9 ms·
Google Giving Will Provide 15,000 Raspberry Pi's to UK Schools
- polshaw 14y agoGreat move from google, no doubt the move will birth some future employees! I take it at this point that the model A is effectively dead?
- Peroni 14y agoI had the pleasure of meeting Eben when he spoke at HN London last year. His passion is blatant and powerful and he's comfortably one of the most down to earth people you could wish to meet and has a brilliant sense of humour. The fact that he turned up wearing a HAL 9000 t-shirt cemented the fact that he's a true geek who is doing something he absolutely loves every single day. If you ever get an opportunity to see him speak then I suggest you jump at the chance. Eben's HN London talk: http://vimeo.com/43039279 http://vimeo.com/43039279
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoIf one were being cynical, one might suggest that this was a way for Google to distract attention from it not paying UK tax (through loopholes): http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/29/google-tax-chairman http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/29/google-tax-...
- bitcartel 14y agoJust two weeks ago: "Google to build £1bn UK headquarters at London's King's Cross" http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/17/google-uk-headquarters-kings-cross http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/17/google-uk-h...
- jmillikin 14y agoA cynical person would note that the UK government isn't upset that the loopholes are being used, since they've made no serious attempts to close them. They're upset that the loopholes are being used by the wrong companies. If Apple or Google or Starbucks spent as much on UK lobbying as other multinationals, I doubt they'd be receiving any negative press.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoHMRC change rules all the time to beat tax avoidance. They're hamstrung somewhat by European regulations that prevent them from penalising companies for hiding their profits in other EU countries. But it's a cat and mouse affair and the HMRC can only be reactive unless someone comes up with a perfect tax code. >They're upset that the loopholes are being used by the wrong companies. // You mean the richest, most successful, most popular, most used by the UK population and most profitable? >I doubt they'd be receiving any negative press. // So in your opinion the UK press is in the pocket of the government who're only highlighting morally questionable tax avoidance as part of a shake down to boost some sort of protection racket? That's what it sounds like you're saying. Personally I think the answer lies in some sort of underpin based on gross revenue levied on all companies over the VAT registration threshold but with the option to apply to have the underpin removed if one can prove in good faith that the underpin is onerous. Amazon could still pretend they're working out of Luxembourg (500 workers) instead of UK (15k workers) but they'd pay on their revenue anyway. That way Amazon can't put UK tax paying firms out of business (simply by undercutting and relying on the extra profit from not paying tax to stay a float) and then off-shore all the taxable profits leaving us with no UK tax paying businesses (but even more consumption). Just think of all the high wage bills for accountants that could be saved.
- jmillikin 14y ago> You mean the richest, most successful, most popular, > most used by the UK population and most profitable? I mean young companies that don't contribute as much to election campaigns as older companies. > So in your opinion the UK press is in the pocket of the > government who're only highlighting morally > questionable tax avoidance as part of a shake down to > boost some sort of protection racket? That's what it > sounds like you're saying. I'm not saying that the UK press is an organ of the government. Rather, individual members of the government are complaining only about companies that do not give them (sufficient?) kickbacks. The press merely reports on these complaints, because true investigative journalism is rapidly dying out. The obvious solution is to close the "pick any EU nation to pay taxes in" loophole so companies are required to allocate taxes based in part on the geographical source of their revenue, but this would affect the companies that paid for those loopholes in the first place, so it will not soon happen. If the government were actually interested in punishing companies that pay taxes to Ireland for profits in the UK, they would have just done it instead of kick up a flurry of press releases.
- alexkus 14y agoI doubt it. Google pay little to no corporation tax on profits in the UK (because they ship all of the profits overseas where Corporation tax isn't so expensive). But Google employ lots of people in the UK so they do contribute a non-insignificant amount to the UK treasury in the way of taxes related to employees (PAYE/CGT on share option grants, NI, etc). They do the former because they can, the do the latter because they must.
- meaty 14y agoWho cares. The government are quite happily coughing up £35bn of tax of our cash to "fight terrorism", yet are quite happily throwing only £32bn of tax at education. I'd rather Google gave all their money directly in schemes like this than had it divvied up into the warmongers chests and pissed into running itself. Source: http://wheredoesmymoneygo.org/bubbletree-map.html#/~/total http://wheredoesmymoneygo.org/bubbletree-map.html#/~/total
- wisty 14y agoI love Sean Lock's comment on 8 out of 10 cats, comparing tax evasion with farting in an elevator. Sure, it's not legal ... (link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAcjntGQuCU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAcjntGQuCU)
- zura 14y agoAh, that explains why UK and not Congo, Uganda, Zimbabwe or any similar country...
- meaty 14y agoWhilst I applaud the effort, I'm cynical. I have three children at two good but different schools and my wife is a teacher. From observation, they will either be locked in the cupboard because the staff won't know what to do with them or are uninterested or are too lazy to adapt them to the curriculum, or they will be stolen or broken within the week. This whilst cynical is probably realistic. The only thing that has ever survived schools is the BBC micro because they weren't cool, were indestructible and you could screw them down.
- kenjackson 14y agoI had recently visited an elementary school (private) where they were actively using 3D printers and Arduino boards. That said, they are certainly not the common case, and I fear that your cynicism is well-placed. What might be better for many such schools is to give the boards as a reward to the "top science" or "top math" student for a given grade level. I suspect it would get a lot more use.
