19 ms·
That Daily Shower Can Be a Killer
- tomjen3 14y agoSolution: a bathtub. I have some combination bathtub + shower so I sit down and wash myself -- it doesn't take longer and I can fall (since I am already at floor height.
- kyberias 14y agoI can easily think that climbing in and out of a bathtub is way more risky (wrt. falling) than merely stepping under a shower. I believe people don't fall when they stand in the shower. They fall when they step out of it on moist surface. Sorry if I ruined your day. :)
- atdrummond 14y agoThey actually make such tubs that allow one to walk in: http://www.luxuryhousingtrends.com/walk-in-tub-with-massage-jets.jpg http://www.luxuryhousingtrends.com/walk-in-tub-with-massage-...
- redwood 14y agoI visited a friend in Slovenia and discovered this is the normal routine in Central Europe. In fact they have comfortable tubs which have a higher section for sitting on.
- abraininavat 14y agoNot discussed is how the author's hyper-vigilance impacts his life in the form of stress. Stress kills.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoIts possible to be careful and unstressed. I avoid caffeine. I don't even think about it any more; I just don't choose drinks containing caffeine.
- feintruled 14y agoNot so black and white though, caffeine may have health benefits, e.g. http://www.webmd.com/alzheimers/news/20120607/coffee-may-help-turn-tide-on-alzheimers-disease http://www.webmd.com/alzheimers/news/20120607/coffee-may-hel...
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoSure, but I get squirrly and my blood pressure goes up. So all the studies in the world don't mean more to me than my experience.
- abraininavat 14y ago"I don't even think about it any more" means you're not being "hypervigilant". I'm using the author's word-choice here.
- tokenadult 14y agoThe author has already made it to age seventy-five. As he writes in the submitted article, "My hypervigilance doesn’t paralyze me or limit my life: I don’t skip my daily shower, I keep driving, and I keep going back to New Guinea. I enjoy all those dangerous things." I think the author has actually made a very sound point, statistically speaking, that often incremental improvements in dealing with the little things has as much impact on health outcomes as heroic measures to deal with the big risks to health. All around the developed world, mortality from all causes is steadily declining at all ages, http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=longevity-why-we-die-global-life-expectancy http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=longevity-w... and most of that decline in mortality (and consequent increase in life expectancy) has come about from incremental reductions in risk. Changing engineering standards for highway construction reduces risk of injury and of death from car crashes. Simple checklists can reduce the risk of surgical complications. http://www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/en/ http://www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/en/ http://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/dp/0312430000 http://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/d... A girl with my daughter's birth year in the United States has a better than even chance to live to be 100 years old, http://www.prb.org/Journalists/Webcasts/2010/humanlongevity.aspx http://www.prb.org/Journalists/Webcasts/2010/humanlongevity.... http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/1/1/e000128.full http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/1/1/e000128.full just from an accumulation of incremental improvements in health in the developed countries. The little things matter. We don't have to worry about the little things. Indeed, we can celebrate that so many little things are taken care of for us by societal changes.
- mauvehaus 14y agoI think hyper-vigilance is a poor choice of words. It's more a habit of thinking than a constant state of conscious alertness. When you become aware of a hazard, it takes conscious effort to avoid putting yourself in the way of that hazard. To take the author's example of sleeping in the jungle under dead trees, when you first become aware of the hazard, you have to stop and look at your campsite before deciding whether or not to pitch a tent there. Eventually it just becomes part of your background processing when checking a spot, and you would pass up an otherwise nice spot without stopping to think why. If asked, it might take you a moment of looking the spot over before realizing that it's because of the dead tree sitting over it. If you think about it, it's a lot like developing good practices in coding. What at first is something you have to think about quickly becomes second nature. For example: why do you (possibly hypothetically) use curly braces around a single line block following an if statement in a C-like language? Several reasons if you think about it. First, so that you can't forget to add them in when you need to add another line. Second, because it makes it unambiguous which if or else if an else belongs to if you have a big nasty chain. You don't spend a lot of time thinking and stressing about those reasons every day, but having the habit protects you anyway.
