4 ms·
"“Science literacy” tests quiz the initiated on their command of abstract dogmas acquired through no exercise of one’s ability to generate knowledge." This is
by jimbokun 14y ago
"“Science literacy” tests quiz the initiated on their command of abstract dogmas acquired through no exercise of one’s ability to generate knowledge."
This is something that often bothers me about the r/atheism crowd.
A young person encountering an idea like evolution for the first time should be extremely skeptical and require much convincing, because it is not an intuitive idea at all. Believing in it just because the teacher says you will get a bad grade on the test if you don't does nothing to inculcate scientific thinking in young people.
Now, students unwilling to engage with physical evidence obviously have a different problem. But with the level of discourse I see coming out of many proponents of atheism on the Internet, I often feel many of them are proud of their "command of abstract dogmas" and are not particularly people demonstrating the "ability to generate knowledge."
- Centigonal 14y agoPersonally, I thought evolution through natural selection was pretty intuitive and obvious, given the previous instruction on how DNA and chromosomes worked. If everything changed a little bit, and only the good changes stayed, then they'd all stack up and constitute a big change! DNA and chromosomes were pretty unintuitive, but we have pictures of those, so that helped. Also, I think Occam's razor applies even if you're a young person who hasn't heard of it yet: with no previous knowledge on the subject, I am wont to accept the simplest explanation that doesn't contradict reality without much skepticism.
- username3 14y agoPresuming everything will follow a linear path is simple.
- rbanffy 14y ago> A young person encountering an idea like evolution for the first time should be extremely skeptical Not really. Evolution follows directly from hereditarity and natural selection. We turned wolves into shih-tzus through artificial selection. From that point, it's natural to imagine what natural selection does to the population. I often find useful to use a disadvantageous trait as an example. If all your family is, say, allergic to peanuts and all you have to feed your tribe is peanuts, your family will probably leave less descendants than those who can eat. With a couple generations, this trait will be eradicated.