7 ms·
Twitter’s Speech Problem: Hashtags and Hate
- shurcooL 14y agoThis seems like a significant event.
- adventured 14y agoIt's certainly not trivial, but it was very predictable. France has had strong censorship laws for years when it comes to what is deemed to be 'hate speech.' For example, what they've done to Brigitte Bardot for voicing her opinions publicly.
- masklinn 14y ago> what they've done to Brigitte Bardot for voicing her opinions publicly. Made her pay fines under "incitement to racial hatred"?
- addlepate 14y agoThe author should see what people in America tweet about President Obama.
- Svip 14y agoI am slightly disappointed. I was hoping the article would be about what to call 'hashtag' in other languages. What do the Swedes call it? What about the Polish? Then it just turns out to be another relevant article about free speech.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoI will say when I saw the headline I thought was going to be about something along those lines.
- hakaaaaak 14y agoI am not for hate, but once you go down the road of censorship and get called out for specific types of censoring you are doing, troubled times are ahead; more groups will jump on the bandwagon and cry foul on more and more tweets.
- rahoulb 14y agoThe corollary being that I have just shut down one of my websites because I'm sick of the racist and other abuse that myself and my brother were receiving (the justification being "you take offence, not give it"). There's only so many times you can use the block button.
- hakaaaaak 14y agoI'm sorry. Racism should not be ignored. But I'm not sure how censorship initiated by the provider solves it. It is truly a tragedy that you had to shut your site down, and I think those that caused you to have to do that should be punished. However, when a provider starts censoring specific types of speech, there is much left ahead that they will be asked to censor, which is all I was trying to say. I hope that you and your brother find a safe place to share your information without being harassed.
- rahoulb 14y agoFor the most part, I agree. But "free speech" has real, human, costs; just as censorship does.
- dantheman 14y agoThe obvious solution is for nations that want censorship is for them to censor through filtering at their ISP level. By offloading the cost to private organizations it allows the cost to be hidden, and when people have to pay to censor their neighbor maybe they won't do so. Though, on the other hand having this brought up in the news whenever they want to censor a new company keeps the arguments about censorship current and lets people see the backwardness of countries not embracing free speech. The argument against offensive or incorrect speech is not less speech, but more speech. Win in the argument with words not violence.
- tlrobinson 14y agoI agree, but in practice they'd have to block entire sites due to HTTPS.
- tkahn6 14y agoSounds like France is pretty racist and hateful in general. Can you imagine #AGoodJew or #AGoodNegro trending in the US? That's absurd. I don't see how censoring the tweets will fix that or change anything. So much for fraternité.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoAre you serious? I'm flabbergasted that you think this sort of racism unlikely in the U.S. to the point that it is absurd ... When you say US do you mean "United States of America." Racism is so common in the US that I'm surprised that anyone would not know.
- tkahn6 14y agoDo you have any examples of racist hashtags trending on Twitter in the US?
- MrRage 14y agoThis is not an example of racist hashtags, but I remember hearing about a lot of racist tweets when Obama's speech about the Newtown massacre interrupted Sunday Night Football. Edit: grammar
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoWell, if you want to get to politics; it is virtually impossible to deny the amount of racist signaling the Republican party uses in their messaging, debates, legislation to disenfranchise voters, and so forth. And this is not support one party or the other; it's just reality.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoYou said: > France is pretty racist and hateful in general ... That's a separate issue from hashtags. I think that is totally irrelevant. Let's say, just hypothetically, French culture is such that the racism there is expressed through hashtags twitter. Now, let's say in the US, the culture is such that racists prefer to make disgusting racist comments on YouTube AND perform lynchings and enact legislation prevent people of the same race from drinking at the same water coolers. Does that make the French more racist or hateful? I don't really see the point. Also, let's, for argument's sake, keep the racism discussion to Twitter. Does it really matter if the racism is in tweets or hashtags in the picture? If you REALLY want to see examples of racism in the United States, I can produce them. But do you REALLY think I am just "hand waving" when I dispute that it's absurd to think there is no at least the same amount of racism in the US?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoWell, it's just ridiculous. YouTube can be a cesspool of racism but if Twitter has any comments related to one particular group, it faces legal action. I don't want to preach to the choir about free speech; however, what do people really expect from censorship? Let's say some racist group was spewing hatred on Twitter. Now, let's say someone was, rightfully, offended and then went and tattle tailed to Twitter or the legal authorities. What is their benefit from that? Those people still think and believe exactly the same things. You could say at the very least it reduces the spread of certain and so forth, but I don't think it does; just because they can't say it on Twitter doesn't mean it is not said hundreds or thousands of times a day. I don't know why anyone would want the government to be our nanny in this case. If anything, taking action like this just eggs them on.
- monochromatic 14y agoMore and more, people think that nannying is the essential function of government.