- abraininavat 14y ago> I think hyper-vigilance is a poor choice of words Well, it's his choice of words. You seem to be trying to redefine the article to your liking. You're right, rules like the curly braces one you mentioned eventually become second nature, such that you don't think about them. That's a "habit of thinking", as you say. That's clearly not what the author is talking about. The author uses words like: "hypervigilant", "obsess about the wrong things", "verging on paranoia", "constructive paranoia", "I remain alert", "I try to think constantly", "being attentive to hazards". He's talking about an attitude which might very well bring about stress. It beign second nature to add a curly brace after an if statement doesn't.
- EwanG 14y agoFor those equally concerned, there are "shower chairs" that you can get that greatly reduce the risk of falls. Since my SO had her amputation it was the only way she could take a shower. However I've found it to be pretty convenient as well.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoA handy technique for evaluating situations is this: how many mistakes am I away from death/injury? If I drive without a seatbelt, I've put myself 1 accident away in many cases. My Scouts are young, and love to climb things. I tell them, I know you're strong and skilled. But a loose rock or slippery foothold puts you at risk anyway. So wear the harness - now it takes two mistakes to kill you (e.g. loose rock + badly rigged harness). The risk goes down drastically. So put some non-skid floor mat in your shower, or a chair as advised in this thread. The mis-step no longer carries the same risk.
- mauvehaus 14y agoIn the climbing example as presented, you should be at least three mistakes away from injury. The belayer should check the climber's harness and knots before allowing the climber to climb. Naturally the climber should check that the belayer's harness is fastened securely and that the belay device is rigged properly before climbing too. Realistically, there are still several single points of failure in the system: 1) The space between the belayer's ears 2) the rope if it has become damaged since it was flaked and inspected or gets cut while catching a fall. Yes, that happened, though not to me [1]. 3) The protection on the wall, due to improper use. although depending on how high you are, the next piece down might still keep you off the deck. 4) The harness itself, although barring invisible damage this should be caught by the belayer/climber him/herself and the cross check. 5) The protection on the wall due to gear failure. The above are listed in what I would consider descending probability, although 2 and 3 are pretty close, with 3 probably jumping 2 in trad climbing. I would rate the probability of 5 being negligible barring manufacturing defects, the prevention and possibly detection of which is probably outside the expertise of virtually all climbers. Moral of the story: safety is complicated. (edited to add) I'd believe that trying to get people to apply a simple model of "how many mistakes" is better than none, but I wonder to what extent it reduces safety by making people complacent about having done a risk analysis when the system is too complicated to be analyzed that way. [1] http://www.redriverclimbing.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=13270 http://www.redriverclimbing.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=132...
- JoeAltmaier 14y ago
- jessedhillon 14y agoStrangely not mentioned at all, so I'll put it here: Jared Diamond is the author of Guns, Germs and Steel, his most famous work. It addresses the question of how and why European societies were able to advance themselves so much farther ahead of all other civilizations. There is also an excellent four-part series streaming on Netflix.
- roflc0ptic 14y agoGuns, Germs, and Steel was most certainly not about "how and why European societies were able to advance themselves so much farther ahead of all other civilizations". The concept of "advanced", or being "ahead of" is inapplicable. It's a book about sociocultural evolution. Additionally, Diamond is pretty ambivalent about the "winners". Diamond wrote an essay on the subject of agriculture called "The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race". He closes the essay with "As our second midnight approaches, will the plight of famine-stricken peasants gradually spread to engulf us all? Or will we somehow achieve those seductive blessings that we imagine behind agriculture's glittering facade, and that have so far eluded us?" http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html
- jessedhillon 14y agoNo. I'm pretty sure it was about why and how European civilizations were able to conquer technology and the world, and specifically why many of the developments critical to the rise of European supremacy are not found in other societies. Yes, the judgments made in the book tend to be more fact-based and objective, e.g., a gun is more effective than a spear. It is not a screed extolling the virtues of European civilization, nor a litany of the failings of other people. Sorry if that's how you understood my brief. Gotta love HN-contrarianism. Oh have you also heard of Jared Diamond and would now like that knowledge recognized by pedantically contradicting me? EDIT: actually let me update this. It is about sociocultural evolution. However if I had said "he wrote a book about sociocultural evolution," nobody would have understood the primary emphasis of his work. That book is specifically and primarily about identifying the key developments in Europe which allowed that civilization to rise in power. He has spent many years living among primitive societies around the world to explore his hypotheses. As much as possible, concepts like "primitive" and "advanced" are objective qualifiers and not value judgments. When I say it that way, people understand what it's about and want to read the book.
