8 ms·
Speaking as a graduate of one, top schools teach you credentialing and ladder climbing. If you’re lucky, you might learn how to create a financial model or craf
by _delirium 14y ago
Speaking as a graduate of one, top schools teach you credentialing and ladder climbing. If you’re lucky, you might learn how to create a financial model or craft a solid argument.
If that's what you got out of college, you were definitely doing it wrong. Maybe in a business degree, but most people who do a science, engineering, or math degree learn some, you know, actual science, engineering, and/or math, not merely schmoozing skills.
You could learn that elsewhere, but if you care about scientific progress, my experience is that few people without a science degree ever get around to developing a rigorous scientific education, whether out of disinterest, lack of time, or whatever other reason. Lots of people plan to one day work through some textbooks, but most people don't. You see it in a lot of self-taught programmers, many of whom have a weak grounding in computer science. That might be okay, depending on what you're hiring for, but there are many cases where you want some more solid foundations. For example, if you're doing anything with machine learning, you might want people who understand statistics. Oh, and if you're designing aircraft, you might want someone who's studied aeronautical engineering, or at least some kind of engineering, whether at a university or through equivalent self-study. Even Google, a canonical Disruptive Silicon Valley company, seems to prefer its technical employees to understand computer science, rather than to hire pure programmers.
If someone is a true autodidact, learning on their own the equivalent of what they would've learned in a rigorous 4-year degree, that's fine, and there are some of those, so I have no problem making sure to look out for them, or even actively seek them out. I don't run across them very often at all, however, especially if we're talking about people without any formal mathematical training who are able to do solid mathematical or engineering modeling work. When you do find such a person, they're often amazing, but they're not common. Maybe MOOCs will increase their numbers, but it's a bit early to tell.
That said, I agree in not caring about the actual credential. If someone studied CS at CMU but left without the piece of paper for whatever reason, but learned the kind of stuff people learn in the CMU CS program, I don't really care about the missing document.
- cookiecaper 14y agoI think this is mostly about the resources available to self-taught programmers. I know on many occasions I've sought to strengthen my mathematical and theoretical background without a lot of tangible progress because the resources online don't really approach things comprehensibly or accessibly. I have a friend getting advanced physics degrees and even he says the usual suspects like Wikipedia are uselessly over-technical for him. I've bought a couple of textbooks without much progress in penetration, and Khan Academy and/or Open Courseware is kinda OK for specific issues but they're too tight and "locked up" in video format to really constitute a generally useful guide, and I think they lose some relevance without the greater context. Better Explained is also selectively useful, but most of his analogies don't click with me and the site tends to ramble. What I really need is a decent tutor who is willing to help me specifically with the issues I have but I've sought in vain for one who is willing to free-wheel it with me instead of just copying out of a textbook. I tried one briefly and he came up with a cop-out shortly after our first lesson, because I don't think he liked the unconventional questions I was asking, like "Why and/or how are sine waves relevant to non-geometric data? The only definition I can find of a sine casts it in strictly trigonometric terms, so how is it applicable to non-trigonometric data? Is everything encoded into a representation of a triangle before these calculations are applied?" Heh, that one made him pretty annoyed and he didn't really have a good answer. I would love to increase my background in statistics and comp sci theory (which is basic but imo sufficient, and I seem to have a better grounding than most of the CS grads I've worked with), but I don't really know of a good option to receive that training. If someone wrote tutorials for graduate-level math from the bottom principles up like they write out tutorials on PHP or whatever, I'd be all over it. I really want to increase my formal mathematical literacy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 14y agoMan, I used to tutor math -- I wish I got questions like that from my students! Three answers (in case you haven't found one you like yet): A set of sine and cosine waves whose frequency is a multiple of some value form an orthogonal set of vectors/functions, which means that for any given function or vector whose domain is at most the period of the lowest frequency wave, there's exactly one set of weights whose weighted sum equals the function (with certain caveats if the function isn't discrete). There are other such sets, for example the Hadamard series, so sines and cosines aren't unique in this regard. A complex number can be treated geometrically, as a phase + magnitude (converted to a+bi using sin & cos of course). This representation has the benefit that the magnitude of the value is readily apparent, and makes certain calculations involving multiplication and exponentiation easier. Sine waves arise naturally in differential equations, because they are the only functions which are the negation of their own second derivative. Hence they often turn up in second-order systems with negative feedback (e.g. microphone feedback is more-or-less a sine wave).
- rdouble 14y agoWhen I lived in Cambridge, there were many math graduate students who would have entertained questions like these in a tutoring context. Also, what about Math Overflow?
