3 ms·
> Instead of making those hard changes like using public transit Actually diesel buses make more soot than cars. For this problem, public transit is not the so
by ars 14y ago
> Instead of making those hard changes like using public transit
Actually diesel buses make more soot than cars. For this problem, public transit is not the solution. (Unless you use LNG buses.)
- jonpeda 14y agoI like how you immediately contradicted your conclusion with the obvious counterexample.
- ars 14y agoI like to be honest. But LNG buses are just not common enough, they apparently cost more than diesel ones so municipalities don't buy them.
- khuey 14y agoOn a per-person-moved basis? I'm going to call [citation needed] on that.
- saosebastiao 14y agoThis hasn't been true for almost a decade now...and even before then, all it took was a few cars (3-4) taken off the road for the bus to come out ahead.
- agscala 14y agoWhat are you talking about? The idea is to reduce the total number of cars by getting everyone using public transit. One bus might make twice as much soot as a car, but the bus can bring a lot more than two cars off the road if people ride the bus.
- ars 14y agoBuses make about 150 to 250 times as much soot. Not twice as much. Old buses granted. Newer ones are much better.
- saosebastiao 14y agoHave you been reading research papers from the 1950's? If you get on any bus anywhere in the US, you are virtually guaranteed that the bus is less than 10 years old. The average replacement time for Municipal buses is 7 years...10 years with complete engine replacement.
- ars 14y agoI was driving behind a bus in the US just last week - every time the bus accelerated a huge cloud of black smoke poured out of it. Yes, new buses are good. But there are still plenty of old ones. (And this one didn't look old.)
- saosebastiao 14y agoAh yes, we should go ahead with a ban on public transportation due to a fucking anecdote. You and my former boss would get along quite well.
- meh01 14y agoWelcome to HN. Where we state opinions as fact and anecdotes as truth, usually with some hand wavey out in case we're called on BS. :)
- ars 14y agoI guess you are not as secure in your beliefs as you thought if you need to resort to swearing. You thought buses are modern and clean, and when you discover different you swear? Diesel is very polluting compared to gasoline and I hate it. And stop/start diesel is the worst. So despite its great reputation public buses are not the automatic win they are made out to be.
- saosebastiao 14y agoThey aren't beliefs. And yes, I have a tendency to curse when people advocate for very stupid policies using ideas that can be refuted in less than 5 minutes on Google.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoBeijing is quickly moving to battery-drawn electric buses (not to mention traditional electric trolley buses). LNG is another solution, but for some reason, electric is catching on here (maybe b/c a lack of natural gas when compared to the states?)