- timruffles 14y agoReminds me a lot of Nassim Taleb's focus on payoff/cost (expected outcomes) vs probability. If the possible costs are high enough, it makes a lot of sense to take precautions. Hardly rocket science - seat-belts, hand-rails, smoking etc.
- taeric 14y agoOddly, I'm not sure why one would not consider skipping the daily shower if you had these concerns. Though, I realize that is a highly personal decision. (Meaning that personal influences matter a lot. I've known folks who would go without a shower for upwards of a month with nobody noticing. Others, if a day was skipped it was obvious.)
- hammock 14y agoNothing against New Guineans, but the notion of attributing not sleeping under a dead tree to their specific culture is funny. It's basic risk management of anyone who camps frequently in the backcountry. In fact many learn the 4 W's of concern when picking a campsite- Wind/Weather, Water, Wildlife, and Widowmakers (i.e. a falling tree branch)
- GiraffeNecktie 14y agoI think you missed his point. He wasn't trying to establish that New Guineans somehow "invented" the idea of not sleeping under a dead tree, merely that the author wasn't personally tuned to the risks of being under trees until he spent time with the people there. That's all.
- hammock 14y agoThe point is not lost, but the author does attribute it to a specific culture: >"I first became aware of the New Guineans’ attitude toward risk on a trip into a forest..." >"I now think of New Guineans’ hypervigilant attitude..." >"Traditional New Guineans have to think clearly about dangers....In contrast, Americans’ thinking about dangers is confused." The truth is it's a common, learned attitude of anyone who spends a lot of time sporting in the outdoors - no matter where you live. The author himself points out the American/European pilot and raft guide, for example.
- jff 14y agoIt's just another example of the "magical natives, so in tune with the natural world" bullshit myth.
- inyourtenement 14y agoI was about to respond to the GP with "Jared Diamond uses New Guineans in many of his examples because he spends an extraordinary amount of time with them. He's not trying to say they are unique." But you're right, he's a native fetishist.
- adamio 14y agoWhere can I get that snake-head shower-head?
- IsaacL 14y agoOne of the reasons falls are so fatal for old people is because elderly people in our society rarely stay active. Look at cultures like the Chinese, where you so elderly women up in the morning doing Taichi, or working out on those weird outdoor gym sets in the rest of the day. Maintaining strength and flexibility during old age helps mitigate damage from falls a lot. Physical deterioration is often a self-fulfilling prophecy,
- peeters 14y agoThe real reason falls are so fatal for the elderly is because the victims become immobalized, causing them to become less active. After a fall, many elderly people are bed-ridden which causes a whole host of greater health problems which are the actual killers. But then good health and daily activity are the best ways of preventing falls, (along with balance training and physiotherapy, especially after a surgery or stroke) so yes it is a cycle as you say. I don't agree with it being primarily a cultural thing though. Daily exercise is an individual choice. There's a guy in my new building who I see all the time, he just walks to the end of the hall and back many times each day. Each lap probably takes him 10 minutes. But he chooses to stay active, even in very old age.
- mfringel 14y agoDaily exercise is an individual choice, but humans are social beings. An implicit societal framework for being physically active helps at the margins... and the margins are pretty large.
- Angostura 14y agoJust to point out that according to: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expectancy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expec... the life expectancy at birth for China in 2011 was 73.47 years (CIA World Factbook (2011 estimates)) compared with 78.37 for the U.S and 80.05 for the UK. So one reason that all those old Chinese people may appear so mobile is that they aren't quite as old as you might expect.
- 14y ago
- nathan_long 14y agoYep. This is why every dollar spent on the TSA would be better spent on preventing car accidents, heart attacks, and falls in the shower. http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparative.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparativ... But I like the OP's more practical point: personal attention to normal activities that are actually risky, based on a realistic view of those risks.
