8 ms·
How Bitcoin dies
- happywolf 14y agoAnybody please provide a summary? After a long day of work I just can't finish this long post. Yes I know the main conclusion is bitcoin is gonna die. Please fill me in. Thx
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- elux 14y agoSummary: 1: A DOJ indictment is unsealed which names everyone [involved in] BTC/USD exchange, as a criminal defendant. 2: The BTC/USD price falls to 0 and remains there. BTC are permanently worthless.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoMore specifically, the charges behind (1) are predicted to be on money-laundering.
- zby 14y agoThe crux seems to be: "the defendants knew that BTC were used for organized criminal activity. Therefore, they knew they were transferring money for criminals." He also claims that: 'Government control (excuse me, "public oversight") of all major monetary transactions is one of the basic attributes of sovereignty in the modern world.' - this also sounds dubious - the money laundering laws are not that old and I don't believe they became 'basic' in that short time span - also a government controlling all transactions is a very totalitarian design.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- walls 14y agoI think you're looking for this -> http://reddit.com/ http://reddit.com/
- mikemarotti 14y agoHow HackerNews Dies.
- Claudus 14y agoI've thought about "investing" in Bitcoins, but when thinking about the risks I always consider what would happen if it ever became really successful. It would take power away from governments of the world, and I think they would fight that in every way they could.
- jobigoud 14y ago"A DOJ indictment is unsealed which names everyone on Planet Three…" Since when the US government has jurisdiction in other countries ? "The evidence: the defendants knew that BTC were used for organized criminal activity." What ? Aren't dollars used for criminal activities too ? Shouldn't we close all banks then ?
- gst 14y agoI just wanted to post a similar comment. Yes - the US might outlaw Bitcoin in its own jurisdiction. But there's a considerable amount of trade going on in other jurisdictions (see http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/volumepie/ http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/volumepie/). If Bitcoin is outlawed in the US there will be a price drop, but the remainder of the world will continue trading the same way as before. And even in the US the market won't be fully killed. Already nowadays people violate lots of laws to be able to gamble in offshore casinos. In the future the same people possibly will find an (illegal) way to sell and buy Bitcoins, and use Bitcoin casinos instead (http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonmatonis/2013/01/22/bitcoin-casinos-release-2012-earnings/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonmatonis/2013/01/22/bitcoin-ca...). I don't want to judge if Bitcoin and everything related is a good thing or not. But I think the chances of killing it are about the same as the chances of killing P2P software.
- mylittlepony 14y agoHe's not saying what we should do. He's saying what he thinks will happen. And to me it doesn't sound crazy at all, it sounds like the kinds of things that have been happening in the last years.
- nextstep 14y agotl;dr someone who is clearly not a lawyer makes bold and unsubstantiated claims about bitcoin and the DOJ, loosely tying the issue into other pop-law flavor-of-the-month topics such as broad computer hacking laws.
- sixbrx 14y agoWhich is unfortunately similar to the thought processes of some judges and juries.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- smokeyj 14y agoDo bitcoin users care if it's legal? Sure, some would. I doubt the underground economy would.
- wmf 14y agoIf the exchange rate goes to zero or undefined then you need infinite Bitcoins to buy a bag of weed. People who are doing trade in BTC are relying on the exchanges to set an exchange rate.
- smokeyj 14y ago> If the exchange rate goes to zero Users would switch to an exchange in a different jurisdiction before the price ever hit zero.
- wmf 14y agoThe theory is that the top N exchanges would be taken out in a simultaneous raid (and the US can reach many jurisdictions, just ask Kim Dotcom) and the remaining tiny exchanges would either voluntarily shut down to avoid prosecution or would collapse under the volume. If the raid was on a Friday people would be unable to transfer money into exchanges until Monday, giving time for the price to drop.
- MacsHeadroom 14y agoThere are 30+ exchanges in two dozen countries that would benefit indirectly from other exchanges being taken down. The notion that these exchanges would shut down voluntarily just when things are looking up for them is ridiculous.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 14y agoThis article assumes that Bitcoins will primarily be a passive asset, but converted back into USD (or other regular currency) for usage. If Bitcoin becomes popular, that won't be the case - Bitcoins will be bartered directly for products and services. So I think the article rather describes step 2 and 3, with step 1 being "Bitcoin fails to become popular".
- kaonashi 14y agoYou can't pay income taxes with bitcoins. If you make income in bitcoins, if you are an American at least, you will need to pay taxes on that income. In this way, bitcoins cannot replace the dollar for American citizens. The most it can ever do is be a stable exchange currency.