- dbaupp 14y ago(Such questions would probably be better received on math.stackexchange, but I agree with your general recommendation.)
- hexonexxon 14y agowhere I live all the Mathematics professors hang out every month doing a public round table discussion which is free, completely informal and held at a local cafe. anybody can go in and ask questions about anything there is no discussion agenda you can also show up to public lectures given by visiting math profs and afterwards ask them whatever theoretical background questions you want so long as it's not total spoon feeding campus walls are also covered in tutor posters for hire and many of them graduate level
- rayiner 14y ago> Lots of people plan to one day work through some textbooks, but most people don't. You see it in a lot of self-taught programmers, many of whom have a weak grounding in computer science. That might be okay, depending on what you're hiring for, but there are many cases where you want some more solid foundations. This rings true to me. I have a degree in aerospace engineering, but I'm a self-taught programmer. I've worked as a programmer, never as an aerospace engineer, but to this day I have a much better theoretical grasp of the latter than the former. I was recently trying to understand bidirectional type checking, and I'm just stuck. I understand ML-style type inference based on unification, for which there are a lot of undergraduate-style descriptions online, but I'm clearly missing half a dozen classes between "point A" and "point B" when it comes to anything more advanced, and I don't know enough to know what I need to learn. Some things are just not easy to pick up, even for people skilled at self-education. They require a level of background knowledge that has to be acquired incrementally, and it takes time and discipline to pursue that path systematically.
- strlen 14y agoUnfortunately a lot of undergrad programs don't cover it either. I didn't quite grasp type systems until working getting ahold of Prof Pierce's books: http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~bcpierce/tapl/ http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~bcpierce/tapl/ (It is very amenable to self-study) and then: http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~bcpierce/attapl/ http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~bcpierce/attapl/ (Began working my way through this, but haven't quite) I think knowing abstract algebra is pretty helpful to understand types, but I'd imagine you were likely exposed to a great deal as an aerospace engineer already.
- rayiner 14y agoI have ATTAPL and couldn't get through it. Now I know why. I didn't realize there was a more introductory book in the series. Thanks!
- happy4crazy 14y agoBe sure to check out Pierce's new book, Software Foundations[0], which is available for free online. Learning how to use Coq is quite an amazing experience. [0] http://www.seas.upenn.edu/~cis500/current/index.html http://www.seas.upenn.edu/~cis500/current/index.html
- x3ord 14y agoWell put--this largely sums up my perspective in these sorts of discussions, though I've never been able to put it quite so coherently.
- emmett 14y agoTop schools do not teach the material differentially better. Yale teaches computer science quite well (I'm a graduate!) but not particularly better than any other school. CMU and MIT also have great CS programs, but they're not substantially superior to what you get at Yale. Or at any UC school. What Ivy League schools do teach better than other schools is exactly what Justin says: how to fit in to the elite.
- _delirium 14y agoAh, ok, I don't disagree with that. I had read the anti-credential argument as being against formal education entirely. I do agree that the finer distinctions of university rankings are unimportant, especially at the undergraduate level, and serve mostly as a pedigree. I wouldn't differentiate at all among, say, the top-20 CS schools, and I'd differentiate only weakly between the top-20 and top-100. To the extent I would, it's mostly in that the top-20 tend to have "harder" programs, since they typically accept stronger students, so their curricula can often be designed with higher expectations and covering more material. But there are plenty of solid programs at non-Ivy-League places like Cal Poly Pomona or Purdue.
- justin 14y agoI'm not against formal education entirely. I don't believe that everyone derives benefit equivalent to the cost (both to themselves, and the public cost) of college tuition, but clearly there are a large number of professions that require a formal education, including ones in software development. Like Emmett point out, however, I think any potential incremental benefit of a CS education at a top school is very much overvalued by recruiters.
- tossacct 14y ago>>>I don't believe that everyone derives benefit equivalent to the cost (both to themselves, and the public cost) of college tuition The "everyone" that you are referring to consists of the vast majority of university majors, which happen to be non-vocational. I would say that STEM majors are generally pretty close to vocational, but as you say lots of people can get the degree without actually learning anything useful to any specific employer. Which is what vocational schools are for. The biggest pity is that vocational schools aren't held up as great opportunities - lots of them are intellectually challenging - can you name and describe the function of all of the moving and non moving parts in your car? Also vocational schools are just as social as long as they are encompassed in a normal junior college. Oh and JOBS that pay MONEY. The funniest part of the tragedy is that (on average) someone going to vocational school for a law certificate is going to make less money than someone going to vocational school for an electrician or plumbing or automotive repair certificate. Have we mentioned debt and compound interest?