- davidroberts 14y agoEspecially since the TSA actually accomplishes almost nothing in preventing deaths. All a terrorist about to be discovered at the airport security gate would have to do to complete his deadly mission would be to detonate his bomb right then and there. It would cause people to fear airports and security gates and mess up the whole system. Terrorism is all about sowing fear that the government can't protect you. The TSA just shifts some of the risk from the airplane to the airport. You can't security check everything in life. Better to figure out why people want to detonate bombs in the first place and solve that problem. But symbolic solutions are so much easier.
- mikeash 14y agoIronically, the fact that there haven't been any big successful airline-related terrorist attacks in the US for a long time is evidence that the TSA is useless, because of what you point out, despite the tendency for certain groups of clueless people to claim the opposite.
- Amadou 14y agoThere are a couple of more parts to that story that help to make it more persuasive. 1) Zero succesful airline attacks 2) Zero convictions for attempted terrorism of anyone detained by the TSA 3) Zero civilians killed in any form of (islamic extremist) terrorist attack on US soil in the last decade or so (all the way back to 9/12 if you don't count the borderline case of John Malvo). The point being that not only is the TSA not stopping attacks on airplanes, it is also not doing such a good job that it would redirect those attacks to other targets.
- noname123 14y agoIn the derivatives world, there's a saying for trying to bet against highly unlikely events with catastrophic risk for small gains: "picking up nickels in front of a steamroller." The issue is when you pick up enough nickels and watch for the steamrollers vigilantly first few times, you grow complacent and think that you are the master of nickel pickers and steamrollers are slow mofo's. You try to pick more nickels and linger longer in front of incoming steamrollers. See debacle of Long Term Capital Management. Options trader take profit/loss as soon as a humble target is hit. It's as in life, the biggest loss is the complete loss of your physical capital which takes you out permanently of the game. Gamblers focus on the potential profits and get high on how their luck evaded fate in one nick of time, traders focus on preservation of capital.
- phil 14y agoI think LTCM's problem was more that they picked up all the nickels in front of steamrollers. But it looked like there were some more nickels out in the middle of an 8-lane freeway...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sinnerswing 14y agoGutfreund to John Merriweather (LTCM's founder) "One hand, one million dollars, no tears." To which Merriweather replied "if we’re going to play for those kind of numbers, I’d rather play for real money. Ten million dollars. No tears." Gutfreund declined. In fact, he smiled his own brand of forced smile and said, “You’re crazy.” No, thought Meriwether, just very, very good." https://s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/booksikindle/html/Liars_Poker/Liar_s_Poker_split_002.html https://s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/booksikindle/html/Li...
- shin_lao 14y agoAuthor doesn't understand how statistics/probabilities work and it ruins the article. If you roll a dice six times, you have no guarantee to get a six. Each time you roll the dice, you have 1/6th chance of getting a six and this doesn't change no matter how many times you roll. If you roll a dice six times, you have around 66,51% (1-(5/6)^6) chance of getting six at least once. For the same reason, if you have 1/1000th chance of dying under the shower, and you take 5,000 showers, you won't die 5 times... You will have 1-(999/1000)^5000 chance of dying, that 99,32%. That's not 1. So you won't die 5 times.
- sparky_z 14y agoYou're apparently the one who doesn't understand how statistics/probability works. You're correct about his chance of dying once, but there's also a chance of dying twice, a chance of dying 3 times, etc. The expected value of the number of times he would die is 5000(1/1000), or 5. If you replaced "deaths" in your post with "coin flips", this becomes obvious. I'll repeat your post with some different numbers so you can see how absurd your argument is. If you have a 1/2 chance of flipping heads and you flip 10 coins, you won't get 5 heads. You will have 1-(1/2)^10 of flipping heads, that [sic] 99.902%. That's not 1. So you won't get 5 heads. See how that doesn't make sense? Now, obviously a real person can't die more than once, but if you think he was mistaken about that then his supposed error has more to do with biology than statistics. Any reasonable reader would understand that it was just his rhetorical way of describing a large number of independent statistical events. If it helps, think of it as a population of 5000 equally-careless people taking 1 shower each, not a single person taking 5000.