- yuvadam 14y agoYou don't have to pay income taxes on bitcoin.
- cube13 14y agoNo, you just need to pay income tax on the USD you get from converting the bitcoins.
- 0x0 14y agoI think you're wrong. What if you got paid in EUR? Could you delay income tax by not converting EUR->USD?
- lotharbot 14y agohttp://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/Foreign-Currency-and-Currency-Exchange-Rates http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Em... > "you must immediately translate into dollars all items of income, expense, etc. (including taxes), that you receive, pay, or accrue in a foreign currency and that will affect computation of your income tax. Use the exchange rate prevailing when you receive, pay, or accrue the item." This is fairly straightforward -- if you get paid in EUR, you have to use the exchange rate from when you get paid and declare your income in equivalent USD. Given that bitcoin calls itself a currency, I would expect the IRS to treat it the same way.
- dreen 14y agoHow exactly are they going to do that? I want to know how are they going to obtain a list of names from websites that do not operate from US or EU, or from those who do not require you to hold a balance account with them (which is what I would recommend to anyone wanting to buy bitcoins anyway). You fail to explain that. Plus, those who think Bitcoin is just used to buy drugs on Silkroad has probably only a very passive interest in the currency anyway. It is used for much more. Many people, like myself for instance, use it for cheap international transfers. Just like Bittorrent which is used for more than piracy, but despite a massive campaign lasting what 10 years now? which is funded by basically most of the richest entities on the planet, has failed to even decline in use.
- wmf 14y agoThe Man doesn't need any list of names (whatever that is). He seizes the exchanges' domain names and their "fiat" bank accounts and the damage is done. Once the exchange rate hits zero there's really no need to bring anyone to trial. (I have no idea whether any government will go after Bitcoin, but they certainly could if they want to.) ...cheap international transfers... Aka illegal money laundering.
- mistercow 14y ago>The evidence: the defendants knew that BTC were used for organized criminal activity. Therefore, they knew they were transferring money for criminals. That would apply to any currency exchange. Considering the amount of money we're talking about here, I think the defendants could afford a lawyer to explain that to a judge.
- diego_moita 14y ago> the defendants knew that BTC were used for organized criminal activity [Irony]And since everybody knows that criminals never use dollars, guns, cars, phones and computers then it is ok to use them.[/Irony] > The BTC/USD price falls to 0 and remains there Its price already fell down close to it on Dec/2011. And it rebound back because people need it. This article is a truckload of bullshit. Yes, most governments in the planet will try to control BitCoin. And most will fail simply because BitCoin is useful, decentralized and is already working.
- jere 14y agoA while back I would probably think the whole premise that government would go after people who buy/sell a product sometimes associated with criminal activity is flawed. Articles such as the following have made me think otherwise: http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2011/12/29/mass_budget_motel_fights_forfeiture_by_feds/ http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2011...
- dmix 14y agoThe pressure will come soon no doubt. "Bitcoin-based casino: More than $500,000 profit in six months" http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5100697 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5100697
- nwh 14y agoThat's the issue really. SatoshiDICE seems to make up the vast majority of transactions on the bitcoin network, thousands every hour. There's probably a lot of eyes on the bitcoin network because of that one service.
- fatbird 14y agoThis is by Mencius Moldbug, a coder who made off with enough options money just prior to the dot-com crash to basically be retired in the Bay Area, reading and writing. He's been bringing the wordy essays for almost a decade now on a wide variety of topics, but I'll save you some time: He's crazy. He's the very definition of Umberto Eco's lunatic, who says things with a certain superficial plausibility, but you know something is wrong with it, but it takes so much work to dig through the mess and find it out that you'll find you feel it was a waste of time to do so. His prolixity is a direct attempt to enhance this quality of this prose. He's got some weird definition of an ideal state based on corporate governance, he thinks black people are a social class defined by welfare queens and petty criminals, he thinks he eviscerated Dawkins by somehow agreeing with him. The length of his work is actually a subtle trap: If you read enough to understand what he's going on about, you're subtly invested in not rejecting it because then you'll have wasted all that time understanding him.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- elux 14y agoSee for yourself: "To me, and I hope to other UR readers, the logical leap from step 1 (BTC exchangers are indicted) to step 2 (BTC price goes to 0) is obvious. But here at UR, we are operating under our own special theory of money, which I have modestly dubbed MoMT (Moldbug Monetary Theory). If you know and believe MoMT, the leap is obvious. In the conventional wisdom, it's not obvious at all." "Imagine that the BTC/USD market is perfectly liquid with no exchange overhead. Imagine also that there are two types of BTC users: Jews, who speculate (holding BTC long-term with the expectation that it will appreciate against USD); and Aryans, who only trade (and sweep all BTC balances into USD at the end of every day). These are simplifications, of course - but edifying ones." "If I have one lesson to impart (...) it is this: [The US Government] is what it is. It is not what you want it to be. It is not what you hope it will become. It is certainly not what it claims to be. No - it is what it is. Respect that reality, and you will neither run afoul of Leviathan, nor live "free" as his spiritual servant. In short: think for yourself and obey the strong."