- doktrin 14y agoI think the cornerstone of this discussion centers around what, where and how non-university educated developers can excel. Everyone seems to have a certain implicit sense that, sure enough, a CS education isn't crucial to work in certain sub-sets of software development. Likewise, it's well understood that such a foundation is necessary in others. > For example, if you're doing anything with machine learning, you might want people who understand statistics. Oh, and if you're designing aircraft, you might want someone who's studied aeronautical engineering Exec, of course, is neither doing cutting edge work in machine learning nor designing aircraft. Neither, if we are honest, are most startups or software companies hiring developers (including those who emphasize & prefer pedigree). The question being posed (continuously) is : To what degree is being self-taught (or, non-university taught) a hindrance in positions that do not explicitly call for it? If it's not a major hindrance, then is limiting the hiring pool in fact irrational? I do not see this being answered adequately and directly. More often than not, we default to pointing out edge cases where a university education in CS/robotics/engineering/bio-engineering/what have you is necessary to perform the basic job functions. This isn't particularly productive. Data should resolve discussions, not corner cases or anecdotes. Is there anything actionable or quantifiable that we can work with, or will this discussion inevitably lead down the path of opinion?
- pyre 14y agoWithout the "University Degree" filter, you end up with a lot more candidates that claim to be self-taught. If you're only looking at a handful of candidates, applying the filter might not make sense, but if you're looking at 1000 candidates, trimming it down by even 25% is probably pretty productive.
- lmg643 14y agooff topic, but i can't help but note the irony of a company that claims to not care about credentials, but under the "meet our execs" section shows a helper who is a BA graduate of claremont mckenna. https://iamexec.com/meet_our_execs https://iamexec.com/meet_our_execs the company may not care about credentials for hiring, but for marketing purposes at least they are creating the illusion that their menial helpers are in fact credentialed. further off topic - it's a little depressing to me to see the "high tech" cradle of silicon valley creating a service to organize menial labor. wow, house cleaning online is sexy? i must be dreaming, is it 1999 again?
- eranki 14y agoI really enjoyed my MIT education, and maybe it made me smarter, but I can't say it made me a much better programmer. We had exactly one class (6.170) that was a practical programming course and the content should have been familiar to anyone with previous programming experience. The foundational "computer science" skills held in such esteem by companies like Google amount almost entirely to an understanding of algorithms and data structures (you will almost never see an interview question based on, say, programming language theory), which was covered by exactly one semester-long course in our curriculum. I think we learned a lot of cool stuff, but not stuff a working programmer really needs to know.
- papercruncher 14y agoI practiced writing code a lot during UROPs (research opportunities available to MIT undergrads). While UROPs are not required, most course VI (cs majors) that I know did at least one during their 4 years there.
- eranki 14y agoI think the alternative being proposed though (no brand name but lots of drive) assumes lots of coding experience outside of the classroom.
- JVIDEL 14y agoI learned a lot of CS on my own before college, and yet my first semester was quite a ride, even other guys who came from schools with a strong computer background had some trouble.
- rjzzleep 14y agothat's not really true. I very well remember a friend of mine who was building depackers for polymorphic pe packers, he went on to study security, and switched to graphics immediately. his reason "at least I can learn photoshop there" I was simply appalled, when I noticed my co students in computer engineering had never seen a computer from the inside or knew that c was a programming language I studied. every single one of them has a ph.d now. I pretty much left. And now that I moved to the US I can tell you each one of those who studied in a german engineering school is worth more than your average Ivy league candidate. See, the thing is, the ones that actually do care drop out, because the system is made to find the highest common denominator. You want to get as many cs engineers out as you can from your university. I often go on to tell people you should get interested high school students. Most of the ones in the University are already damaged. The ones that know coding at highschool age, are the later self taught wizzes I was recently involved in hiring cs graduates for a university program, it was a horrible experience. They did all these capability assessments, grade measurement stuff, etc. In the end I got bored, and started asking them to solve problems(yes, like every half decent interviewer would do). You'd be surprised how few people can break down a problem that would be 3 if statements into something that actually resembles a function. Sure, they can do exactly what you want them to do, but if that was it, you might as well just outsource it to some dude in india.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoMost people don't do science for a living. How is your advice relevant.
- _delirium 14y agoA large number need to at least understand the science. Doing machine learning and data analytics correctly requires mathematical and scientific understanding, for example. Same with, say, chemical engineering, or structural engineering.