- shin_lao 14y agoSorry, I understand what you're trying to say, but I don't think your example serves your point. I don't think I mixed up expected value and probability of occurrence, if I did please point out where. You don't care too much about expected value because once the event occurs (death), you can't play anymore... If you were playing money, on the other hand, expected value would be much more interesting. I think probability is interesting because if you say "I'll take the shower 2,500 times instead of 5,000" you drop the probability of death to 91.8 % (from 99.9%)... If you say I'll die on average only 2.5 times you say nothing interesting.
- stewbrew 14y agoThat's why they build special showers (that are on floor level) for elderly people. No reason to sleep under a dead tree.
- patrickk 14y agoNot to mention hand rails, non-slip mats to stand on, chairs in the shower and other risk reduction strategies.
- protomyth 14y agoThe CDC has keeps statistics on how people in the USA die http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/lcod.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/lcod.htm Looking at the 2011 prelims "Accidents (unintentional injuries)" comes in at #5 with 122,777 deaths and Intentional self-harm (suicide) is at #10 with 38,285. Assault (homicide) is no longer in the top 15. Also, Assault (homicide) by discharge of firearms is 11,101 with all other Assault (homicide) totaling 4,852. To give some context to the Assault (homicide) numbers, "Accidental poisoning and exposure to noxious substances" totals 33,554 deaths or about 3x the Assault (homicide) firearm number or 2x the total. Looking at the stats and what kills us, we spend a lot of time looking at the stuff that is actually going down versus the stuff that is increasing.
- RyanMcGreal 14y ago> Looking at the stats and what kills us, we spend a lot of time looking at the stuff that is actually going down versus the stuff that is increasing. We need to be careful: maybe things that are going down are going down because of how much time we have spent looking at them.
- protomyth 14y agoPossible in some things. They do make a special not on HIV in the paper that should not be ignored. On guns, we have more than we had before, so the liberalization (old school meaning) of gun laws has not increased any gun related violence. On the other hand, we spend a lot on educating the public on proper eating. I get the feeling our approach isn't correct given the changes, but I would have to look up some study data.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoI don't deny for a moment that Americans (and indeed, people everywhere) worry about the wrong things. We are biased in a number of ways to pay more attention to risks based more on the availability heuristic than any realistic assessment of what is more likely to happen.
- 14y ago
- nerdfiles 14y agoI shower +1 day to having my immediate social circle bear witness to my wardrobe selection per cycle.
- larrys 14y agoThe NYT headline is clearly link bait. If it had simply said "Some thoughts on everyday risks we underestimate" if would go nowhere. That said there is a clear benefit and need to take a shower for many people as opposed to sleeping under a tree or crossing the street in the middle for which there is a work around.
- teach 14y agoA good headline is pretty much 'link bait' by definition. If a feature writer mistakenly wrote a terrible headline like yours, I would expect the newspaper editor to fix it before going to press.
- Evbn 14y agoSome people have a more civilized education.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoWhat is nowadays called "link bait" used to be called "headlines" back in the days of paperboys and rotary presses. It's simply an old journalistic practice.
- stcredzero 14y agoThe takeaway for programmers: every time you write a statement, the odds that you're introducing a bug are quite small, but you do this a lot, so the odds guarantee you will introduce a bug. The guys at NASA who came to TX/RX in Houston used to treat soldering defects as a statistical certainty. You empirically determine your solder failure rate, count the solder joins in the project, then look for your predicted number of failures. When they told me this, a light went off in my head. Why don't all programmers do this? Think of it like this: if someone paid you $100 to take 2 steps balancing on a rail, you're certain to be able to do it. How about going 100 times as far for $10,000 over a 1000 foot drop? As they say: Quantity has a quality all its own.
- dredmorbius 14y ago"They" in this instance was one Joseph Stalin.
- stcredzero 14y agoOh yeah! I've been watching too many WWII documentaries. Linus Torvalds also once said that there's a point after which a quantitative difference becomes a qualitative one. ( Back when the grumps were complaining that the world didn't need his stupid git thing.)
- Evbn 14y agoStalin worked at TX/RX?
- stcredzero 14y agoNo, there's a different dictator there.