- LatvjuAvs 14y agoWell, there is no easy way for me to buy heavy drugs using any other currency and online.
- ColinDabritz 14y agoI thought this was going to be a cryptography article. I believe the concern has been raised before and goes something like this: 1. The Bitcoin cryptosystem is shown to be weak in some way, and might be breakable. There is no migration strategy to a new, stronger system, so people are stuck using it. 2. The weakness turns into a full exploit, and anyone with a desktop computer can forge Bitcoin transactions all they like. Bitcoins lose their trust and no one will exchange them for other currencies, goods, or services. Has any progress been made on this issue?
- kbaker 14y agoWhat issue? Please cite your sources... The best part of Bitcoin is that when a problem is found, people can upgrade the software and move past it. Even if there was a weakness in certain cipher, the way Bitcoin is constructed it would take multiple serious vulnerabilities in ECDSA, RIPEMD160 and SHA256 _at the same time_ to have any effect on the security for the end user. Bitcoin itself has been around for 4 years with some serious attackers already on the core protocol, and it is still pretty much unchanged. It is unfortunately much more rewarding and much easier (sadly, but that is improving) attacking services that use Bitcoin.
- ColinDabritz 14y agohttp://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/88/is-bitcoin-future-proof http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/88/is-bitcoin-fut... I saw the questions raised on discussion threads so I can't recall the original context. The triple protocol I wasn't aware of, and is what provides the transition buffer if one of the protocols is broken. Neat.
- Vinnix 14y agoDOJ/USGov't could bring the system to a halt, but I see that it hasn't found a solid use case to do so. Ideally, BTC could defend themselves and saying that it is a virtual product that the exchange is just coincidence, but holds no merit in the 'real world' tl;dr le'sigh
- DennisP 14y agoMeanwhile, a Bitcoin currency exchange has been officially approved by the French government. https://wealthcycles.com/blog/2013/01/11/digital-currency-bitcoin-accepted-as-payment-service-provider-by-french-government https://wealthcycles.com/blog/2013/01/11/digital-currency-bi...
- MacsHeadroom 14y agoThere are dozens of exchanges operating fully within the law of their jurisdictions all over the world. A U.S. exchange take down would only be good for the smaller foreign exchanges and their extended network of established Bitcoin businesses and new Bitcoin start-ups. Decentralized peer-to-peer networks are like hydra. Cut off one head and two more grow in its place. As far as government agencies can intervene, it's only a matter of time before global Bitcoin adoption reaches escape velocity--if it hasn't already.
- egypturnash 14y ago> The connotations of "speculators" are so negative that I always want to say, "speculators and Jews." > If your bond portfolio returned 6% last year, but gold went up 9%, you have speculated incorrectly; if you could go back in time and speculate again, you would speculate instead in gold. (It's hard out there for a Jew.) Because casual ethnic slurs always add weight to an argument.
- quasque 14y ago"Imagine also that there are two types of BTC users: Jews [...] and Aryans" What is this Nazi-era shit doing here. It's hard to take the article at all seriously when the author frames it in terms like this.
- DiabloD3 14y agoI have flagged this post. This is a flamebaity post that does not impart relevant content to the HN community.
- nanoscopic 14y agoAs long as you only generate bitcoins, and then use those online, I think it would be hard to say that is money laundering of any sort. Many many many people do that, including myself, so bitcoins will never die.
- conroe64 14y agoThe US government doesn't usually directly attack something without putting up a straw man to blame first. Examples would be WMD's to masquerade the purpose of the invasion of Iraq, the drug war, terrorists, etc. I don't see any big media push to demonize something so a war against bitcoin would then become politically palatable. Not that this won't happen in the future, but for now, it seems just too quiet for them to spring a trap on BTC holders.