- meaty 14y agoSounds like a good school! Good to hear, even if it is private. My comment only stands for state schools. State school usually have swathes of kit (mine had CNC lathes, mills and other nice stuff) but it is never used other than to show off at parents evenings. As an ex-top math and top science student, we probably already would have one. Back in my day I had the equivalent - a BBC master, a Casio FX-7000G and a well stocked cupboard of desoldered electronic components :)
- alan_cx 14y agoBest chance I think it has in education is in small after school clubs for those interested. But its always going to need a decent teacher to lead it. Well, maybe not a teacher but knowledgeable parent?
- NickPollard 14y agoOne of the organisations mentioned is Code Club[1], who do exactly that - they run small after school clubs, with volunteer programmers running them (and with a teacher to monitor the kids). One of the founders, Linda Sandvik, spoke at HN London a couple of months ago. They're always looking for volunteers, so anyone here with some technical knowledge who would like to help kids learn computer engineering, give them a look! [1] http://www.codeclub.org.uk/ http://www.codeclub.org.uk/
- jiggy2011 14y agoI have a feeling the first question will be "why couldn't they give us an xbox instead?" It will be interesting to see how these are used in schools though. When I was in school the ethos around IT and computers was very much "don't do anything we haven't asked you to do" which seems to be the opposite of how the pi is intended to be used.
- meaty 14y agoIt's still like that. Everything is locked down, locked up and entirely filtered. It's like a computing prison. A couple of years ago, my then 8 year old daughter (!!!!) was actually told off for using the Run dialog (to fire up notepad) in Windows XP because they removed it from the start menu and was accused of hacking! I literally fucking exploded like a WWII bomb at the clueless peon who made that accusation. I'm now a school governor to make sure that these morons don't take over the planet. The kill pretty much every bit of interest there is straight away for most students.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI could certainly tell plenty of stories of our exploits (literally and figuratively) with the RM branded computers that our school used. The focus from what I remember was very much on the "computers as tools for business" angle. Databases were taught by designing forms in MS Access, not a single line of SQL. It might be interesting to see how they use the pies though, hopefully they will assign them to students individually and let them change the Window manager/install quake3/install nmap to their hearts content.
- keithpeter 14y ago"I literally fucking exploded like a WWII bomb at the clueless peon who made that accusation." I'd watch the blood pressure there (I've been teaching for 24 years). As you are now on the management: Is there (safe, filtered) Internet via wifi and BYOD for the older pupils? Cheap android tablets for shiny media but also hackable? Scratch (http://scratch.mit.edu/ http://scratch.mit.edu/) on the PCs? Basically what policy innovation/leadership have you contributed? Not challenging here, I'd really be interested to know. Having documented examples to point at really helps in situations where you have to be diplomatic with idiots.
- antidaily 14y ago15000 super nintendo emulators!
- meaty 14y agoThat actually made me laugh because it's exactly what I'd probably do with it (or install RISCOS and play Zarch). At the same time, in the process, I'd have to get over a learning curve so perhaps that's not a bad thing.
- __alexs 14y agoOne per 3 kids who do the ICT GCSE. Or almost 4 per kid who does A-level Computing. Not too bad I suppose. Hopefully the new Computer Science courses that are coming out will make it a relevant platform to people.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoI think the idea is to encourage more kids to take up computing (as opposed to ICT). To that end giving them to kids who're already doing A-level computing seems misguided?
- hilti 14y agoIt's a good move Google. Just have a look at the kids happy faces. It's a gift they didn't expect. Let's pause for a moment talking about tax loopholes.
- berlinbrown 14y agoThis is why it is so hard to buy a raspberry pi. Google has bought them all up.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoUnfortunately this seems like a drop in the ocean to me. In January 2010 there were 24,605 schools in England alone [1]. Add more for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Then subtract the fairly small number of private schools. My guess is that that about 1 in 3 of UK schools will see even one Pi. And then, since the Pis are being given to pupils not the school, they have to identify the lucky pupil who gets to take it home. I wonder how that will work? I'm not trying to be cynical, but is this actually meant to achieve anything that is related to education? [1] http://www.education.gov.uk/popularquestions/schools/buildings/a005553/how-many-schools-are-there-in-england http://www.education.gov.uk/popularquestions/schools/buildin...
- NickPollard 14y agoI don't know the full plan, but it makes perfect sense to start with a more reasonable number as an experiment; if it works, it'll be much easier to raise funding for the rest of the country. Even Google can't be expected to donate millions of $ (or £) straight up for something in it's infancy. Just because it does not single-handedly fix computing education does not mean it is worthless - to make such an inference is a fallacy (I forget which one; there's a particular name. Essentially the-perfect-is-the-enemy-of-the-good). Helping 15000 people is better than helping 0. At the end of the day, even the ocean is still made of nothing but drops.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoPerfect Solution Fallacy [1]? I agree that helping 15000 people is better than helping none. My cynicism relates to how the Pis are to be distributed and what can be learned about whether this works in any educationally meaningful sense. If this is an experiment and the [geekiest|nicest|poorest] kid in a school gets a Pi to take home, how do you evaluate the educational outcome? This announcement also exists within a political context (corporate tax avoidance), and occurred on the same day that Eric Schmidt made public comments about Google not being opposed to a more restrictive corporate tax regime in the UK. If it is a PR move then I don't have much confidence that there will be any follow-through aimed at achieving genuine educational improvements. To do this requires infrastructure and ongoing commitment. For the record, I have three Pis and I think they are wonderful. My children are going to be using them at home soon and if they had access to them in school too then I would be very pleased. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy#Perfect_solution_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy#Perfect_solutio... [2] http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/29/google-tax-chairman http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/29/google-tax-...