- tossacct 14y ago>>>Stalin worked at TX/RX? You have conflated the two uses of the word "they" in the gpp. And you are maddeningly close to having your pedantry card revoked pending discovery that you are in fact a native english speaker: so consider yourself on notice, [as they say](they refers to Steven Coldbear). Let's begin. >>>As they say: Quantity has a quality all its own. The word "they" occurred twice in the gpp. The first time was in reference to "The guys at NASA who came to TX/RX". The second occurrence of the word "they" occurred in the phrase "As they say" which is an idiom, or a turn of phrase [as they say](they refers to "people who use idioms"). Therefore it clearly was not referring to the only other use of the word "they". A native english speaker would know this...but maybe you aren't a native english speaker! Watch your posts friend, maybe spice them up with some "ethnic" flair. Also, do not get into a land war in Asia, [as they say](they refers to the writers of The Princess Bride, as they wish).
- brudgers 14y agoMortality Data on Falls from the CDC shows the increase in risk as Americans age - and that is the direction of our demographics: Cause of death (based on ICD-10, 2004) Falls (W00-W19) All ages 26,009 Under 1 year 10 1-4 years 24 5-14 years 28 15-24 years 211 25-34 years 299 35-44 years 493 45-54 years 1,283 55-64 years 2,011 65-74 years 2,988 75-84 years 7,249 85 years and over 11,412 Not stated 1 http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/deaths_2010_release.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/deaths_2010_release.pdf
- daeken 14y agoThis is a bit of an aside, but I have to say this: even as a young person, take falls very seriously. I was 22 or so when I slipped in the shower. I was falling to the side and was going to hit my head, so I decided to twist so that I'd fall flat on my back, figuring I'd be fine. Well, I was, until a few hours later, when I started having chest pain and my left arm went numb and started getting shooting pains. Thinking it was a heart attack, I went to the ER and was told I was fine, and it was probably just a pinched nerve from the fall. Three years later, the pain hasn't stopped -- the chest pain isn't so bad these days usually, but my left arm is almost continually numb and, well, the body doesn't really get used to the pins-and-needles feeling. If I had taken it more seriously, had a CT scan taken at the time, etc, it may have been caught early. Unfortunately, now that so much time has passed, doctors are at a loss as for what's going on. I'm still finding new doctors and doing my own research into what's going on, but this process has been excruciating. So, please, if you have a fall: go to the doctor, and have them do a real examination immediately. When I went, they focused on my heart and didn't even so much as look at my neck or my shoulder; had I gone after the fall, they may have figured out what it was, and I wouldn't be in pain years later. Hope this cautionary tale helps someone!
- seestheday 14y agoI some similar problems along with significant pain, also caused by falls (and a fairly serious injury that compounded things). I had pain for years, until I stumbled onto a combination of things that completely resolve the issues as long as I stick to them. I'm telling you in case they help. If nothing else it shouldn't hurt anything. In order of importance: 1. Develop & maintain significant muscle mass, specifically in my upper & lower back. I'm not a huge musclehead by any stretch, but I can do 20+ pull-ups (not chin-ups) in a row and deadlift over 350 lbs. This had the biggest impact, and if I stop working out, the pain/symptoms come back. It literally took me years to get here, but is completely worth it to live pain/numb free. Health/aesthetics benefits are nice too. 2. Active Release Therapy - this broke up scar tissue that I had, may not be applicable to you. 3. Fish Oil Supplements - acts as a natural anti-inflammatory 4. Vitamin D/sunshine - Not sure if it's just because the sun & vitamin D makes me feel better overall, but I feel like it makes a small difference. Edited to clean up paragraphs
- Irregardless 14y ago"Cause of injury: Lack of adhesive ducks." - Sheldon I'm not sure what the takeaway from this article is supposed to be. Always be conscious of your safety but not to the point of constant paranoia? Isn't that basically -- dare I say it -- common sense?
- abraininavat 14y agoIt remains to be shown that a hypervigilant attitude has any effect whatsoever on what you're being vigilant about, and in particular shower falls.
- vickytnz 14y agoThis stuff particularly applies to machinery: the horror stories about people getting hair and clothing caught in machinery or looking away for a second when using a bandsaw are always a reminder to be careful no matter how many times you've used the machine before.
