56 ms·
Feedback and data related to your actual goals is key to achieving anything, and of course education and health should be targeted, but a bigger underlying prob
by ilaksh 14y ago
Feedback and data related to your actual goals is key to achieving anything, and of course education and health should be targeted, but a bigger underlying problem is the structural inequality causing a constant lack of resources for many countries and communities.
The fact that Mr. Gates ignores this leads me to believe that he thinks that the grossly unequal distribution of resources is the result of some process that has a sound basis. Our current 'economic' models, since they do not take into account equality, health, education, or any other important scientific data, are fundamentally unsound, and that is why we have the problems of gross inequality and inadequate distribution of resources.
We should frame this as less exploitation and more fairness rather than more charity.
- specialist 14y agoI agree with what you say. What bothers me about the Gates Foundation is their education agenda. Their priorities reflect a naive reductionist worldview akin to Rudyard Kiplings' Just So Stories. MEASUREMENT I'm confounded by the emphasis on Taylorism (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management) and privatization, and by extension the emphasis on teacher performance. Make a list of all things wrong with public education in the USA (inequity, parental involvement, malnutrition, etc). Teacher performance isn't even in the top ten. A friend works on some sort of in school room surveillance system at the Gates Foundation. It records the teacher. Which is then reviewed and the teacher graded. By what criteria, I can't imagine. Then the teacher's performance is graded and coaching in administered. For improvement. I asked if any teachers were advising the project. No. I asked who reviews the tapes. Non teachers. Yea, that'll help. Even more standardized testing is another aspect of Taylorism. As every QA/Test person knows, you cannot test your way to quality. The only measure of teacher performance is student achievement. But with so many factors beyond the control any teacher or group of teachers, it's patently unfair to judge teachers. And yet ask any faculty, group of students, or parents, and they'll tell you who the great teachers are. PRIVATIZATION The outsourcing of education is just a way to divert money meant for the classroom towards cronies. Standardized testing, textbooks, misc contracts are some examples. The rationalization for corporate charter schools is that somehow the free market will make schools more competitive. Alas, free market means monopoly, not more parental choice. Further, how is a private entity more accountable than government? I can attend board meetings, vote on levies, submit public records requests. But corporations can easily hide their activities, that's what makes them private entities. THE FIX I believe what's needed is more transparency, more accountability, more democracy. Every single profession struggles with their bad apples. What's needed is a way to hold individuals accountable and some means of either correcting the problem or firing them. This applies to cops, doctors, accountants, teachers, everyone. It's always an open secret who the bad teachers are. But just try to fire one. A second friend was a principle for a few years. Of the bad apples, one of his teachers was assaulting his students. For years. My friend wasted three years trying to fire this person. Opposed by the district, the union, the other teachers, etc. Couldn't get it done. Violent teacher was a few years away from retirement, hey buddy, don't rock the boat. Another friend works in the local school district. He recently related that people within the district admin were quite pleased they only "had to fire" 5 teachers out of 2,000+ in the last year. That's astonishing. I know there's more than 5 bad apples in the district. The documentary The Rubber Room shows what happens to bad teachers in NYC that can't be fired. (Spoiler: They all sit in a room every work day, doing nothing.) I have it on good authority that happens in every district. Probably in every profession. One example from my experience: I wasn't allowed to fire 4 developers on my team. Pushed onto my team by my VP, who was building an empire. Completely toxic individuals (eg one Lebanese and one Isreali who would go at each other). No other manager would deal with them. Complete drain on my team's morale and productivity. I had numbers, facts, personal reviews in my arsenal. I couldn't fire them. I can't imagine how much harder it is in a public context. But in truth, I don't know a specific fix is for culling bad apples. I believe this governance issue is the central management challenge in our society. Meanwhile, I advocate for gathering more data (transparency) so that we can at least know what's going on. (Thanks for reading this far.)
- jbooth 14y agoGreat post. I feel like giving more power to school principals and trusting them to make non-standardized-test-based judgment calls is a solution but unions are terrified of it for whatever reason. On the one hand, the teacher's unions are the only people who stand up for teachers, a job that would otherwise be whittled away in pay and benefits until only an idiot would take the job. On the other hand, union leadership's primary concern seems to be protecting bad teachers and retirement benefits.
- specialist 14y agoMany friends and relatives of mine are teachers. My mother fought both the district and the union. Her specialty was learning disabled kids. Non standard everything. In a world that demands standardization. I'm very pro labor, pro teacher, but have many grievances with the teachers unions. Like every other self-preserving group (cops, gangs), they can't show weakness. I get it. I have many union friends. They're assaulted from every side. All sorts of contradictory demands, without any concessions or compromises offered. I believe in my heart the only way for teaching to be reformed is for the teacher unions to get out in front of the reform issue, instead of digging in. Like the french cliche, Do or be done. Unfortunately, there are few professions more susceptible to fads than education. "Reform" for most teachers is "Been there, done that, it sucked. Just let me get back to teaching." Meaning there'd be near zero consensus on a reform platform.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI don't necessarily disagree with much you wrote, but this piece about corporate charter schools, Alas, free market means monopoly, not more parental choice. seems like it came out of nowhere. Since charter schools entered my area, my kids have gone from two choices, the local high school and a gifted program for engineering students at a local college, to many choices, includes a performing arts school, a science and engineering school for the "non-gifted" and many others. As a parent, I have concerns about how charter schools impact the local school budgets, but monopoly is the exact opposite of the word I'd use. So I'm curious about what logic brought you to that statement. Your comment was well thought out, so I don't think you are just pulling statements out of nowhere.
- jbooth 14y agoI'm inclined to believe that targeting education and health is actually the best way to fix inequality problems. I mean, it's not like he's sinking the money into SAT prep classes for lawrence academy students, he's attacking malaria. Handouts don't fix underlying problems. Education and better health might.
- jacoblyles 14y agoFor most of human history, equality and poverty were much greater. People were equally miserable. It is only in modern times that we discovered the productive capability to escape the Malthusian trap and improve the human condition. Because this happened unevenly, "inequality" rose. But this was not a bad thing, it was a necessary step in progress. Today, much of the developing world is catching up to the rich world. This is reducing inequality. Inequality is neither good nor bad in itself. Focusing on this one variable creates a far too simple model to understand the world.