, the one he believes to be more likely. In an essay it's always best to address all the options, not just one, even if the author intends to discuss only one of them in depth. Also, regardless of how we address or analyze the demographic issues, the only truly catastrophic outcome would be continued growth. > Also, it would be better if you skipped the adhom ... Not really an ad hominem. To a reader unfamiliar with the WSJ, it's simply context.
- DenisM 14y agoYour comment was the first on this article, and it set the tone for the entire discussion. Do you like what became of it?
- lutusp 14y agoMy comment was both germane and consistent with the tone of the linked article. > Do you like what became of it? Who cares what I like? The conversation will do just fine without checking with me or my tastes.
- joezydeco 14y agoIt's Wall Street. Wall Street is all about growth. Look at how Apple stock got hammered because -gasp- they didn't grow at the rate expected.
- hayksaakian 14y agoLook at Japan, they've been getting crushed over the past few decades by low fertility and a disproportionally older population.
- newbie12 14y agoActually they're getting crushed by lousy spending and monetary policy, and regulations that dampen local competition. The next leg down for Japan will, however, be demographic, as retirees turn the nation's savings rate negative and the bills for the past 20 years come due.
- anigbrowl 14y agoIt's a crisis because the ratio of workers to retirees has been almost flipped on its head. by 2030 two individuals payroll taxes (SSI, medicare) are supposed to support each retiree, down froma opstware ratio of about 16 to 1. That means either benefits have to be slashed, or taxes on the employed have to soar. In practice there's a bit of both and more savings from reducing waste, but there's still a big gap to close. The boomers were a big generation, but they had far fewer children than their parents and lived far longer. This is a pattern that has already appeared in many other countries. You'll see movement on immigration reform this year, because it offers the best way of correcting these imbalances without massive tax hikes or benefit cuts, and and can get us through the hump to a longer-term population equilibrium after 203 or so. See this elegantly-explained summary of the issue: http://www.ssab.gov/documents/immig_issue_brief_final_version_000.pdf http://www.ssab.gov/documents/immig_issue_brief_final_versio...
- lutusp 14y ago> You'll see movement on immigration reform this year, because it offers the best way of correcting these imbalances without massive tax hikes or benefit cuts ... Yes, I agree, but that doesn't address the population-growth issue, it only relocates it. I agree that immigration policy needs to change, but it's only a stopgap measure -- it kicks the can down the road. Someone else will have to deal with catastrophic overpopulation.
- anigbrowl 14y agoBut you don't need endlessly growing population. If the fertility rate stays around 2.1 (IIRC) then eventually you end up with an equilibrium, where gains in lifespan can be offset by gradual increases in the retirement age. You don't need endless growth; if you look at the paper I linked to you'll see that they expect things to settle down to a steady state. World population is expected to stabilize at around 9bn by 2050. The UN's millenium development goals are succeeding extremely well, eg a 50% drop in under-5 childhood mortality (from 12m/yr to 6m/yr) over the last 20 years. That sort of thing is a great constraint on fertility.
- 14y ago
- msellout 14y agoI was more annoyed that he didn't see immigration as the answer. If we can't expect more immigrants from Mexico, we can still welcome millions from India and Africa.