- casca 14y agoFor a more detailed description of Jared Diamond's experience with the dead tree in New Guinea: http://www.edge.org/conversation/tales-from-the-world-before-yesterday http://www.edge.org/conversation/tales-from-the-world-before... And if you're in London, consider adding yourself to the waiting list: http://www.thersa.org/events/our-events/the-world-until-yesterday-what-we-can-learn-from-traditional-societies http://www.thersa.org/events/our-events/the-world-until-yest...
- samspot 14y agoWhat else should we be vigilant about besides falling? I felt the article was a little incomplete w/o this information. I've got one: * Lifting heavy things correctly.
- eliben 14y agoBoy, I love Jared Diamond's books. An absolute must read for any hacker.
- ef4 14y agoSpeaking specifically about fall risk in older people: if you want to ensure a high quality of life when you're older, maintain strong muscles through exercise. This may seem like a no brainer, and yet almost nobody actually does it. Balance and strength are highly dependent on exercise. Even fairly old people can maintain very good balance and strength if they don't let their muscles deteriorate through inactivity. Being frail in old age is not inevitable. A sedentary person after age 50 loses something like 5% of muscle mass annually. But that same person can boost their muscle mass 20% in a single year if they just get serious about strength training, and then slow the deterioration to 1 or 2% thereafter. Run the numbers, it makes a dramatic difference in outcomes.
- mattmaroon 14y agoYes! Not to mention it makes you much more resilient even if you do fall.
- darkarmani 14y agoJust as important bone density and minimizing bone loss through resistance training. Stressing the bones forces them to become stronger.
- eridius 14y agoAmusingly, Lonely Island's latest music video, just posted 5 days ago, expresses pretty much this precise sentiment. It's called YOLO and is available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z5Otla5157c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z5Otla5157c.
- caf 14y agoIt's common knowledge in Australia that you don't pitch your tent under a tree, alive or dead. I imagine that's because Eucalyptus trees have a habit of dropping large limbs without warning (it's an adaptation to survive droughts).
- waqf 14y agoThe other reason of course is because of the drop bears.
- dredmorbius 14y agoEucalyptus are rather notoriously bad about that, moreso than many other trees. I've witnessed them make a widow, or widower, in this case.
- symmetricsaurus 14y agoAngband(the roguelike) is an excellent teacher of the point made in the article. The game is quite long and if you die you have to start over from the beginning. You can also be killed in one turn if you are unlucky and not careful. The only way to win is to lower the risk to die at each turn sufficiently that you can play through the 100 000 turns or so that it takes to win. Playing it has really given me perspective on risks in a similar way to the author of the article. In real life you end up doing some things a lot of times and then the risk has to be damn low.
- eagsalazar2 14y agoSeriously showering 365 times/year is, while normal in the US, really pretty bizarre and definitely decadent. Put on some deodorant, shower every other day and this guy could cut down his risk massively. And save colossal amounts of water! Does he sweat regularly? Play sports? If not, in the winter, shower twice per week. Doing otherwise is really falling into one of the weirdest forms of American prissiness. In general I shower when my wife tells me I need to. On average that means every 2-3 days. How strange and wasteful would it be if someone washed their car every single morning regardless of whether it was dirty or had even been moved from the garage that day! (I work from home so the analogy frequently works) I know he's making a broader point about risk but if you want to get over some crazy warped American perceptions to improve your life and the world, obsessive showering is as good a one as getting over delusions of risk of terrorist attacks.
- abrichr 14y agoIn general I shower when my wife tells me I need to. I'm not here to judge you or your lifestyle, but if I were to rely on my significant other to tell me when I needed to shower, I would feel as though I was taking advantage of their good will. I want to take care of myself and be attractive for them, not use them as a smell-o-metre.
- eagsalazar2 14y agouse your own heuristic but showering every day, when all you did was sit in front of the computer and walk your dog in 40 degree weather, is wasteful, pointless, and weird.
- saraid216 14y agoHuh. Funny. Your comment seems wasteful, pointless, and weird, but here we are.
- driverdan 14y agoThis varies significantly from person to person. For me after 30-48 hours so I start getting itchy, my hair and face get obviously oily, and I start to smell. And that's assuming I'm not being very active.
