4 ms·
It's scary to think that this guy who was just shocked to discover a very basic concept of object oriented programming (polymorphism) has written his own book o
by greenyoda 14y ago
It's scary to think that this guy who was just shocked to discover a very basic concept of object oriented programming (polymorphism) has written his own book on iOS programming:
http://clayallsopp.com/posts/writing-a-programming-book http://clayallsopp.com/posts/writing-a-programming-book
- AlexeyBrin 14y agoHow many books did you wrote ?
- mylittlepony 14y agoHow is that relevant?
- AlexeyBrin 14y agoJust pointing that his little ad hominem attack has no place on HN.
- mylittlepony 14y agoIt would be an ad hominem if the book was about gardening but it's not, it's about programming.
- adamnemecek 14y agoAh, the good ol' ad hominem.
- icebraining 14y agoThat's not an Ad Hominem.
- adamnemecek 14y agoI assume you are responding to me. Yes, yes it is. From Wiki "Argumentum ad hominem, is an argument made personally against an opponent instead of against their argument." AlexeyBrin is implying that because greenyoda may not have written any programming books, that his argument is less valid. AlexeyBrin's argument is not refuting greenyoda's central point, that it's somewhat strange that the blog post author has written a programming book about Ruby, despite not being aware of what some argue are the language's commonly used features.
- icebraining 14y agoSorry; I was actually responding to AlexeyBrin on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5157519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5157519 Sorry for the confusion ;)
- martinced 14y agoI did write about twelve books and I still consider OP's point to be very valid. The blog entry is great in that it shows how collaborating over the Internet can lead to improvement but it's indeed a bit concerning that someone who didn't know what polymorphism was had been publishing a programming book.
- AlexeyBrin 14y agoClay wrote a book about RubyMotion (a Ruby compiler for iOS), not a book that teaches OOP. His knowledge about polymorphism is not so relevant for this book (I think he "knows" what polymorphism is but he was genuinely amazed by the way you can use it for this particular case).
- rmrfrmrf 14y ago> very valid Validity is a binary state. Don't modify it with an adverb.
- mylittlepony 14y ago"He is the creator of some of the most widely used RubyMotion libraries" Then everyone is surprised when critical bugs come to light in Ruby stuff.
- dhaivatpandya 14y agoI think this comment is a little unwarranted. Polymorphism wasn't the concept he discovered - the idea of generating the classes (metaprogramming) and the "clever" (well, some would say so at least) was interesting to him. I also don't like how your comment tries to make fun of his efforts to learn something new.
- mylittlepony 14y ago> I also don't like how your comment tries to make fun of his efforts to learn something new. The problem is not that he's learning, he's teaching.
- dhaivatpandya 14y agoWhy is that a problem? As I pointed out, he's just showed us a metaprogramming trick he thought was cool. That is no indication that he is an inept programmer or someone that should be allowed to teach something like RubyMotion (if he was writing a book on metaprogramming, that's another thing).
- mylittlepony 14y agoNo problem at all, I was talking about the book. Even if he hasn't lied, when one reads the "author" section, it sounds like he's an expert. In the description of the book it also says it can help you even if you are a "veteran", which might be true (or not), but makes one think he is a veteran too. It's misleading.
- chris_wot 14y agoWhat, teachers should never learn?
- mylittlepony 14y agoThe basics? Yes they should learn that, years before starting to teach.
- 14y ago