- mattmaroon 14y agoI love it when people who don't understand the concept of expected value circle around it intuitively without quite getting there.
- dhughes 14y agoCBC.ca mentioned a study by Simon Fraser University in BC, Canada. > "We show that the most common causes of falls are incorrect weight shifting and tripping, and the most common activities leading to falls are forward walking, standing quietly and sitting down," http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/story/2012/10/16/falls-elderly-long-term-care.html http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/story/2012/10/16/falls-elderly...
- jokull 14y agoConsider doing exercise that strains your bones and strengthens you in ways that will protect you when falling. Jiu-jitus is excellent at this. You will learn to structure your body, and creating frames with your limbs in many potitions, and you will fall to the ground multiple times. This prepares you.
- ajaymehta 14y agoI initially thought this was going to be about long-term health risks of showering every day. I've heard that long hot showers are bad for the skin and/or hair, is that true? Or might they be bad for the body in other ways? (But good piece nonetheless, Jared Diamond is brilliant.)
- zobzu 14y agoI like how this article is written, with good english. This is refreshing. It might be that old people write better than we do. :)
- doki_pen 14y agoWhen I here a statistic like, your chance of falling and getting an injury in the shower is 1 in 1000, I assume they mean over my lifetime, not each day. There is not way in hell it's 1 in 1000 per day. I don't buy it. That said, I get the point of the article.
- skittles 14y agoI see someone on a motorcycle, and I think "idiot". I've known 7 people in my life who have had motorcycle accidents. One has had 2. He broke his neck in one of them. A couple spilled their bike on uneven pavement. A guy I met in college was like doctor House (dead bone in his leg causing great pain). Another guy was thrown 60 feet when he was rear-ended by a truck. And the last 2 are a father and son. The father has brain damage that destroyed his marriage. Go ahead and have your midlife crisis. I'll be in my car. I might die in a horrific accident someday, but a fender bender won't turn into road-rash and a concussion.
- dr_ 14y agoThe article ignores the fact that there is a variety of equipment available to further minimize the risk of falls in the elderly - and it's the elderly that really matter, because a fall, in their case, could very well turn out to be life threatening. There are shower mats to increase friction. There are bars in the shower to hold on to. There are even tub benches to sit on while showering. I don't really expect the sort of absurd headline grabbing articles like this from the NYTimes. I expect articles that responsibly describe the risks and ways to mitigate them.
- bambax 14y ago> If I’m to achieve my statistical quota of 15 more years of life, that means about 15 times 365, or 5,475, more showers. Or, take fewer showers. You don't need to shower every day in winter, do you?
- lutusp 14y ago> Or, take less showers. Would that be showers taken with reduced water pressure? Or do you perhaps mean fewer showers? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fewer_vs._less http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fewer_vs._less
- bambax 14y agoYes, I meant fewer. Corrected in the post above, thanks. (I'm not a native speaker but this is no excuse, I should have known that! ;-)
- lutusp 14y agoIt's been my experience that non-native speakers do a better job of paying attention to issues of structure and coherence than native speakers. And I can't count the number of times I've met someone whose excellent English composition abilities were completely at odds with their place of birth. Some might say that my going on about "less/fewer" and other similar grammatical arcana is unfair or irrelevant. There is some merit to that argument, but we're comfortable tearing people's computer code apart, and this is a similar activity -- except in an emotional sense. Most people who eagerly welcome computer code corrections bristle at grammatical corrections. So thanks for taking my comment in good humor.
- Qantourisc 14y agoYou mean ... you people in the US don't all have rubber anti-slip mats in the showers ?
- aneth4 14y agoI've always been shocked at how wealthy people fly around in small private planes. At least once a year, I hear of a tragedy involving such a person, often wiping out all or most of their family. While large aircraft are extremely safe, small ones have a significant chance of catastrophic crashes, particularly in inclement weather. While I'll fly in small aircraft, I will never make a habit of it - eventually the number will catch up with you. Same goes for motorcycles. How many motorcyclists have driven for 30 years without a serious accident? None I know.
- chiurox 14y agoShouldn't this problem be hugely mitigated by putting rubber or any non-slippery material on the shower floor?
- known 14y agoInteresting post for senior citizens. Thanks.